I actually like that model. I like how players have to freedom to setup their own servers
Good point. I guess for me, it seemed too haphazard, not knowing which servers would be open, which would operate OK, etc.
Dang dude. I was still occasionally getting on full BF4 servers not too long ago and that was released what 2015?
How long do you think you should be able to play a single MMO release? You ought to get out more. 
I hear you. I would still play BF 1942 if it weren't basically abandonware. It was so much fun (except for the planes, which I felt ruined the game play). But there were bugs, exploits (I had some 3rd party anti-cheating thing that cooperated with the game -- forget what it was called -- but that sort of thing should have been part of the game). Bugs never got fixed, as the company just moved on to the next thing, and eventually the game dies out.
I'd prefer BF 1942 v1, v2, . . .instead of BF 1942, then they abandon it and move on to a series of (from my perspective) inferior pieces of crap in comparison.
For example, if Aces High were shinkwrap, and HTC had WWII for a while, then abandoned it for Korea, then some years later abandon it for Vietnam, then Tomcats, then F-35's, then space madness or whatever crap -- when WWII is the golden age of air combat -- I wouldn't prefer that.