Nice work, Mr Bush

[Martlet]

Originally posted by Fishu

Martlet,

Except not all of them are terrorists, most I suppose.. but not all.
Must be fun spending 2 years under worse conditions than a prison, for no reason...

Really?  Which ones aren't terrorists?

[Virage]

[Fishu]

Originally posted by Martlet
Really?  Which ones aren't terrorists?

Have you missed the news?  some prisoners have been released from guantamo.

[vorticon]

held at Cuba, in US custody

[Martlet]

Originally posted by Fishu
Have you missed the news?  some prisoners have been released from guantamo.

So?  That doesn't mean they weren't involved with or defending terrorists.

Tim McCamey  was released from jail, but he's still a sex offender.

[FUNKED1]

You're right, Crabofix, it's wrong for these terrorists to be held in Cuba.  The soldiers who captured them should have given them the traditional military treatment for combatants who masquerade as civilians - a bullet in the head.

[FUNKED1]

Originally posted by crabofix
Mr Bush will be brought to Haag when his term has ended.

ROFL, he will be in Texas.

[Duedel]

Originally posted by Martlet
Really?  Which ones aren't terrorists?

Do u really think that a kid can accountable decide that he wants to be a terrorist?
Do u really think a 13 year old kid should be put into "prison" instead of giving him psycholigical help and showing him that the evil american isnt so evil as hes been told?

[Arlo]

All teenage terrorists should be sent to Germany as exchange students.

[lazs2]

so thats what happened to duedal... he was captured by Americans and held for many years for no reason.

if only we had be kind to him and shown him that America is a nice place with decent folks.... oh well... too late now I guess.

lazs

[Yeager]

Dowding, Im not in guantamo and Im guessing you arent either.  
As such, it would be hard for me or you (or anyone not directly involved) to say with any level of accuracy that the young people subject to this thread should or should not be held there.

But heres the rub.  If in fact there are young teenagers being held in guantamo then I am going to believe that it is justified as I would prefer to default in favor of my nation during war then against it.  Sorry, just the way I believe.

[Maniac]

This is how you create the next generation of Osama Bin Ladinīs

[Saurdaukar]

So in short:

A decision was made by those with first hand information regarding these two detainee's which resulted in their invitation to stay at a maximum security resort in Cuba.

Yet some of you, who dont even know their names, let alone why they are being held, feel that its wrong - entirely based upon their age - and not their actions of which you are clueless.

Is this correct?

[Martlet]

Originally posted by Duedel
Do u really think that a kid can accountable decide that he wants to be a terrorist?
Do u really think a 13 year old kid should be put into "prison" instead of giving him psycholigical help and showing him that the evil american isnt so evil as hes been told?

It completely depends on what the kid did.  

Since you seem to know so much about it, why don't you tell me where the teens were captured, and what activities they were engaged in that resulted in their capture.

[Arlo]

Originally posted by Maniac
This is how you create the next generation of Osama Bin Ladinīs

Versus the Timothy McVeighs and Terry Nichols of the world? Neh ... I don't buy it. When someone either gets it in their head or lets it be put in their head that terrorism is a justifiable act then they don't deserve a "get out of jail free" card when they're captured in the act or supporting it. Even juvies here in the states are locked up when they commit violent crimes.