Originally posted by Toad
Let me ask you "Gore really won" guys this question.
If the situation was exactly reversed... exactly, all the same things happened on the same timeline.. and Gore "won" the election... would you still be whining that "Bush actually won the election!" ?
Would 10Bears and Towd be arguing that Gore stole the election?
Please do answer.
Because I'm sure my view would be the same had the situation be exactly reversed. Just curious to see if YOUR position would be the same.. IE, popular vote determines. (Which of course it does not. Never has.)
Candidates have been elected even though they received fewer popular votes than their opponents. Both Rutherford B. Hayes, in 1876, and Benjamin Harrison, in 1888, were elected in this manner. John Quincy Adams also received fewer popular votes than his opponent. On several occasions the popular vote pluralities of the electoral college victors have been razor thin or even questionable. One instance was the election of John F. Kennedy over Richard M. Nixon in 1960. IIRC, Eisenhower prevailed upon Nixon not to challenge the discrepancies in voting in order to preserve the peoples "faith in the system". It wasn't because he felt the wasn't sufficient grounds.
Actually I was a Gore supporter as I thought he was the lesser of two evils (Sad that I had to make my selection that way). At least Gore wasn't a cocaine user in his past, he served in Vietnam, seems to have the higher IQ, seems to be a straight arrow.
Although the election was finally settled on a very rare Supreme Court intervention, I have accepted the fact that some IDIOTS in Florida could not comprehend how to vote properly for their choice. We deserve what we get. Had the results been different and Gore winning, I'd bet we'd see a fair share of Bush supporters claiming of an election stolen. All about biased thinking and arguements on all sides.
Actually the 1960 election of Illinois voting results being in question would not have made a difference had they been overturned. Even had Nixon won that state, he still would have lost that election. Had those electoral college votes been enough to give Nixon the presidency, you can bet Nixon and most (if not all) Republicans would be DEMANDING a recount. As would any candidate from any party given those same circumstances.
Regards,
wSNPR