I never seem to lose just my vert stab, if it goes, the horizontals go with it, and that's all she wrote. I've lost the rudder only before, but I can't ever recall losing the whole vert stab and nothing else.
best I've done is rip both wing tips and ailerons off the Ta-152 (in a TOD, the ONE time I've flown that plane) and managed to get out of the fight AND land it. Me and Ghosth dove in on some P-47s... I follow him in thinking he know what he's doing... hehe, next thing I hear on RW is "awww, damn it!" and sure enough, he's lawndarting and I am too. I try to pull out of it, and rip off a lot of both wings and immediately it starts looping on me (kinda like when you lose the horizontal stabs) I'm seeing tracers all around me from the P-47s that musta been laughing their butts off. I just let go of the stick thinking "sheesh, this was quick..." Somehow though, the loop gets them to overshoot and I try to level her out with the elevators. sure enough, I have authority again with them and get her pointed down and haul some more butt to the deck back to Germany. hehe, getting it pointed in the right direction was rather interesting. I'm amazed I got her down.
The B-17 with only 1 or 2 engines, 1 wheel out, 1 side of flaps gone, the other side's aileron gone. That was amusing too. I think more things were red in the damage list than were green!