I read and I ponder upon the doubts vetilated on those boards, adn I find that all of them have been up for discussion over at the WWIIOL boards many many times, and CRS have been explaining to us many many times the way those issues are going to (supposedly) be handled.
Altough a community naturally reacts in a hostile way to an external threat which can potentially wipe out the own community, many of your concerns are not viable, while some concerns are VERY valid.
I found myself doubting the player base would be large enough, but then I time after time are boggled by the interest shown for a game not even out yet...
So if WWIIOL delivers the nessecary player base WILL be there, I'm more or less positive of this.
As for the 'cheerleading' and overly confidence shown by many 'fans' of WWIIOL, that is a natural stance when looking forward to something that promises to be THE game one has been waiting for the last 15 years...but don't think there are no 'internal critique' in the WWIIOL community, because there sure is.
But also, we are idiots no more than anyone else, and we know that WWIIOL might be a flop and blah blah we know all that. Its all about which stance you decide to take on the game; I've decided to take the optimistic stance, so what?
And for the remark about 'General wannabes, especially on the German side', what is wrong with that? I think everyone had a dream as a kid to be a great general one time or another, and now we have the chance to realize that dream
Its not like we become real generals under whose command REAL people are killed. This is a GAME gentlemen.
thanks