Definitely for, provided you use what you kill.
Grew up in farm country. We were allowed to shoot as many deer as we wanted a year if they were destroying crops. My family (whole family, uncles, cousins, etc.) probably killed (and ate) 20-25 deer a year. Also hunted squirrels, dove, rabbits, pheasant, but always ate what we killed. If deer went unhunted where I'm from (rural PA), they would become a nuisance very quickly.
*I have been known to shoot a squirrel with a high-powered rifle when I get really bored during deer season. They're tree rats, who gives a chit.
Haven't hunted since I left that area, but if I moved back, I'd dust off the .270 and mow some more bambis down.