It appears that we get 25 players, 11 O, 11 D, and 3 special. Therefore I pick the following.
Jim Brown RB-KR Also an awesome blocker, he can also punt and kick off.
Walter Payton RB-KR-Receiver also awesome blocking back, and backup QB.
Jerry Rice WR One just can't leave the all time all timer off any list.
Don Hutson WR Maybe one of the top 5 players of all time period.
Joe Montana QB Just barely beats out Johnny U as the best overall QB ever. Possably also in the top five all time players.
Mike Webster C With all due respect for Donaldson.
John Hannah OG
Gene Upshaw OG My choice for guards I would not argue any of three other picks however.
Big Jim Parker OT
Anthony Munoz OT These two guys are the consensus expert all time greats couple of others would get no argument from me.
Lou Groza OT Oh and he place kicks as a sideline.

Kellen Winslow TE If one never saw him play one has missed a rare treat.
Randy Cross C-OG-OT got to have a backup and this man will not give much of a drop off at any position.
Bob Lilly DT
Joe Greene DT
Gino Marchetti DE
Deacon Jones DE These 4 or any of about 6 others.
Ray Nitschke ILB
Dick Butkus ILB
Lawrence Taylor OLB This group give me the latitude to play either a 3 or 4 man front with Tunnell
Dick "Night Train" Lane CB-KR.
Ronnie Lott CB-Safety These two are a must, Nuff said
Paul Krause Safety Only the all time interception leader.
Emlen Tunnell CB-LB-Safety-KR-PR Emlen the Gremlin, he was labeled "offense on defense," a moniker he justified with 4,706 combined career yards on interception runbacks, punt returns, and kickoff returns. Oh and he is second in interceptions only to Krause.
Jim Thorpe K-P-RB-KR-PR-QB-Receiver-DB To leave this man off would be an injustice.
Lombardi