Originally posted by AdmRose
WWI would make an excellent movie. Haven't seen a good WWI movie since The Lost Batallion.
Hi AdmRose,
At one time I too was hoping for more WW1 themed movies, being a huge fan of both versions of "All Quiet on the Western Front," "Sgt. York," and even "The Razors Edge" (which actually has more to do with the enui of the post-war generation) and the war poets (Blunden, Owen, Sassoon, Graves, Rosenberg, etc.).
But the problem with WW1 is that unless you focus on the last few months of 1918 and the German collapse, all you have is mud, and despair and sacrifice that achieves little or nothing. Any movie therefore ends up being either a desperate struggle for survival or inevitably falls into the anti-war war flick, and only the best of directors are going to be able to do this without making it 2 hours of patently obvious bludgeoning about the evils of our own time.
For an example of what I mean (actually done better than most modern directors would probably do) pick up Kubrick's "Paths of Glory" some time.
- SEAGOON