Author Topic: Current radar settings  (Read 1204 times)

Offline thndregg

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 4149
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #45 on: Today at 08:19:15 AM »
All I know is..  while I was spacing out while there was an enemy darbar in the sector with me deep into and high above Rookland, I was suddenly jolted out of my daydreaming by the sounds of 50 cal. working my B29's all over at 30+K. Looking out front, and not behind me, no pinpoint contact on the map.

Checked my six. There was Skishill in his jug, parked right on my a**, ventilating my lead plane from wingtip to wing tip.. POOF!  :D

I had it coming. He earned it. :airplane: Head on a swivel, people.. head on a swivel.

Good change back to something we had ages ago, HiTech..  :cool: I like it.
Skeleton Crew is **Selectively Recruiting** B29 Bomber Crews. Contact: thndrEGG-CO or MATAHARI-XO in game via PM.

Offline LilMak

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1650
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #46 on: Today at 11:17:33 AM »
I thought it was supposed to be modelling the Observers and Sentries normal at every military base.

Those guys had binoculars and were equipped with mechanical sighting instruments that could provide the position of the aircraft with map grid coordinates, height, time, and number of aircraft for each sighting. They were well trained and highly skilled, lives depended on them so they were alert! They never texted their wives :rofl

Icon range is intended to be the distance at which a visual observer could identify the aircraft type using the unaided Mk1 eyeball. In reality observers were able to spot and warn of approaching enemy well before dot range so that is already a compromise.

A base command remaining unaware of an attack until icon range would have about a three second warning or less before bombs were falling... They would have been issuing court marshals.

MoL
All cool I guess. But what is being seen is driven by the pilot. Not guys on the ground with binoculars. Why would canopy frames, wings, clouds, all block “seen contacts”? There is zero possibility that a pilot could identify friendly from enemy at over seven miles. ZERO. Now the game clipboard might help with that because friendlies are painted on it 100% of the time at any distance. But that doesn’t excuse the same thing for enemy equipment.

At 7.5 miles every plane and GV if essentially a radar tower that is 3/4 the size of the actual radar circle for “seen contacts”. There appears to be no delay in how quickly a “seen contact” manifests. So I can literally run a 360 on my hat switch in less than a second and paint everything I can “see” on the clipboard for 20 seconds over 56 square miles from the dirt to 40000ft.

Mol. Essentially what you’re trying to sell me is that you can go outside, do a Wonder Woman spin, and plot exactly where every airplane in the sky is on a piece of paper from the surface to 40000ft. Not only that, but you can tell me which ones are Gulfstreams and which are 737 and which are Delta, American, or Southwest.

I know we’re playing a game and there are concessions. But this game is also supposed grounded somewhat in reality. I’m suspending my take on reality if we can drawn in “seen contacts” to 3.4 miles (icon range). Then I accept all the Wonder Woman spin plotting.

My reasoning is simple. For every additional mile you can “see”, the square miles your field of view covers is tripled.
"When caught by the enemy in large force the best policy is to fight like hell until you can decide what to do next."
~Hub Zemke
P-47 pilot 56th Fighter Group.

Offline Dadtallica

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2659
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #47 on: Today at 11:24:04 AM »
Dude just quit already. Good grief!
My Videos @NightspanNavigatorProductions

Back in 2022 after a loooooong break from 2010. Old name Ratpack, same for the BBS. Old squads, Excaliburs, 172nd Rabid Dawgs.

Offline LilMak

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1650
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #48 on: Today at 11:28:44 AM »
Dude just quit already. Good grief!
No.
"When caught by the enemy in large force the best policy is to fight like hell until you can decide what to do next."
~Hub Zemke
P-47 pilot 56th Fighter Group.

Offline hazmatt

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2608
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #49 on: Today at 11:51:08 AM »
Dude just quit already. Good grief!

There's a way to get the numbers up!

Curious if you treat new players the same...

Offline Dadtallica

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2659
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #50 on: Today at 12:17:43 PM »
There's a way to get the numbers up!

Curious if you treat new players the same...

lol easy troll… you do nothing here but talk about “the game you play” while I and others actively promote this one daily… for free!

With all the time you spend here there is absolutely no reason for not playing other than spite.

Mak isn’t new here and even if he was and spent 18 pages going on and on and on about a radar perfectly subjective to him then I would also tell the new guy to take down a step.

It’s getting to the point where it’s just over the top.

