Hmmm.... I seem to remember me and Popeye encountering a pair of La5's coalt at about 25k over f14 a couple of weeks ago. Me in a Pony, Pops in a Spitfire I think.
In fact this was the exact encounter I was thinking of when I wrote my above post.
<shrugs> Maybe we just got lucky.
And I always am a proponent of doing whatever works for you, and your own tactics.
But in this particular encounter, we went "loose duece" splitting apart at the merge and the La5's went tight cover.
If I remember correctly they went for me first, and then we had them bracketed front rear. And even the plane (me initially) that the La5's were attacking could use standard merge , nose to nose, 1 v 1 tactics.
Basically it was fairly easy to dodge both planes because they were so close to one another. Whatever "dodge" manuever worked on one, worked on the other because the second pilot didn't have any more seperation or reaction time.
Then we went into iterations of switching off and going for the "cover man" of the La5 pair. Because the cover man was so tight, he would have to give one of us a shot at his open six, while he was following the lead plane on his attacks.
It was on the second or third "merge" that we finally got the cover man La5, and it was fairly simple 2 v 1 after that.
Just one encounter
and its not definitive proof of either concept. Just saying that in my years of flying, I find the close wing tactics way too restrictive, and a good pilot can use them against you.
Just my opinon and style, if something else works for you, I say use it.
------------------
Vermillion
**MOL**, Men of Leisure,
"Real Men fly Radials, Nancy Boys fly Spitfires"