Cleverness does not excuse lack of engaging dialogue or character development, or any semblence to a plot (other than "Chick gets pissed, gets sword, kills everyone. Fadeout".). As a tribute I felt the movie would have been better had QT been subtle with it (such as when XXXXXX makes the comment about being a square, and then draws half a square with her other hand, a subtle throw back to PF).
This was just too over the top for me. I am glad some found it highly entertaining, and I did like a lot of the cinematography, it just seems to me that QT is too focused on getting the point of his "This is cool, isn't it?" vibe all through the movie.
I don't know, I'll probably watch in again in 6 months and declare it the best movie EV4R.