Do I really hafta be the first to say it? Save your money and get CH gear!
Seriously though, ive never used any logitech gear but ive always heard they have the tendacy to be flakey.
My first stick was a MS sidewinder FF2, great stick. Still have it, not entirely sure if it still works and im not sure what they run on ebay nowadays.
My first saitek stick was a cyborg something something. Then I upgraded to the X45 when it was relatively new, alot of folks disliked the rocker rudder but I didnt find it too bad.
After the X45 I had an X52, then moved on to the X52 pro. Both X52s are twisty sticks, not sure what they run for now either. But overall the saiteks are good sticks for the price, my only gripe with the saiteks are the hat switches tend to go wonky after short periods and they tend to have some play in the stick as well.
Now I have all CH gear, but before the CH gear I laid down a substanial amount of cash for the cougar HOTAS (which a squaddie of mine - silat, said NOT to get. But what does he know right?
)
Once I got the cougar, I hated it. All kinds of problems with the hats, which you have to mod with aftermarket pots to get the hats to work the way they should have right outta the box.
Good luck with whatever stick you get. YMMV.