just to say a few things....
we have been through this before, I'm sure Skuzzy remembers. IIRC there was a point in time that i think we DID have "the board with the most boobies", and it actually did get so out of control I am thoroughly impressed Dale, Roy, and Doug didn't have a brain aneurysm. Heck I was one of the offenders back then... and someone who got funny looks if someone saw it at work. Back then I believe it was just to see how far we could all go, and some crossed the line and were "punished" for it.
Over the 4+ years I have been around this forum alot has changed. I remember the day avatars were enabled, it was totally foreign to me. Anyway in that time the "personality" of the board has changed alot as well. If I were to have to put a finger on it I would say the board has become more like a high school. There are clicks, there are jocks, there are nerds, and every other group you can think of. They all also seem to act like high schoolers (myself included). I don't have a reason why, or an answer to anything, I just wanted to make that observation.
As to the current state of avatar affairs, I agree with what someone said already. I identify some people's posts by their avatars. When I want to see what Hitech said in a 5 page thread I scroll through quite fast just looking for "I Coad". I think they are a useful thing in quickly identifying someone. I hope they stay.