Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => The O' Club => Topic started by: XxDaSTaRxx on October 18, 2014, 05:59:53 PM

Title: Let's talk Drones
Post by: XxDaSTaRxx on October 18, 2014, 05:59:53 PM
With new drones rolling out it seems by the week for new and more complex tasks and purposes, it's been a common topic around 'hese parts talking about drones replacing pilots.


I figured we could all discuss our stances on them...

Here's my 2¢

Reconnaissance: Absolutely

Air to Ground Attack: Neutral on this point

Air to Air Combat: Never
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: jolly22 on October 18, 2014, 07:24:02 PM
Beer Delivery service: YES PLEASE
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Rich46yo on October 18, 2014, 08:15:17 PM
Quote
Air to Ground Attack: Neutral on this point

Air to Air Combat: Never


Why? Does it strike you as unsporting that we dont put your neighbors kid at risk of being blown to pieces? Maybe captured, tortured, and beheaded?

I for one dont care how we kill the enemy as long as they end up dead. There's nothing more pathetic then when we give a bunch of civilians a vote in the rules of engagement in a war they, or their kids, aren't fighting.

Ive talked to these troops coming back from I-crap and I-crapistan. They are just disgusted with these ROE's the couch warriors are forcing upon them.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: caldera on October 18, 2014, 08:25:23 PM
The bad guys don't follow any rules and neither should we.  The more terrible you make war, the sooner it will be over.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: XxDaSTaRxx on October 18, 2014, 08:32:23 PM


Why? Does it strike you as unsporting that we dont put your neighbors kid at risk of being blown to pieces? Maybe captured, tortured, and beheaded?

I for one dont care how we kill the enemy as long as they end up dead. There's nothing more pathetic then when we give a bunch of civilians a vote in the rules of engagement in a war they, or their kids, aren't fighting.

Ive talked to these troops coming back from I-crap and I-crapistan. They are just disgusted with these ROE's the couch warriors are forcing upon them.
Kill the enemy.... but do not hate them (unless it's ISIS, hating is open there)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: ghi on October 18, 2014, 09:00:39 PM

Kobane Syria today , cool photos on Dailymail, what a fireworks party, drones are too small for big jobs like this; :lol

Love this photo:

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/10/18/1413652001326_wps_33_Smoke_rises_over_Syrian_t.jpg)

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2798266/raining-fire-isis-amazing-picture-captures-moment-u-s-bomb-lands-heart-kobani-kurdish-leader-warns-airstrikes-not-defeat-jihadists.html
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Skyyr on October 19, 2014, 09:04:45 AM
The bad guys don't follow any rules and neither should we.  The more terrible you make war, the sooner it will be over.

I'm pretty sure that's what the Nazis said...
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: bozon on October 19, 2014, 11:10:49 AM
Kobane Syria today , cool photos on Dailymail, what a fireworks party, drones are too small for big jobs like this; :lol

Love this photo:

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/10/18/1413652001326_wps_33_Smoke_rises_over_Syrian_t.jpg)

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2798266/raining-fire-isis-amazing-picture-captures-moment-u-s-bomb-lands-heart-kobani-kurdish-leader-warns-airstrikes-not-defeat-jihadists.html
This is an outrage! indiscriminate bombing in civilian areas.
Just wait till the UN, Humans Rights Watch, Doctors Without Borders, Cocker Spaniel relief, Humans Left Wristwatch, and Recep Tayyip Erdogan hear about this!
 :mad:
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: -ammo- on October 19, 2014, 11:13:22 AM
This is an outrage! indiscriminate bombing in civilian areas.
Just wait till the UN, Humans Rights Watch, Doctors Without Borders, Cocker Spaniel relief, Humans Left Wristwatch, and Recep Tayyip Erdogan hear about this!
 :mad:


 :lol  Ain't that the truth.  Tell it like it is Bozon
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on October 19, 2014, 11:27:07 AM
... drones are too small for big jobs like this; :lol

Current generation, yes...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAiZ6SS2oSA
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: caldera on October 19, 2014, 01:05:34 PM
I'm pretty sure that's what the Nazis said...

Intentionally targeting and executing civilians is not war, just plain murder.  The Allies were guilty of this during WWII, but bombing cities to destroy factories and infrastructure is hardly equivalent to concentration camp genocide. 

Our modern enemy is clothed as civilians and hides among them.  Collateral casualties in large numbers may be necessary to kill all the jihadists.  Tippy-toeing around has never worked.  It only sometimes shuts them up for a while.  The enemy holds no regard for their own populace, much less ours and gets their jollies killing innocents.  They are playing for keeps and the only way they will back down is by getting crushed on an unprecedented scale.  I don't mean break out the nukes, but unload everything else at them until they beg for mercy.  There is no diplomatic solution, so long as political correctness and the court of world opinion continues to appease them - even to the extent of letting them force their views and rules in our countries.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Lusche on October 19, 2014, 01:19:07 PM
Our modern enemy is clothed as civilians and hides among them.  Collateral casualties in large numbers may be necessary to kill all the jihadists. 


