Author Topic: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?  (Read 291 times)

Offline MDStampf93

  • Aces High CM Staff
  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1879
      • https://paa.ge/acecombatant
When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« on: November 13, 2026, 11:54:25 PM »
A Word About FSO, Competition, and Sportsmanship

I'd like to address something that has become increasingly frustrating, and it applies equally to both sides of the arena.

First, let me make something clear: constructive criticism is always welcome. I encourage feedback, and I recognize that not every decision I make as Campaign Manager will be perfect. If something genuinely needs improvement, I want to know about it.

However, there is a significant difference between constructive criticism and complaining simply because a scenario didn't unfold in your favor.

Not every frame is supposed to be an overwhelming victory. Not every aircraft matchup is supposed to favor your side. And not every mission is supposed to be easy.

Operation Venezia's second frame is a perfect example.

The Allies were presented with an advantageous defensive position, and they made excellent use of it. They coordinated, fought hard, and earned their victory.

Meanwhile, despite facing considerable opposition, the Axis managed to destroy approximately 65% of the available ground-target points.

That's not a force that accomplished nothing. That's a force that fought through difficult circumstances and achieved substantial results.

Yet before the scores were even calculated, the complaints had already begun.

When did a difficult fight become something to complain about rather than something to overcome?

Somewhere along the way, it seems we've started confusing competition with the expectation of success.

The entire purpose of FSO is to challenge ourselves. To adapt. To work together. To overcome disadvantages. To experience scenarios that force us to think differently and fight harder.

Sometimes you'll have the advantage. Sometimes your opponent will. Sometimes you'll execute a brilliant plan and still lose.

That's competition.

If every frame were designed to guarantee both sides an easy fight, we'd have no meaningful competition at all.

I spend a considerable amount of my personal time researching, designing, balancing, configuring, and managing these events. I do it because I enjoy creating something worthwhile for this community, and because I want to see FSO continue to succeed.

I'm not asking for praise, and I'm certainly not asking everyone to agree with every decision I make.

But I am asking for a little perspective.

Before declaring a scenario unfair, consider whether your opponent simply performed better. Before criticizing the design, consider what your side accomplished. And before complaining about the difficulty, remember that overcoming difficulty is part of the experience.

If there is a legitimate imbalance, bring it forward. If something didn't work as intended, tell me. I'll examine it, acknowledge mistakes, and make adjustments where necessary.

But losing a battle, suffering heavy casualties, or facing a disadvantage is not, by itself, evidence of poor scenario design.

This applies to Axis and Allies alike. I've seen complaints from both sides, and I'm equally tired of the mentality regardless of who is doing it.

We're a relatively small community, and these events survive because people are willing to invest their time and effort into keeping them going.

Let's not lose sight of why we're here.

Fight hard. Adapt. Take your losses with some dignity. Give your opponents credit when they've earned it. And remember that a victory means considerably more when it wasn't handed to you.

I will continue working to make these events competitive, challenging, and enjoyable.

All I ask in return is that we approach them with the same spirit.

<S>
Rider
FSO Campaign Manager
JG11 'Sonderstaffel'
Aces High 3 content below
https://paa.ge/acecombatant


Offline Molsman

  • Aces High CM Team
  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 6295
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #1 on: November 14, 2026, 01:42:11 AM »
 Very well Said Rider and especially the amount of time we as designers put into making FSO and even the Scenario Team puts in the time and work to make these events stay alive. We also make these events on the limited planes we have and have to use other models to sub for planes that we don’t have. I have also noticed every one likes Air Spawns but they were also limited back in the day and only a few fsos used them back when we had hundreds of players fighting with the 1 life had. We can’t make everyone happy these days so we have to play the best we can and that also falls a lot on the CiCs who come up with their sides attack and defense plans not the Admins we just create and send the objectives out… And take constructive  criticism as a learning tool and to make the events better.

Just my 30 cents worth

Molsman

JG11, DerWanderZirkus, -The Flying Clowns-
              
Wait n Bleed

Offline AKKuya

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3201
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #2 on: November 14, 2026, 07:12:03 AM »
I totally agree 100% with above comments.

Challenge is the essence of competition.  That being said, the romantic part of challenge is taking the underdog position in a fight.  Fighting with your back against the wall gives you the best exhilaration possible.  That's a perspective.  Not all subscribe to that concept.

In a perfect scenario, both sides would be evenly matched in numbers and aircraft, both sides would have equal experience and skill per pilot, and both FSO Orders would be equal in design for offense and defense.  That's not the case.  If so, would that be any fun?