I won’t be responding to whatever silliness you come back with. Go play “your game” and have a nice day.
My Videos @NightspanNavigatorProductions

Back in 2022 after a loooooong break from 2010. Old name Ratpack, same for the BBS. Old squads, Excaliburs, 172nd Rabid Dawgs.

Offline Mol

  • Zinc Member
  • *
  • Posts: 27
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #51 on: Today at 03:29:17 PM »
All cool I guess. But what is being seen is driven by the pilot. Not guys on the ground with binoculars.

No, it is also being driven by guys on the ground in the tower, as stated here:

A contact is "seen" when any friendly player sees it:
- That friendly can be in flight or in the tower
- Seen range is out to dot range, about 7.5 miles in the MA.

So the real question is could someone in the tower see an aircraft at 7.5 miles.

Anyone on the ground looking for enemy aircraft would almost certainly be a lookout and thus using binoculars so the question is easy to answer using wartime sources.

The most useful source is the US Navy's Lookout Manual, published in 1943, which provides specific figures for the detection of aircraft both with the naked eye and using binoculars.

On page 33, the manual states:

Quote
A good lookout can sight planes at 6,000 yards with his naked eye, and at two or three times that range with binoculars.

Converting those distances into statute miles gives:

Naked eye: 3.4 miles

Binoculars: between 6.8 and 10.2 miles


This is particularly interesting because the 3.4 mile icon limit corresponds almost exactly to the US Navy's figure for naked-eye detection. However, the same wartime manual explicitly states that using binoculars extends the detection range to as much as three times that distance at 10.2 miles, significantly farther than the current dot setting.

If you take the average value using binoculars it is 8.5 miles so the existing 7.5 mile dot range is already conservative.

Naturally, detection distances would vary with visibility, atmospheric conditions, aircraft size, aspect, background and the observer's ability.

Nevertheless, the historical evidence establishes that trained wartime observers equipped with binoculars could sight aircraft considerably farther away than 7.5 miles and as far as 10.2 miles.

Then I accept all the Wonder Woman spin plotting.
My reasoning is simple. For every additional mile you can “see”, the square miles your field of view covers is tripled.

Sorry, it just looks to me as if your reference to square miles and wonder woman are both entirely irrelevant and don't even make any sense.

However, using wartime sources:

In view of the 10.2 mile value, the 7.5-mile detection range is therefore quite reasonable. In fact, it falls towards the lower end of the 6.8–10.2-mile range given in the 1943 US Navy manual.

This provides strong historical support for 7.5 miles as an already conservative range for a lookout in the tower.

Later evidence based on visibility trials suggests bombers could be seen with the naked eye as far away as 15 miles.

MoL
Man of Leisure (MoL)

Offline LilMak

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1650
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #52 on: Today at 04:19:03 PM »
No, it is also being driven by guys on the ground in the tower, as stated here:

So the real question is could someone in the tower see an aircraft at 7.5 miles.
 :banana:
Anyone on the ground looking for enemy aircraft would almost certainly be a lookout and thus using binoculars so the question is easy to answer using wartime sources.

The most useful source is the US Navy's Lookout Manual, published in 1943, which provides specific figures for the detection of aircraft both with the naked eye and using binoculars.

On page 33, the manual states:

Converting those distances into statute miles gives:

Naked eye: 3.4 miles

Binoculars: between 6.8 and 10.2 miles


This is particularly interesting because the 3.4 mile icon limit corresponds almost exactly to the US Navy's figure for naked-eye detection. However, the same wartime manual explicitly states that using binoculars extends the detection range to as much as three times that distance at 10.2 miles, significantly farther than the current dot setting.

If you take the average value using binoculars it is 8.5 miles so the existing 7.5 mile dot range is already conservative.

Naturally, detection distances would vary with visibility, atmospheric conditions, aircraft size, aspect, background and the observer's ability.

Nevertheless, the historical evidence establishes that trained wartime observers equipped with binoculars could sight aircraft considerably farther away than 7.5 miles and as far as 10.2 miles.

Sorry, it just looks to me as if your reference to square miles and wonder woman are both entirely irrelevant and don't even make any sense.

However, using wartime sources:

In view of the 10.2 mile value, the 7.5-mile detection range is therefore quite reasonable. In fact, it falls towards the lower end of the 6.8–10.2-mile range given in the 1943 US Navy manual.

This provides strong historical support for 7.5 miles as an already conservative range for a lookout in the tower.

