I find it quite good.
I always found online RPG boring because the player doesn't have to have any skill...everything happens with the 'skillz' of the character.
Here, at least during cannon fights, you have to sail the boat, try to stay upwind, aim and fire etc...Agreed it's extremely simplified but it allows you to take on a much bigger NPC ship if you know what you're doing.
OTOH, sword fights are pretty lame and must be completely re-thought IMO.
Another downside is the lack of online players...4-10 players online at the same time. I've maybe seen a PC ship twice.
My handle is DeMalte. I'm french in-game (to please Saw

). I'm not an intensive player because I only play it when I feel a AH burnout coming.
Yell if you see me online,
...err I mean