I, myself, prefer being Allied in early war and Axis in late war both as a general pilot and as a CIC.  Those are my favorite challenges.  At the same time, as a bomber pilot, I enjoy the challenge of LW in BoB and 8th AF over Germany 1945. 

Everyone has their individual preferences.

Why do lopsided victories happen?  Three reasons.  One is assigned CIC creates lazy Orders.   It happens.  Two is assigned squad doesn't follow assigned Orders.  This happens also.  The last reason is the most damaging.  One side suffers too many pilots not showing up for a frame.  These reasons have been hashed out over the decades.  Nothing new.

Ultimately, it's the squad COs to help ensure the proper perspective per design and most importantly for speaking out for anything not balanced.  Squad leadership is crucial in making a bad situation into something fun.  In the Arabian Knights, at the beginning of takeoff, someone will say, "We are all gonna die", in a sarcastic quip for positive morale especially when the mission might go sideways. 

Just my to copper coins.
 :salute

Future CEO of Section Eight Society
Rule #1 I make the rules
Rule #2 If in doubt, refer to above rule

Offline JimmyD3

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 5013
      • Gospel Web
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #3 on: November 14, 2026, 09:26:59 AM »
Rider, well said. I don't do FSO much anymore, but I can imagine what  you deal with. As you know we have many of the same issues in the MA.  :rock
Kenai77
CO Sic Puppies MWK
USAF 1971-76

Offline LCADolby

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 7958
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #4 on: November 14, 2026, 11:04:20 AM »
Allied pilots are generally wimps, expect nothing less. :old:
YouTube+Twitch+KICK - 20Dolby10

Offline hazmatt

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2609
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #5 on: November 14, 2026, 03:44:01 PM »
In the Arabian Knights, at the beginning of takeoff, someone will say, "We are all gonna die", in a sarcastic quip for positive morale especially when the mission might go sideways. 

I don't recall if I was flying with the AKs at the time but we were assigned to fly betty bombers and did not have fighter escort. The fighters were free ranging to try to clear the air ahead of us. I swear we flew for an hour to get to the target area. We actually got close enough to the target that we started lining up and calibrating. We got bounced and I don't think a single betty survived long enough to get bombs out.

Nobody cried, that's just the way it goes sometimes in FSO... Sometimes you draw the short straw.

Offline LilMak

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1652
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #6 on: November 14, 2026, 04:52:23 PM »
OK. I complained a lot but it had everything to do with vulching. Axis were basically crossing one or two sectors to attack (fair), running into a thick defense (fair and fun), and having to cross that distance back home (fair). But after running that gauntlet and surviving, empty guns, low fuel, damaged, wheels bouncing on the runway of the single clear Axis recovery point…

Here comes a vulcher.

Then I get platitudes of how there’s another base to use the better part of a sector away. I get that FSO is among the most war-like parts of the game and war is hell.

But…

Let me explain what some people probably don’t give much thought about in FSO in its current form. Back in the day we only had one life to give. You died and you were a gunner, an observer, or back in the MA. This actually made setups and planning a little easier and imbalances easier to correct. Now you basically have unlimited lives. Cool. But the conventional thinking and setup doesn’t apply so well anymore.

Here’s why…

Distance (when there are unlimited lives) is a force multiplier. First, the team who is closer to spawn points or bases can get back in the fight almost immediately. This generally means defenders can be back in the fight within 5 minutes or less. If attackers have to cross 10 minutes of airspace to get back, the net effect is a 2:1 advantage for the defense. But it’s potentially even worse than that if an attacker actually survives. If you fly 10 minutes, fight, escape, you still have to fly 10 minutes back home. Making the force multiplier for the defense even more lopsided. In the 20 minutes spent getting to and from the target, another pilot on defense can potentially fly 4 sorties. Then there is the organizational issues. The first mission of the night is always the most organized. Both teams are clashing at full strength. Here’s the hiccup for the force who has to cross the most distance (usually offense). Once everything devolves after the first scrum, everything gets fractured. The defenders are generally consolidated naturally by geography. The attackers (even well organized squads) are going to start throwing themselves against a likely superior force because it’s baked in to the overall setup.

I’ve been doing this a loooooong time. I’ve run a squad, wrote orders, conferred with designers. I understand as well as anyone that sometimes you’re the windshield and sometimes you’re the bug. Some of the most fun FSOs I’ve participated in over the years have been those where we knew we were going to get annihilated and had a blast. But, even then, we had limits and rules. Sometimes those were grid lines one team was not allowed to cross. Often settings like downdrafts and other settings. Showing the forethought it takes to see the potential downfalls.