And this is actually something they are hoping for.
Because it's a very old guerilla strategy that worked before. Don't worry about the civillians that will suffer from the enemy's retaliation strikes - it will radicalize them (and hopefully public opinion in other countries) and not a few will join your ranks or support you in other ways.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: DREDIOCK on October 19, 2014, 01:51:15 PM
Drones of today may be too small. But nothing stopping anyone from making a full sized aircraft a drone. The could probably convert any full sized aircraft into a drone already for that matter.

And the upside is they could design aircraft that can exceed human tolerances. when you dont have to worry about the effects of Gs on a human body
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: TonyJoey on October 19, 2014, 01:51:23 PM
The bad guys don't follow any rules and neither should we.  The more terrible you make war, the sooner it will be over.

How terrible is war when you can zap your enemies while sitting comfortably thousands of miles away? Having such advanced technology seems to me to make war a lot easier and thus makes us much more prone to starting them.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on October 19, 2014, 02:15:24 PM
(https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/26232318/AH/horror.jpg)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Tumor on October 20, 2014, 03:29:12 AM
Drones will eventually replace human piloted aircraft.  We're a long way off yet (well maybe not) and military aviation "Leaders" (at a minimum) will fight tooth and nail to keep it from happening.  I predict billions of dollars being wasted dragging out the fight to keep pilots in the air.  But it's going to happen... eventually. 

That's my 2 cents.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: artik on October 20, 2014, 04:39:53 AM
Reconnaissance: Absolutely

Air to Ground Attack: Neutral on this point

Air to Air Combat: Never

Actually it is all "Yes" for a very long time but in a little bit different way:

The first one was A2G - the V1 drone worked quite well...
The second role was A2A - the Soviet make lots of them like SA-2 and many others...
The latest to come were recon drones.

Basically there is no need for A2A drone - it what a good missile does very well... for a long time...

It is just a matter how do you look at it and how disposable drones are - as under enemy air supremacy even recon drone is "single use drone"
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Vulcan on October 20, 2014, 06:30:07 AM
Intentionally targeting and executing civilians is not war, just plain murder.  The Allies were guilty of this during WWII, but bombing cities to destroy factories and infrastructure is hardly equivalent to concentration camp genocide. 

Our modern enemy is clothed as civilians and hides among them.  Collateral casualties in large numbers may be necessary to kill all the jihadists.  Tippy-toeing around has never worked.  It only sometimes shuts them up for a while.  The enemy holds no regard for their own populace, much less ours and gets their jollies killing innocents.  They are playing for keeps and the only way they will back down is by getting crushed on an unprecedented scale.  I don't mean break out the nukes, but unload everything else at them until they beg for mercy.  There is no diplomatic solution, so long as political correctness and the court of world opinion continues to appease them - even to the extent of letting them force their views and rules in our countries.

At some point you will wonder if you've become the terrorists: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/29/pakistan-family-drone-victim-testimony-congress



Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: danny76 on October 20, 2014, 06:57:08 AM


Why? Does it strike you as unsporting that we dont put your neighbors kid at risk of being blown to pieces? Maybe captured, tortured, and beheaded?

I for one dont care how we kill the enemy as long as they end up dead. There's nothing more pathetic then when we give a bunch of civilians a vote in the rules of engagement in a war they, or their kids, aren't fighting.

Ive talked to these troops coming back from I-crap and I-crapistan. They are just disgusted with these ROE's the couch warriors are forcing upon them.

^^^ This. Courageous Restraint?  My arse  :old:
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Rich46yo on October 20, 2014, 12:38:13 PM
Indiscriminate bombing of civilian areas is now not only unnecessary but also unconscionable. Drones give you the option of surgical strikes of leadership, and at the least makes them keep their heads down. Lusche is right that intentionally targeting civilians will only make more Jihadist's, tho in the end I dont think it matters much cause they have no shortage of volunteers and supporters. So its as inhumane as it ever was but luckily also not needed with modern tech. We can deliver bombs within meters now, even smaller ords like Hellfires or 250 lb with smart kits.

I sympathize with the humanists but we do have to win this thing.

Quote
How terrible is war when you can zap your enemies while sitting comfortably thousands of miles away? Having such advanced technology seems to me to make war a lot easier and thus makes us much more prone to starting them.
I dont agree cause we didnt start this but it doesnt seem like bad advice to keep in mind. We need the drones but we also need a conscious.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Fish42 on October 20, 2014, 01:37:02 PM
Indiscriminate bombing of civilian areas is now not only unnecessary but also unconscionable. Drones give you the option of surgical strikes of leadership, and at the least makes them keep their heads down. Lusche is right that intentionally targeting civilians will only make more Jihadist's, tho in the end I dont think it matters much cause they have no shortage of volunteers and supporters. So its as inhumane as it ever was but luckily also not needed with modern tech. We can deliver bombs within meters now, even smaller ords like Hellfires or 250 lb with smart kits.

I sympathize with the humanists but we do have to win this thing.
 I dont agree cause we didnt start this but it doesnt seem like bad advice to keep in mind. We need the drones but we also need a conscious.

