I agree MT. Parts were magnificent beyond words, stunning, awe inspiring, better than my imagination. Then there were the elves at Helm's deep, the The Arwen might leave angle, Theoden as a cautious fool, Farimar's detour to get to the same mental place he was at in the book, and the reluctant Elrond and Elrond the sitcom daddy (though the Aragorn/Arwen angle was covered in the appendicies). The Arwen episode did give me a chance to drain the bladder though. Ultimately not major deviations, but not needed for clarity or compression purposes either.
Charon