Originally posted by Citabria 
I give them an actual critique. 
 No kidding...I can appreciate the effort it takes to get even the simplest of skins submitted.  But let's be honest, there are a lot of skins in the game currently that are sub-par at best, and only exist because there was a gap in the skin que for that aircraft.
Jeepin's work here is a promising good start.  Fester's just trying to actually give some honest and constructive feedback.