Drones give you the option true... but you need local intel and visual identification. Even the people ordering the drones strikes, don't 100% know who they are hitting or how many are killed. The US (CIA) counts All Males, that are military aged as militants, if they are around the target, unless they have clear evidence to counter this (guilty until proven innocent and sorry about the death in the family). So a family, who by no fault of their own, could have their father & brothers killed in a strike and they would be labeled as terrorists. Nice way to lower that Civilian death toll.

Many people in the zones that these Drones are operating, are fast seeing America as the Terrorists. People living in fear that they might be a target because they were in the wrong area, is a good way to grow hate.

 

Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: bozon on October 20, 2014, 01:47:26 PM
Many people in the zones that these Drones are operating, are fast seeing America as the Terrorists. People living in fear that they might be a target because they were in the wrong area, is a good way to grow hate.
These people were not waving red white and blue before. They hate America anyway, bombing them just intensifies what already exists.

The US (CIA) counts All Males, that are military aged as militants, if they are around the target, unless they have clear evidence to counter this (guilty until proven innocent and sorry about the death in the family). So a family, who by no fault of their own, could have their father & brothers killed in a strike and they would be labeled as terrorists. Nice way to lower that Civilian death toll.
That is interesting. The UN on the other hand counts anyone who is not in uniform + holding a weapon + in active fighting, as a civilian. So a militant that got out of his hole to buy cigarettes and got whacked is counted as a civilian.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Slate on October 20, 2014, 02:24:09 PM
  We don't need larger Drones we need smaller ones. Imagine a swarm of insect size killers going through the Jihadist camps and the Shock and Awe that would cause.  :O

     http://www.businessinsider.com/air-force-bug-sized-drones-are-scary-2013-2 (http://www.businessinsider.com/air-force-bug-sized-drones-are-scary-2013-2)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: bozon on October 20, 2014, 05:23:35 PM
  We don't need larger Drones we need smaller ones. Imagine a swarm of insect size killers going through the Jihadist camps and the Shock and Awe that would cause.  :O

     http://www.businessinsider.com/air-force-bug-sized-drones-are-scary-2013-2 (http://www.businessinsider.com/air-force-bug-sized-drones-are-scary-2013-2)
Good idea! we can paint them with black and orange stripes, attach a needle with a small sack of poison to their butts and release them among the Jihadists!
Here is a sketch of my design:
(http://traviscountybeekeepers.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/drone-bee.jpg)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Hetzer7 on October 20, 2014, 05:48:24 PM
(http://hommage-general-patton.org/images/patton1.jpg)

"Wonder weapons"? By God, I don't see the wonder in them. Killing without heroics?
Nothing is glorified? Nothing is reaffirmed? No heroes, no cowards, no troops, no generals.
Only those who are left alive, and those who are left... dead. I'm glad I won't live to see it.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Dragon on October 20, 2014, 05:59:45 PM
Why does the mind wander to military grade, armed UAV's when someone says "Drone"?

Let the military have their drones.



Plenty of uses out there for UAV's or UAS's as the term is now changing to as the systems become more than a bird and a controller.  The US is so far behind the times in "drones" we may never catch up. 
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Rich46yo on October 21, 2014, 09:45:51 AM
(http://hommage-general-patton.org/images/patton1.jpg)

"Wonder weapons"? By God, I don't see the wonder in them. Killing without heroics?
Nothing is glorified? Nothing is reaffirmed? No heroes, no cowards, no troops, no generals.
Only those who are left alive, and those who are left... dead. I'm glad I won't live to see it.

I doubt his troops shared his love for "heroic" slaughter. Especially since it was them getting slaughtered. Tens of millions dieing and Patton's main worry was how history would remember him.

Generals love war. Its their chance to shine and get promoted. The average grunt hates it since its their chance to get their guts blown out.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Hetzer7 on October 21, 2014, 12:28:54 PM
I doubt his troops shared his love for "heroic" slaughter. Especially since it was them getting slaughtered. Tens of millions dieing and Patton's main worry was how history would remember him.

Generals love war. Its their chance to shine and get promoted. The average grunt hates it since its their chance to get their guts blown out.

I totally agree. But drones and standoff warfare does sanitize war and this topic made Patton's quote stand out for argument.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on October 21, 2014, 05:34:59 PM
I think Patton, in his own inept way, was just trying to invoke Robert E. Lee: "It is well that war is so terrible, otherwise we should grow too fond of it."
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: DREDIOCK on October 21, 2014, 06:34:05 PM
I doubt his troops shared his love for "heroic" slaughter. Especially since it was them getting slaughtered. Tens of millions dieing and Patton's main worry was how history would remember him.

Generals love war. Its their chance to shine and get promoted. The average grunt hates it since its their chance to get their guts blown out.

Pattons 3rd army had the lowest casualty rate of any Allied army in the European theater of operations


"A pint of Sweat will save a gallon of blood"


"No bastard won a war by dieing for his country."

