TC, with all due respect I think that would be overkill in this question. That old HP would die sooner or later anyway, so anything that will get it up and running should do. I got the expression that it's not the main gaming rig.
However, puller, if I'm wrong and you'd like to beef it up for playing AH3 for some years, please send more details.
Edit: All PSU's I've seen blow air/heat out the back, no matter where the fan is. The only difference is that the older design made negative pressure inside the PSU by drawing air through it, the new design blows air into the PSU from the inside of the case. Or from the bottom of the case where the PSU is in the bottom. The latter will keep the PSU cooler since it gets fresh air under the computer. It's also more prone to get clogged by dust.