I think it is worthy especially in the "Any personal attacks." realm. There is no need for it.
I also think restricting the "A whine, not a suggest ,critisim or view, but the over the top stuff." is a good idea, mostly because this stuff really sets me off lolh.
This one "Any flame of some ones post, not a counter discusion, but a flame. Also flame baits. " is interesting and a grey area I would like to see where you draw the line.
Thumbs up from me, although it should only be trial and the BB community should have a vote as a whole on weather it becomes permanent or not.