You should read up more. His entire doctrine was to stay aggressive. An enemy on the run is less able to fight back

" His instinctive preference for offensive movement was typified by an answer Patton gave to war correspondents in a 1944 press conference. In response to a question on whether the Third Army's rapid offensive across France should be slowed to reduce the number of U.S. casualties, Patton replied, "Whenever you slow anything down, you waste human lives.""
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Rich46yo on October 21, 2014, 11:41:27 PM
Quote
You should read up more. His entire doctrine was to stay aggressive. An enemy on the run is less able to fight back

I have. I have also read how he looked at a battlefield and said, "I love it" ; "I do love it so".

I never said we didnt need Patton's. I also agree with his doctrine of knocking the hell out of the enemy and winning the thing, "BTW his 3rd army had such a low casualty rate cause they didnt even exist on paper before 1 Aug. 1944". I wonder what it would have been had they had to slog it our thru the hedgerows of Normandy for a few months before. You should read more.

This "philosophy" is why I favor drones. They take the fight to the enemy, most of all their leadership targets. And they do so without putting our sons and daughters at risk. I'm a father of a troop and I couldnt give a rat's rear end if the world thinks they are inhumane.

My only regret is Im to old to notch some terrorist scalps my ownself.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Vulcan on October 22, 2014, 05:10:37 AM
This "philosophy" is why I favor drones. They take the fight to the enemy, most of all their leadership targets. And they do so without putting our sons and daughters at risk. I'm a father of a troop and I couldnt give a rat's rear end if the world thinks they are inhumane.

My only regret is Im to old to notch some terrorist scalps my ownself.

The argument is not whether drones are inhumane or not, it's how they are being used.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: rpm on October 22, 2014, 05:26:50 AM
These aren't the drones you're looking for.
(http://media.nbcdfw.com/images/652*367/ut-student-drone.jpg)
Quote
Police said they arrested a University of Texas student after he flew a drone over Darrell K. Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium during the Longhorns game Saturday night.
Police said they began investigating after they noticed the drone during the second half of the game against the University of North Texas.
Officials found the student and arrested him shortly after.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Vudak on October 22, 2014, 05:38:34 AM
Intentionally targeting and executing civilians is not war, just plain murder.  The Allies were guilty of this during WWII...

When it came to what they did to Germany and the Germans, the Allies were guilty of nothing in WWII.

Albert Speer on the "terror" bombing of Hamburg:

Quote
We were of the opinion that a rapid repetition of this type of attack upon another six German towns would inevitably cripple the will to sustain armament manufacture and war production. It was I who first verbally reported to the Fuehrer at that time that a continuation of these attacks might bring about a rapid end to the war."

Hamburg was bombed most heavily in July-August of 1943.  We didn't go after another six towns rapidly.  If you read Churchill's memoirs, many of his contemporaries lost their stomach for it after seeing what Operation Gomorrah did.  Meanwhile, the Holocaust raged on for nearly another two years.

When you have a conflict you clearly need to win, you win it, and you wait until the end to feel bad about it.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on October 22, 2014, 06:07:51 AM
I have. I have also read how he looked at a battlefield and said, "I love it" ; "I do love it so".

We need men that are good at warfare, and I think it is a bit unfair and disingenuous to think/suggest that it is morally wrong for them to like, even love, their work; all the while we enjoy the freedom and security they provide.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: jollyFE on October 22, 2014, 10:34:33 AM
The UAV I fly at work is as big as a commercial airliner...air to air isn't that far off.   I hate the term drone, that implies that the aircraft isn't that smart.  The small quad rotors can be programmed to return home is they go lost link, that sounds somewhat smart to me.  Some UAVs can do everything after engine start on their own...take, T/O, execute the mission and return home all without human interaction.  Many can handle almost any emergency without pilot input.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: pembquist on October 22, 2014, 12:14:55 PM
With new drones rolling out it seems by the week for new and more complex tasks and purposes, it's been a common topic around 'hese parts talking about drones replacing pilots.


I figured we could all discuss our stances on them...

Here's my 2¢

Reconnaissance: Absolutely

Air to Ground Attack: Neutral on this point

Air to Air Combat: Never

I vote yes on all three and more when it gets dreamed up. Not to sound ridiculous but I feel like we are on the cusp of something with regards to automation that will be as transformative as the creation of agriculture. Drones are one of the more visible technologies but are still primitive with regards to autonomy. That, though is the future, don't kid yourself. Fire and forget will have a whole new meaning in a decade or two. However, the biggest change won't be military drones but our relationship to work and earning. It has been a truism that automation leads to the creation of yet undreamed of jobs, I am not so sure that that is the case now, or maybe the point is that it will require a whole crapload of creating to figure out what we all will do when robots can do most everything that we can do in the way of work.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: JimmyC on October 22, 2014, 01:34:02 PM
Just saw on news today here in NZ cleaning some quake damage at sumner Christchurch the use of radio controlled excavators. .
The area was deemed to dangerous  so they rigged the diggers to be radio controlled.
Sensible option.
Drone? Or tool
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Slate on October 22, 2014, 02:37:40 PM
  Where is Condor06?  :headscratch:  He could give input on drones.

