Originally posted by SteveBailey
I do have on old version of XP... but have SP 2 and it is fully updated. I'm really scratching my head here. Thanks for all your help and time.
Here is the issue. The original releases of XP had borked up the 48 bit LBA support (one of the many reasons to never be on the bleeding edge, stuff is borked). If you are unlucky enough to be stuck with an old version, even with the installation of SP2, XP will not allow you to get past 138GB per volume.
You can force it, but MS pretty much gaurantees you will have corrupt data if you do. I have tested this and sure enough, you get corrupted data.
You actually need a copy of XP that already has SP2 installed. While there are earlier versions of XP which work, the best cut-off I have been able to find is using a copy od XP with SP2 installed already.
EDIT: By the way, there are utlities out there, like Seagate's format and partioning program, which will automatically make the patches to the Windows registry to enable the 48 bit LBA support. While that soulnds good, these programs do not actually test and verify it will work correctly.