All cool I guess. But what is being seen is driven by the pilot. Not guys on the ground with binoculars.
No, it is also being driven by guys on the ground in the tower, as stated here:
A contact is "seen" when any friendly player sees it:
- That friendly can be in flight or in the tower
- Seen range is out to dot range, about 7.5 miles in the MA.
So the real question is could someone in the tower see an aircraft at 7.5 miles.
Anyone on the ground looking for enemy aircraft would almost certainly be a lookout and thus using binoculars so the question is easy to answer using wartime sources.
The most useful source is the US Navy's
Lookout Manual, published in 1943, which provides specific figures for the detection of aircraft both with the naked eye and using binoculars.
On page 33, the manual states:
A good lookout can sight planes at 6,000 yards with his naked eye, and at two or three times that range with binoculars.
Converting those distances into statute miles gives:
Naked eye: 3.4 miles
Binoculars: between 6.8 and 10.2 milesThis is particularly interesting because the 3.4 mile icon limit corresponds almost exactly to the US Navy's figure for naked-eye detection. However, the same wartime manual explicitly states that using binoculars extends the detection range to as much as three times that distance at 10.2 miles, significantly farther than the current dot setting.
If you take the average value using binoculars it is 8.5 miles so the existing 7.5 mile dot range is already conservative.
Naturally, detection distances would vary with visibility, atmospheric conditions, aircraft size, aspect, background and the observer's ability.
Nevertheless, the historical evidence establishes that trained wartime observers equipped with binoculars could sight aircraft considerably farther away than 7.5 miles and as far as 10.2 miles.
Then I accept all the Wonder Woman spin plotting.
My reasoning is simple. For every additional mile you can “see”, the square miles your field of view covers is tripled.
Sorry, it just looks to me as if your reference to square miles and wonder woman are both entirely irrelevant and don't even make any sense.
However, using wartime sources:
In view of the 10.2 mile value, the 7.5-mile detection range is therefore quite reasonable. In fact, it falls towards the lower end of the 6.8–10.2-mile range given in the 1943 US Navy manual.This provides strong historical support for 7.5 miles as an already conservative range for a lookout in the tower.
Later evidence based on visibility trials suggests bombers could be seen with the naked eye as far away as 15 miles.
MoL