   





    :headscratch:
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: zack1234 on October 22, 2014, 02:52:32 PM
Intentionally targeting and executing civilians is not war, just plain murder.  The Allies were guilty of this during WWII, but bombing cities to destroy factories and infrastructure is hardly equivalent to concentration camp genocide. 

.

The germans were all guilty and deserved what they got from the allies :old:

The allies cannot be that bad as people still speak german and there still is a Germany :old:

Using drones on scum is a fantastic idea, give the drone AI would be more efficient :old:
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: pembquist on October 22, 2014, 03:04:18 PM
The germans were all guilty and deserved what they got from the allies :old:


Even the 6 year olds?

There are forces beyond our control, we are swept in the tides of history. Don't pretend that fairness or justice has anything to do with being in the wrong place at the wrong time.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: JimmyD3 on October 22, 2014, 05:28:48 PM
Even the 6 year olds?

There are forces beyond our control, we are swept in the tides of history. Don't pretend that fairness or justice has anything to do with being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Yes.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: caldera on October 22, 2014, 05:40:43 PM
When it came to what they did to Germany and the Germans, the Allies were guilty of nothing in WWII.

Albert Speer on the "terror" bombing of Hamburg:

Hamburg was bombed most heavily in July-August of 1943.  We didn't go after another six towns rapidly.  If you read Churchill's memoirs, many of his contemporaries lost their stomach for it after seeing what Operation Gomorrah did.  Meanwhile, the Holocaust raged on for nearly another two years.

When you have a conflict you clearly need to win, you win it, and you wait until the end to feel bad about it.

 
I agree.  If you read the rest of that post...

Quote
Collateral casualties in large numbers may be necessary to kill all the jihadists.

I hate that civilians are killed in war but until there is some magic weapon that can kill all the bad guys without hurting anyone else; we can either continue fighting a limited war that goes on forever or steamroll the crap out of them and be done with it.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: pembquist on October 22, 2014, 06:22:38 PM
Yes.


your supposed to say "especially the 6 year olds"
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Rich46yo on October 22, 2014, 11:15:04 PM
What does WW2 Germany and 6yo's have to do with drones?
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: pembquist on October 22, 2014, 11:33:45 PM
What does WW2 Germany and 6yo's have to do with drones?


If you had read the thread backwards you'd be asking what do drones have to do with 6 year olds. Sorry,  to much time on my hands.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: JimmyD3 on October 23, 2014, 09:24:08 AM
your supposed to say "especially the 6 year olds"

No, the full reply would be "Yes, unfortunately the 6 year old's too". War is just like any other human endeavor, when the cost becomes to much to pay, you stop doing it.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Flench on October 23, 2014, 10:48:27 AM
I was going to use mine to spy on deer hunter's but hit a tree . Waiting for parts now . Good thing I did not mess up the 25 mile radio . Can not buy them any more .
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: bustr on October 23, 2014, 04:22:04 PM
UAV over fly's a target city somewhere on the Arabian peninsula after dark. It offloads tiny drones that cannot fly thousands of miles but, can be controlled from thousands of miles away to quietly land on roof tops or hide wherever the remote operator can see from it's onboard camera. The UAV hangs out at 50,000ft indefinitely acting as a control relay. Each tiny drone has super long life tiny batteries, cameras, and a nasty payload. Shifts of operators sit and watch the comings and goings in the city until individuals are identified. Then the tiny drone is flown up behind the target's head and detonated. Cheaper than a Hellfire.

In the US, amazon would rather deliver your books to you with them. The police would like to look in your backyard and windows with them. PETA type groups have used them to harass hunters in the name of keeping an eye on them for hunting violations. Paparazzi have used them. Eventually someone will figure out how to torch property to pull off insurance scams. And copycats will run with it for other nefarious activities if not already.

There are bug sized flying toys that can be modified to land on you and act as a tracking beacon and\or audio bug. Most of us live lives where abuses of this technology will only be interesting 24\7 talking head stories we go tsk, tsk, tsk about. Then write posts like this one to mull over with our friends.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Flench on October 23, 2014, 06:37:22 PM
UAV over fly's a target city somewhere on the Arabian peninsula after dark. It offloads tiny drones that cannot fly thousands of miles but, can be controlled from thousands of miles away to quietly land on roof tops or hide wherever the remote operator can see from it's onboard camera. The UAV hangs out at 50,000ft indefinitely acting as a control relay. Each tiny drone has super long life tiny batteries, cameras, and a nasty payload. Shifts of operators sit and watch the comings and goings in the city until individuals are identified. Then the tiny drone is flown up behind the target's head and detonated. Cheaper than a Hellfire.

In the US, amazon would rather deliver your books to you with them. The police would like to look in your backyard and windows with them. PETA type groups have used them to harass hunters in the name of keeping an eye on them for hunting violations. Paparazzi have used them. Eventually someone will figure out how to torch property to pull off insurance scams. And copycats will run with it for other nefarious activities if not already.

