It shouldn't matter who created the skin, who cares if a newb made it, what matters is who's skin is most accurate, that is what should matter. Just because it is a persons first try, just because someone a rep as a good skinner, if the newb's skin is better then let the newb get the post. I haven't even tried to skin a plane but if/when I do just because it is my first try that should disqualify it? Just doesn't seem right to me.