Originally posted by NUKE
A guy like Pat Tillman would probably not want to make a big deal out of this if he were still around.
No NUKE, you don't want anyone to make a big deal out of this and persuant to that agenda you are trying to ascribe your motivations and desires to a dead hero. If you are so comfortable about knowing what Pat Tillman would or would not want, why don't you phone his parents and tell them what they are doing is wrong because you know thier son so much better than they do.
I just have a great deal of respect for anyone who serves our country and it makes me upset to see Pat Tillman's name being thrown around like it has.
What incredible hypocracy.
That being said, it sounds to me like their was an attempt at a cover-up. I don't know how high it went, but it wouldn't surprise me if it went little higher than his unit, at best they certainly did take part in it. And I think I could understand why. I'm guessing a combination of trying to protect Pat's legacy and fear of someone going down in history as the guy that killed one of the most famous Americans to fight in the Afghan War. However, regardless of the form his death did take it does not detract on iota from the nobility of his decision to fight for his country in the first place.
As far as any failures in US Army regarding this incident. There is only one if the coverup was farther reaching than we know. And we just don't know at this point in time. Still, they proably shouldn't have "sold" the story of how Pat Tillman died until it had been properly vetted. Because if they are wrong it's just going to end up bitting them in the ass, much like it is now.