There are bug sized flying toys that can be modified to land on you and act as a tracking beacon and\or audio bug. Most of us live lives where abuses of this technology will only be interesting 24\7 talking head stories we go tsk, tsk, tsk about. Then write posts like this one to mull over with our friends.

One reason one can not buy the 25 mile hack you put on your transmitter anymore .
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: BuckShot on October 24, 2014, 03:11:23 PM
I wonder of they'll come up with a private airspace around homes.

A drone visible outside a window would likely meet a load of #5 shot.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: bozon on October 24, 2014, 05:46:48 PM
A drone visible outside a window would likely meet a load of #5 shot.
That sounds like a fun sport   :aok
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: zack1234 on October 25, 2014, 04:33:56 AM
your supposed to say "especially the 6 year olds"

Adolf Hitler was voted in and had the full support of the German people so they are responsible for the deaths of their own chidren not the Allies

The British tried everything to stay out of it and but the Germans were savages
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Rich46yo on October 25, 2014, 10:33:24 AM
You have no idea what the Police have to go thru just to record your voice do you?

Not that blowing up terrorists heads and sending a little fly drone into your house to record you and the old Lady nagging have anything in common.

UAV over fly's a target city somewhere on the Arabian peninsula after dark. It offloads tiny drones that cannot fly thousands of miles but, can be controlled from thousands of miles away to quietly land on roof tops or hide wherever the remote operator can see from it's onboard camera. The UAV hangs out at 50,000ft indefinitely acting as a control relay. Each tiny drone has super long life tiny batteries, cameras, and a nasty payload. Shifts of operators sit and watch the comings and goings in the city until individuals are identified. Then the tiny drone is flown up behind the target's head and detonated. Cheaper than a Hellfire.

In the US, amazon would rather deliver your books to you with them. The police would like to look in your backyard and windows with them. PETA type groups have used them to harass hunters in the name of keeping an eye on them for hunting violations. Paparazzi have used them. Eventually someone will figure out how to torch property to pull off insurance scams. And copycats will run with it for other nefarious activities if not already.

There are bug sized flying toys that can be modified to land on you and act as a tracking beacon and\or audio bug. Most of us live lives where abuses of this technology will only be interesting 24\7 talking head stories we go tsk, tsk, tsk about. Then write posts like this one to mull over with our friends.

Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: pembquist on October 25, 2014, 11:33:16 AM
Adolf Hitler was voted in and had the full support of the German people so they are responsible for the deaths of their own chidren not the Allies

The British tried everything to stay out of it and but the Germans were savages

What ever gets you through life chief.

Anyway...DRONE RACE Mini quadcopters race through an advanced course.
http://wimp.com/quadcoptersrace/ (http://Mini quadcopters race through an advanced course.
http://wimp.com/quadcoptersrace/)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Dragon on October 25, 2014, 07:03:02 PM
What ever gets you through life chief.

Anyway...DRONE RACE Mini quadcopters race through an advanced course.
http://wimp.com/quadcoptersrace/ (http://Mini quadcopters race through an advanced course.
http://wimp.com/quadcoptersrace/)


A quadcopter is not a drone, but a drone can be a quadcopter.   :P
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Bosco123 on October 31, 2014, 10:40:35 PM
I know this is a little bit of a bump, but I feel like my 2 cents has a lot of weight here (since my job in the Marine Corps is UASs).  

I can't speak for the other branches of service but from the Marine Corps perspective on this is that they do not want to phase out manned aviation any time soon. From this point now, the Marine Corps is not expected to receive Group 4 and 5 (which are the Predators and Reapers) UAS until around 2020. There is a bunch of reasons for this and I'll explain:

1.  One of the biggest concerns is that the Marine Corps has with UAS is to try and phase out the smaller UAS, Shadow and Blackjack (which mind you the Marine Corps is just finally starting to phase out the Shadow with the Blackjack) to trade in on the Group 4 and 5 UAS. With that will phase out the enlisted UAS pilots.  For one, they do not want to do that at this time just due to the fact that the enlisted pilots do a fantastic job at the Aerial Recon portion of UAS.  

2.  The Marine Corps has only just started to send their officers to the Air Force RPA (Remote Piloted Aircraft) school.  As of current there are only about a dozen Officers that are qualified to fly Group 4 and 5 UAS. So as small as the UAS community in the Marine Corps is (maybe only about 200 enlisted UAS pilots), it's even smaller for RPA's.

3. The biggest and most major concern for the Marine Corps is the JSF (F-35).  They literally just spent billions in the last two years to upstart the JSF program.  Although the JSF can be unmanned, the Marine Corps will never use it in that way.


So in reality:

Aerial Recon: A must for the Marine Corps, and will continue to happen.

Air to Ground Strikes:  Not expected to happen until at least 2020 for the Marine Corps. Laser guided bombs can be hosted with the current UAS that the Marine Corps has, but no UAS in the Marine Corps actually has any bombs attached.

Air to Air:  The technology is there but probably won't happen until far later down the road (2028 or later).

If you guys have any questions about the particular UAS that I fly, I'm more than open to questions.