Later evidence based on visibility trials suggests bombers could be seen with the naked eye as far away as 15 miles.

MoL
I concede view from the ground in the tower. I do not concede view from the air.

So pilots in the tower can “see” 7.5 miles. In the sky they can “see” 3.4.

Or…hear me out…since already have a 10 mile radar ring, and pilots don’t fly with binoculars taped to their head, we set it at 3.4 for simplicity.
"When caught by the enemy in large force the best policy is to fight like hell until you can decide what to do next."
~Hub Zemke
P-47 pilot 56th Fighter Group.

Offline popeye

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3857
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #53 on: Today at 04:35:48 PM »
I believe that the "seen distance" applies everywhere -- not just over friendly territory where there could be observers with binoculars.
« Last Edit: Today at 04:37:52 PM by popeye »
KONG

Where is Major Kong?!?

Offline Eagler

  • Radioactive Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 20478
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #54 on: Today at 04:51:09 PM »
Hitech will issue everyone a pair of super binoculars so that this change is then accurate   :banana:  :airplane:  :banana:

Eagler
Intel Core i7-13700KF | GIGABYTE Z790 AORUS Elite AX | 64GB G.Skill DDR5 | 16GB GIGABYTE RTX 4070 Ti Super | 850 watt ps | Pimax Crystal Super | Warthog stick | TM1600 throttle | VKB Mk.V Rudder

Offline Mol

  • Zinc Member
  • *
  • Posts: 27
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #55 on: Today at 06:33:34 PM »
Or…hear me out…since already have a 10 mile radar ring, and pilots don’t fly with binoculars taped to their head, we set it at 3.4 for simplicity.

Nope, the problem isn't that simple at all.

When you think about translating human visual acuity onto a screen in pixels the problems faced by developers is much more difficult. The main problem is great distances and limited screen resolution at different viewing angles. That's why early sim's used to show enemy aircraft magnified to compensate. At typical viewing distances and fields of view, ordinary monitors cannot reproduce the full resolving power of human vision. So there isn't one clean answer, different developers have different solutions and make different compromises, there is no single correct spotting distance that solves it. The reality is that ordinary rendering makes distant aircraft disappear because their dimensions become smaller than individual pixels. The developers therefore introduced special rendering methods to compensate.

So I decided to take a look at what visual distance was being used in other Sim's to model what the eye can really see, for comparison.

DCS is considered to be realistic, and one particularly useful observation on their forums comes from 31 October 2024. A player named YoYo reported testing fighter versus fighter visibility in VR, finding an enemy fighter visible at 27 nautical miles in cloudless weather. That is: 31.1 miles.

In War thunder fighter to fighter visibility is reported up to 20km (12.4 miles) but some players reports show longer ranges are possible. For example in August 2025 a player verified enemy dot visibility against radar distance at 20 km (12.4 miles). Then in January 2026 there was a community report involving larger aircraft visible at 25 km (15.5 miles). Again in January 2026 a player reported a visual spotting test visibility up to 30 km (18.6 miles).

So the evidence shows that other developers have adopted considerably different solutions to the problem of representing human vision on a computer screen.

DCS has reported fighter spotting distances exceeding 30 miles, while War Thunder players have reported visual detection at 12 miles and sometimes considerably farther.

That doesn't prove those distances are realistic, nor does it prove that HTC's shorter ranges are more realistic. It does demonstrate that this is a difficult simulation problem for which developers have adopted different compromises. The reports suggest that HTC may already be using substantially shorter spotting distances than other simulators, potentially making long range visual detection more challenging.

That last sentence bears repeating... HTC are already using significantly lower spotting distances thus already providing a more challenging visual experience.

So simply declaring that pilots didn't carry binoculars and therefore visual detection should stop at 3.4 miles isn't a technical argument for that distance on a computer screen. There needs to be some evidence that it would better reproduce what a real pilot could see. In fact, the evidence shows that other developers have considered much greater spotting distances necessary or acceptable in their simulations.

MoL
« Last Edit: Today at 06:37:36 PM by Mol »
Man of Leisure (MoL)

Offline Dadtallica

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2659
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #56 on: Today at 08:09:46 PM »
It’s plenty real enough!
My Videos @NightspanNavigatorProductions

Back in 2022 after a loooooong break from 2010. Old name Ratpack, same for the BBS. Old squads, Excaliburs, 172nd Rabid Dawgs.