The quality of the first photo is dark and bleeding colors, as many war time photos did. There are many photos where dark colors "glow" larger than the actual element. This can easily explain the eyes. The look different but only because people are examining the seeping pigment on the photo, not the general picture the pigment represents.
The light scarf is not 'washed out' glowing... The dark scarf is not light with color bleeding.
If you look at the images carefully, you will see more obvious differences. One has a 'thumbs up' the other an open hand. I told you already the about the eyes, one has light pupils the other has none. Look at the buttons on the waist, one has a solid dark button, the over just an outlined circle. Look at the feet, th enose etc...
I think its fair to say that Kjetil is far more the 'expert' then you in these matters.