<S>


EDIT:  a little bit more info for you guys.  any UAS bigger than an R\C plane is not allowed to fly in national airspace.  Hope that relieves some of you guys.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on October 31, 2014, 11:59:15 PM
Appropriate to the size of our country we have the smallest UAV... The Brits like it too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gQSkppYviw
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: bozon on November 01, 2014, 04:56:00 AM
Appropriate to the size of our country we have the smallest UAV... The Brits like it too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gQSkppYviw
Can they arm that drone with a stapler gun?

and what's with the silly feather on their beret? I suppose it hides the wifi antenna?
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: danny76 on November 01, 2014, 07:18:55 PM
Can they arm that drone with a stapler gun?

and what's with the silly feather on their beret? I suppose it hides the wifi antenna?


It's a hackle. I would wander around telling the wearers of this fine piece of traditional British Military headgear that they are wearing silly feathers! ( we call this particular breeding the video tampon-heads)  :old:
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: danny76 on November 01, 2014, 07:24:15 PM
Can they arm that drone with a stapler gun?

and what's with the silly feather on their beret? I suppose it hides the wifi antenna?


It's a hackle. I would wander around telling the wearers of this fine piece of traditional British Military headgear that they are wearing silly feathers! ( we call this particular breeding the video tampon-heads)  :old:
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on November 01, 2014, 07:50:08 PM
Can they arm that drone with a stapler gun?

That would be way too heavy for a nano-drone like this. The drone itself only weighs 16 grams; that's like three or four sheets of paper... However it will fly for 20 minutes and give you real-time intel from its three cameras.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: bozon on November 02, 2014, 05:58:33 AM
That would be way too heavy for a nano-drone like this. The drone itself only weighs 16 grams; that's like three or four sheets of paper... However it will fly for 20 minutes and give you real-time intel from its three cameras.
I definitely see the potential in urban warfare to peak around corners, down alleys, into windows and over rooftops. But since we were discussing armed drones... maybe arm it with a poisoned needle and turn it into a bee-drone?
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on November 02, 2014, 10:30:53 AM
I definitely see the potential in urban warfare to peak around corners, down alleys, into windows and over rooftops.

That's exactly what it's for.


But since we were discussing armed drones... maybe arm it with a poisoned needle and turn it into a bee-drone?

This thread is called "Let's talk Drones" and the original poster stated the scope of the thread quite nicely. This nano-drone would be in the "reconnaissance" category.


With new drones rolling out it seems by the week for new and more complex tasks and purposes, it's been a common topic around 'hese parts talking about drones replacing pilots.


I figured we could all discuss our stances on them...

Here's my 2¢

Reconnaissance: Absolutely

Air to Ground Attack: Neutral on this point

Air to Air Combat: Never
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: GScholz on November 02, 2014, 11:10:46 AM
... maybe arm it with a poisoned needle and turn it into a bee-drone?

I do however like your idea... "The real-world applications are endless" as a callous weapons designer might say.  ;)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBxmck16FhA
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Flench on November 20, 2014, 04:40:43 PM
I should have mine back up and going in a few weeks . Been waiting on part's now for 40 day's . I know what they mean by or when one say's it's on a show boat from China now , lol .
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: BuckShot on December 13, 2016, 07:28:53 PM
I'm looking at several quadcopters in the $80 - $120 range. They all have cameras, some send video to a smartphone.

My Dad wants one from Santa.

Any suggestions based on experience with the entry level drones?

Thanks, ~S~ Buck
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Shuffler on December 13, 2016, 10:07:07 PM
I'm looking at several quadcopters in the $80 - $120 range. They all have cameras, some send video to a smartphone.

My Dad wants one from Santa.

Any suggestions based on experience with the entry level drones?

Thanks, ~S~ Buck

Those are toys. Entry level is a bit more expensive. DJI makes some good ones.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: BuckShot on December 13, 2016, 10:18:34 PM
I tried to get my work to buy a phantom 4...they wouldn't bite.

I'm looking for the toy.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Kanth on December 13, 2016, 10:18:53 PM
Buckshot,

I have this little guy

https://www.amazon.com/Ares-AZSZ2500-Ethos-Ready-QuadCopter/dp/B00O2EU4BK (https://www.amazon.com/Ares-AZSZ2500-Ethos-Ready-QuadCopter/dp/B00O2EU4BK)

It's a little bit above your range. It's VERY easy to fly once you get used to it.
I've also crashed it from pretty high up (many times) and all of the parts are pretty cheap to replace.
It comes with a small camera for flying that transmits to a small screen. I flew it just by sight .
I have some footage of the distances you can get with it. The video was shot by slinging a gopro.

I think he'd enjoy it, it's not very fragile. I tested  :devil

Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Kanth on December 13, 2016, 10:29:22 PM
it looks like it has a little brother that might be cool too. I haven't flown that one though.

http://ares-rc.com/ethosQX130/ (http://ares-rc.com/ethosQX130/)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: BuckShot on December 13, 2016, 10:44:17 PM
Thanks Kanth! I almost wish I didn't see that video...he he he...

