Butcher ... the obvious weak link in that list is that "Snailman" guy ... even if you wet that paper bag, he could fight his way out. Choose him for sure.
Just thought of something, what if we had a dog fighters tournament broken down into 3 Brackets, expert bracket would obviously be the top 12 pilots hand picked by the pilots themselves, 24 pilots would be in a Intermediate bracket (or enough to fill it up) where every tour 2 pilots from the Intermediate go up, and a beginners bracket for anyone not named in the top 2 brackets.
I would be interested to set this up if anyone wanted to take it serious enough.