There's nothing wrong with the high end bows. But they absolutely will not make a new shooter instantly successful. What they'll do is make him instantly broke. Spend $800+ on just a bow, and then you don't have money for a good rest, a good sight, a good release, a good quiver, a dozen or more good arrows, or field points, broadheads, and targets. Buy a $400-$500 PSE package, and you have a rock solid bow you can start with, and money left to buy plenty of arrows, field points, and targets. To kill a deer within 40 yards or so, you don't need a $1K bow. But you do need to be able to accurately estimate distance, and shoot a 4" or so 5 shot group consistently. It requires practice, lots of practice, and then lots more practice.