On the AR15 note......Bushmasters got the crap label because they ran a batch where they didnt stake the gas keys of the bolt carrier groups and they sheered off. They also didnt stake the castle nuts for awhile and they backed out. One more hit they take is they are not 100% milspec so the professionals or want to be pros crap on them.
As a matter of opinion of course.....and from what I've learned over time ( popcorn ready)
Ar15s per "serious" end users
Tier 1A (milspec and better)
Noveske
Larue Tactical
Tier 1 (per military spec ( US Technical Data Pack/ M4 Carbine) , Full Auto Bolt carrier group, documented magnetic particle tested and high pressure tested, 4150CMV chromlined milspec steel barrels hp and mp tested and marked level 3 anodizing,Heavy carbine buffer or H2 buffer standard etc. etc. )
Colt, Daniel Defense, Bravo Company Manufacturing, Lewis Machine and Tool, CMT ( STAG ) with "plus pack" etc.
Tier 2 ( partial military spec, some commercial grade ( 4140 steel barrels semi/auto carriers,carbine buffers/larger than normal gas ports (overgassed) to run .223, non milspec processes ( melonite/ferritic nitrocarbonized barrels etc.) but proper QC ( MP tested bolts, properly staked gas keys/castlenuts )
Smith and Wesson
( Smith suffered early critisim for sourcing parts from all over and having out of spec magwells. Their QC tightened up as they moved forging and machining capability in house. Also they aquired Thompson Center to manufacture in house barrels)
Tier 3 Commerical grade with some milspec parts but serious past or present QC issues and questionable/non exsistent testing procedures.
Rock River arms, Bushmaster, DPMS,Armalite
Go over to M4 Carbine.net if you want to see some fun forum fireworks discussing the quality of AR15 rifles. Those guys over there run the forum with an Iron fist LOL
I own a muscled up Smith ( quick pics ).



Any whoo to the OP good luck in your search for your next 1911. If I had the cash I'd go Colt. Actually if I had the cash I'd go Nighthawk........

For a field gun I personally carry a Glock 21. Not beautiful (its pretty in its own Austrian " but her face" kind of way) like a 1911 but the damn thing goes bang every time.