Hey Ripsnort:
"Morning Angus!
The smaller the trout, the better tasting in my opinion. Ours avg. about 12-16" in length. You're right about the muddy taste, and that is more common in the summer months in warmer lakes than it is the trout that come from our rivers. River trout is ohhhhhh soooooooo delicious!"
12 to 16 inches, that would be very nice and rather similar to what I know.
We have 2 base species up here in Iceland, one is a predator, the other and tastier, is a vegetarian with incredible survivability in muddy water.
I only fished those in a lake with very clean water and not much mud. The lake is overpopulated so the fish is a tad small. But tasty ohhh.
It's basically riverfish, - a little river or stream runs through the lake which is a part of a chain of lakes.
The people who live there use to simply boil the best of them in saltwater. Gut them, clean them, cut into slabs and boil for some 5-10 minutes, eat with butter, salt and potatoes.
The less attractive fish (We fished a lot in nets we layed down into the lake, - sometimes we had like 100 of them after the night) was gutted, cleaned, skinned, and made into fillets which we smoked. Perfect for yer bread.
The least attractive ones were done for mince-fish. Use them in a recipe like meatballs (wheat, spice, eggs, oil, minced fish, mix and fry on a pan) except it's fish. Was quite good actually!
The rest of the rest went to the cats and the dogs.