Its not that hard to see his question was a spin to try and get a flame war going akak. Maybe you should read the posts again.
This was jaeger's post.
"i find it enhances the game and it keeps the fight below 3k. works for me. just my 2 cents"
Now this was BnZs' post.
"Query: Why should the fights be kept below 3K in an arena that is is supposed to be more historically accurate?"
Now jaeger said nothing about how fights SHOULD be kept under 3k. He said that puff ack from the CVs tend to keep people below 3k. From jaeger's post it seems that he didn't mind it and you could even say he enjoyed it. Now BnZs comes in and posts a random question wording it like jaeger said the fights should be kept under 3k. Which, if anyone took the bait would have started another 'you cant tell me how to fly' thread and put all the work some people have been doing to try and get numbers into the AvA.
Its obvious to see what was happening because its happened so many times before. The AvA starts seeing numbers and people start putting the past behind them, then someone comes in and stirs the pot and it all goes down the drain.
So akak you want a valid answer to his question? Well you're right I don't have an answer, because its not a valid question.