Evaluating fighters ENY by comparing them 1vs1 ?

[save]

How would you list look from top to bottom, and why ?.

[Karnak]

I am sorry to say, but that is a very, very subjective question and I doubt any two people here would agree with each other.  Heck, have me write out my list now and then again next week and the two lists, both mine, won't agree with each other.

[Butcher]

I am sorry to say, but that is a very, very subjective question and I doubt any two people here would agree with each other.  Heck, have me write out my list now and then again next week and the two lists, both mine, won't agree with each other.

I would certainly write a list now and change it in a week, I could write my own ENY list - however I can already see the trolling/flaming that would come out of it.

I've been in favor of upping the ENY value total from 40 to 60, (my opinion now) and the reason for it is to reward players who fly older rides rather then newer. However over the years with the different ENY system, pretty sure lusche can point out not much would change - 51 would be a prefered ride, along with spit 16 etc.

However for the past year, even missing over 3+ months of flying I still have 10k perks in fighters, I don't see any real reason to change the ENY system.