Originally posted by AKIron
Only if we pull out and let Iran/Taliban/Religious Zealots take over. We're still in Germay and South Korea and it's relatively painless. Iraq is growing less painless. Pulling out of South Vietnam was painless neither for us nor the millions murdered in the region as a result.
er, Iraq is growing less painful
never mix whiskey and rum, unless you run out of whiskey
Unfortunately, there is a world of difference, between Iraq, and the situation in Germany/South Korea.
The situation in Germany/R.O.K. stemmed' from having hostile OUTSIDE neighbors, who were driven and equipped by our chief nemesis during the cold war-the U.S.S.R.
Iraq is a country that we recently invaded, and overthrew the government of. A Non-extremist, albeit ruthless and dictatorial one.
In Germany/R.O.K., The U.S. could probably leave tomorrow, letting those countries' look after themselves. Germany would probably be ok. The R.O.K. Still faces' a hardline communist regime, that could possibly be backed up by the new Communist superpower-China-and they more than likely still want the help of the U.S. To deter any possible aggression from their northern cousins.
But such is not the case with Iraq.
It faces more insurgency. It has to cope with the fact that very few other nations' in the area, have a non-theology based form of Gov't. And that is what these people...well, seem to cherish.
We'll be there forever, propping up a pro-western gov't. I don't see any way that any gov't. we install, will stand up on it's own, without a significant U.S. presence. All it will take is a coup, as soon as the U.S. force levels' are down low enough. It would be 1979 all over again.