So last night I was pissed. I didn’t even get vulched but I saw the dude fly over as I was still trying to stop my plane. There were tons of reasons for my anger the main reason I was mad is because I knew it was going to happen just by looking at the setup. If I knew that was a problem before the first shot was fired, I have to assume the designers should have as well. So, as I see it, you’re encouraging kills on the runway or you really think players want to be effectively spawn camped during FSO.

Competition and sportsmanship clearly has to be enforced sometimes. Funny that sportsmanship was mentioned here specifically. I flew right past three Allies on the runway talking to my squad and telling them “I’m not that guy” when they encouraged me to vulch last night. Shortly thereafter I’m getting lectured on which bases I should take off from to avoid being vulched on landing when everything about the entire night screamed the runway feast should’ve been much worse. Now that I think about it, I really should thank the Allies for their sportsmanship. They could’ve easily over exploited their position en mass but didn’t. Appeared to be just one or two.
"When caught by the enemy in large force the best policy is to fight like hell until you can decide what to do next."
~Hub Zemke
P-47 pilot 56th Fighter Group.

Offline MDStampf93

  • Aces High CM Staff
  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1879
      • https://paa.ge/acecombatant
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #7 on: November 14, 2026, 05:14:50 PM »
Mak,

You bring up fair points and I understand them all and this post was not directed towards you specifically.

Vulching is neither encouraged nor prohibited. There were alternative airfields to both land and respawn at. Had the axis controlled the skies last night - vulching would not be occurring. Vulching was not a result of design but rather a result of player performance.

There was nothing stopping the axis from winning the aerial engagements and putting pressure on the allied fields, other than their own performance.

It has just gotten to the point where every month, every frame, there are the complaints - and it gets tiresome for us designing it who are trying our best to keep it fun for all.

There’s very little ”thanks - had a great time” and way more “this is unfair - I kept getting shot down”

No hard feelings - I know how frustrating it is to spend 2 hours on a Friday doing more flying to target, getting killed quickly and doing it all over again. Our 110s lasted less than 30 seconds in the target area and we made at least 10 sorties or so.

Next week will be a blood bath for all.

 :salute

JG11 'Sonderstaffel'
Aces High 3 content below
https://paa.ge/acecombatant


Offline hazmatt

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2609
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #8 on: November 14, 2026, 07:38:28 PM »
Let me explain what some people probably don’t give much thought about in FSO in its current form. Back in the day we only had one life to give. You died and you were a gunner, an observer, or back in the MA. This actually made setups and planning a little easier and imbalances easier to correct. Now you basically have unlimited lives.

I was not aware of this. When I flew FSO is was one and done. Seems this would really change the dynamics.

Offline MDStampf93

  • Aces High CM Staff
  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1879
      • https://paa.ge/acecombatant
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #9 on: November 14, 2026, 07:44:51 PM »
I was not aware of this. When I flew FSO is was one and done. Seems this would really change the dynamics.

With 30 players per side the event ends in 15-20 minutes if we maintained the old ways.

Even with the 1 life per hour set up, we would lose a large number of players if they are shot down early and have to wait 45 minutes to take off again.

Unlimited lives is the only way to keep the event alive.
JG11 'Sonderstaffel'
Aces High 3 content below
https://paa.ge/acecombatant


Offline hazmatt

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2609
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #10 on: November 14, 2026, 07:53:01 PM »
With 30 players per side

Wow. I didn't realize the numbers were that low. That really does change things.

Offline AKKuya

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3201
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #11 on: November 14, 2026, 09:32:50 PM »
Just need to recruit hot looking women wearing bikinis being filmed playing the game.  Post videos on social media.  Start a Come Fly With Us campaign.  FSO would see an increase in player count.

Just an idea.  I think it’s a Spikes original. :D
Future CEO of Section Eight Society
Rule #1 I make the rules
Rule #2 If in doubt, refer to above rule

Offline MDStampf93

  • Aces High CM Staff
  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1879
      • https://paa.ge/acecombatant
Re: When Did a Difficult Fight Become Something to Complain About?
« Reply #12 on: November 15, 2026, 09:09:22 AM »
AI might be able to assist us with that  :rofl
JG11 'Sonderstaffel'
Aces High 3 content below
https://paa.ge/acecombatant