Originally posted by AKcurly
There is no such thing as a private bar or restaurant unless it is operated in someones home.
Bars/restaurants avail themselves of roads, garbage disposal, mail delivery, power and police services, all made available (at least initially) by good old John Q. Public.
John Q has every right to decide on matters which affect him.
Decisions made by the majority with builtin protection for the minorities. That's the way it works.
curly
Please explain the difference between your definitions of public and private then. Mine is simple -- if it's paid for by public money, it is public. If it's paid for by private money, it's private.
"Bars/restaurants avail themselves of roads, garbage disposal, mail delivery, power and police services, all made available (at least initially) by good old John Q. Public."
By that definition, every house in a city is also public. My house is connected to public roads, makes use of public garbage disposal (incidentally, most businesses have private trash disposal companies), my house has a private mailbox, and uses semi-public power and public police services. You don't propose to legislate against smoking there, do you?
Your definition makes no sense.