Basically no one is right and no one is wrong in this debate. IMO it amounts to personal preference.
My "Personal Preference" would be to have the "Keylar Body Armor" removed from the BUFF gunners. Especially, the bombadier who never has to worry about dying or a shot up bombsight.
On the subject for BUFF's being too easy to shoot down and being attacked by a single fighter. Well for me it is about 65/35/50 + 25/25.
65% - The BUFF gets the victory for the kill
35% - Mino gets the victory for the kill
50% - The BUFF'er and myself both ride the silk
25% - The BUFF'er rides off into the sunset
25% - Mino rides off into the sunset
The numbers change from fighter to fighter. Pick your cannon wisely.
------------------
Mino
The Wrecking Crew