I went through something like this when I started my account a few weeks ago. I had been playing h2h on and off for the past 2 years or so, but hadn't subscribed because I had a crappy connection to the MA. I could play h2h with no problems though. So I had a 2 year old non-paying account when I decided to give the MA another try. I started a new account, hoping to get another 2 week trial to check out the connection, but no dice. Sounds like the same problem you're having.
I just gave Skuzzy a call, to see if I could get any amount of free trial. While he was reluctant to renew the free trial, HTC does have some sort of refund policy. I gave my CC number, with a verbal guarantee from Skuzzy that if I had poor gameplay my money would be refunded. Everything works great, and as a result, I lived happily ever after.
I'd suggest you give Skuzzy a call at (817) 251-1540 and talk to him... I don't know if the refund deal is official policy or was just a verbal thing, so you'd probably be best off asking first.
Hope to see you flying soon Skitzo.