Running off and landing intact except for some minor damage(engine out, fuel leak, winchester, etc), while denying a kill to someone, I'm absolutely in favor of. Having your plane blown to pieces and getting a ditch because the code looks at your speed when you break the ground plane, and your proximity to a field when your speed reaches 0, I'm against.
You are more concerned with not being killed, while I'm more concerned with killing. We're on different sides of the fence here, and I see why you're opposed to this. That's fine too, but quit trying to tell me I'm wrong.