I don't know if reducing SA has been beneficial. It seems to further favor high speed high alt fighters blowing thru. It would be interesting to compare kill and aircraft stats to previous tours.
A good point, it got me thinking.
There's another aspect to this discussion that I think deserves consideration, and that's the influence of gameplay on the visibility settings we prefer.
Aces High is a unique combination of air combat simulation and strategic warfare. Players can pursue very different objectives, and those objectives sometimes create conflicting preferences about how the game should work.
For example, fighter pilots generally want to find enemy aircraft and engage them. For them, good visibility and information about enemy activity help create opportunities for combat.
On the other hand, players flying bombers, ground attack aircraft or operating vehicles may have very different priorities. They can achieve high scores and rankings by destroying ground targets, factories, radar installations and other strategic objectives. For many of those missions, the ideal outcome is to reach the target undetected, destroy it or capture it without ever encountering an enemy player.
In real warfare that's obviously desirable. Accomplishing your objectives without suffering losses is a success. But whether that's equally desirable in a multiplayer combat game is another question.
I've recently seen the MA with around 20 players online, all apparently pursuing their own objectives with almost no combat occurring between them. Everyone may be achieving something, contributing to the war effort, but with very little or no direct interaction between the players.
That raises an important question about what makes Aces High enjoyable and keeps players coming back.
The strategic element is valuable, but I would argue that it works best when it creates opportunities for combat. Bombing raids provide opportunities for interception, ground attacks generate defensive responses, and battles for territory bring opposing forces together. In my view, the strategic game and the combat simulation should complement each other.
The difficulty arises when the most effective way of achieving objectives is also to avoid contact with other players. The scoring and ranking systems can reward activities that produce little or no direct combat. That's not necessarily wrong, but it can create incentives that conflict with the interests of players who primarily come online to fight.
I suspect this conflict of interests influences our preferences about visibility. Players who want to find combat are likely to favour better detection, while those who want to complete missions without interception may prefer greater opportunities for concealment. Neither preference is inherently bad or even unreasonable, and I'm not suggesting that anyone advocating shorter detection ranges necessarily has that motive.
There's also the question of realism. Concealment, surprise and reconnaissance are all important aspects of warfare. Aircraft operating at low altitude against a terrain background should sometimes be difficult to detect, and terrain masking should provide real opportunities for avoiding observation.
But equally, military forces employ observers, reconnaissance and communications specifically to locate and report enemy activity. More observers generally provide better coverage, and pilots can communicate sightings directly through voice or text, irrespective of what appears on the clipboard. Restricting automatic reports doesn't eliminate those advantages.
Ultimately, I think we're dealing with a gameplay balance problem rather than simply a question of visual acuity.
Particularly with the relatively small player population we have today, finding opponents and generating encounters is important. If we make enemy activity more difficult to locate, we risk creating even more situations where players are online with fewer opportunities to encounter one another.
In real warfare, most military personnel spent only a small proportion of their time actually fighting. Reproducing that level of inactivity might be historically realistic, but it wouldn't necessarily make for enjoyable gameplay. There's an important distinction between making combat itself realistic and reproducing the historically low frequency of combat.
I believe that more opportunities for meaningful player interaction generally make Aces High more enjoyable, encouraging existing players to stay and new players to subscribe. More players then create more opportunities for interaction, producing a virtuous cycle that benefits everyone.
Unfortunately, the reverse is also possible. Fewer encounters can make the game less enjoyable, causing players to leave, which further reduces opportunities for interaction. That becomes a vicious cycle of declining player numbers and activity.
Of course, stealth and strategic operations are important parts of the game, and combat shouldn't be unavoidable. But we need to be careful that changes intended to improve realism or protect particular styles of play don't inadvertently reduce the interaction that makes multiplayer gaming attractive.
The objective should be realistic combat, not necessarily a realistic scarcity of combat.
For me, the priority should be a system that preserves realistic opportunities for concealment while encouraging encounters, interceptions, defensive responses and combat.
After all, the central attraction of a multiplayer air combat game is surely the opportunity to engage other human players. If we make it increasingly easy for everyone to avoid one another, we risk undermining the very thing that makes multiplayer combat different from flying offline.
We all have strong views about what's realistic and what we'd personally prefer, but are those preferences necessarily what's best for the game as a whole?
Badboy