I'm surprised it can haul a gopro.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Kanth on December 14, 2016, 07:29:29 AM
Ya it's pretty strong! it still has plenty of power.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Curval on December 15, 2016, 08:14:06 AM
Here's a couple of Instagram posts I did for our Guesthouse'saccount, done with a Phantom 4.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BN4-qg6BWk5/?taken-by=edgehillmanor

https://www.instagram.com/p/BMNYsQEh9a1/?taken-by=edgehillmanor

https://www.instagram.com/p/BL9rtaHBG8g/?taken-by=edgehillmanor
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Kanth on December 15, 2016, 08:23:48 AM
Beautiful place. The Phantom 4 gives quality video and is very stable.

They also have racer type quads which look like a lot of fun.

Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Shuffler on December 15, 2016, 09:43:20 AM
Here's a couple of Instagram posts I did for our Guesthouse'saccount, done with a Phantom 4.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BN4-qg6BWk5/?taken-by=edgehillmanor

https://www.instagram.com/p/BMNYsQEh9a1/?taken-by=edgehillmanor

https://www.instagram.com/p/BL9rtaHBG8g/?taken-by=edgehillmanor

USE caution there. If your drone is not licensed for commercial use then you can't use those shots. It would be illegal.

For commercial use, even your own, it has to be licensed as such if you are in the US.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Curval on December 15, 2016, 10:12:34 AM
Meh...catch me if they can.  :)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Shuffler on December 15, 2016, 11:51:56 AM
Meh...catch me if they can.  :)

Extremely expensive when they do. :)

Not to mention jail time.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Curval on December 16, 2016, 06:20:50 AM
All 3 of those posts were viewed and "liked" by the Premier.

I am not exactly hard to find here.

I have not sold any videos and the use of my drone is considered recreational.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Shuffler on December 16, 2016, 01:49:19 PM
All 3 of those posts were viewed and "liked" by the Premier.

I am not exactly hard to find here.

I have not sold any videos and the use of my drone is considered recreational.

Not recreational if you shoot footage for sales or ads. Even if you are doing it for yourself.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Curval on December 16, 2016, 03:40:07 PM
None of the footage is of our guest house.  What am I advertising?  Bermuda maybe.  I don't think ANYONE here would prosecute me for that.

:)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: -ammo- on December 16, 2016, 05:26:19 PM
Here's a couple of Instagram posts I did for our Guesthouse'saccount, done with a Phantom 4.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BN4-qg6BWk5/?taken-by=edgehillmanor (https://www.instagram.com/p/BN4-qg6BWk5/?taken-by=edgehillmanor)

https://www.instagram.com/p/BMNYsQEh9a1/?taken-by=edgehillmanor (https://www.instagram.com/p/BMNYsQEh9a1/?taken-by=edgehillmanor)

https://www.instagram.com/p/BL9rtaHBG8g/?taken-by=edgehillmanor (https://www.instagram.com/p/BL9rtaHBG8g/?taken-by=edgehillmanor)


Very nice.  I am amazed how good the video looks and how stable the platform is.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Curval on December 18, 2016, 10:33:23 AM
Some raw footage of a golf course which went into liquidation.  We were part of a group that bid on it and won.  Numbers mean it will never be viable as a golf course but we have a good plan that should keep everyone happy, from government to the existing home owners and to the tree huggers.  :)

I just got back.  I went into a panic and couldn't find my dog when I was at the end of the session, she was happy and content lying in the shade when I took off.  But she doesn't like the drone and you can see on the video that she headed straight for the car.  I found her lying under the tree nearest the car.  She never goes far but because I had the drone she wouldn't come back when I yelled and whistled for her.

https://www.skypixel.com/videos/e811890e-84b5-4c13-9fb8-50171f598028?utm_source=url&utm_medium=copied&utm_campaign=share

I have some other video too and will make a small film for our fellow investors.  :)
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Masherbrum on December 18, 2016, 12:21:52 PM
Not recreational if you shoot footage for sales or ads. Even if you are doing it for yourself.

He's in Bermuda and is, oh, well known around those parts?   Pretty sure if jail time were even in the picture (it isn't), Curval would be leaning back in a smoking jacket, sipping on brandy. 

What applies here in the States, has little to do with Bermuda.  Regardless, I am pretty sure these were under 400 feet and he had permission to film there.   
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Shuffler on December 18, 2016, 08:23:30 PM
None of the footage is of our guest house.  What am I advertising?  Bermuda maybe.  I don't think ANYONE here would prosecute me for that.

:)

From your original post I took it that you were advertising your guest house. Looks like you good to go. LOL

Burmuda is not in the US anyway.

DJI makes great equipment. We use the 3 pro here just for fun. The 4 is even better with a few minutes more air time and the sensors so it will not collide. Well it has less chance to collide.
Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: Curval on December 19, 2016, 04:37:33 AM
They just released the 4 Pro which has side, under, and back sensors now.  It also has more fly time than the 4.

I love flying my 4 though....it's like R/C for dummies.  My father was a huge R/C guy and I watched him crash numerous planes he built from scratch.  He would have LOVED these drones.

They do have strict rules here in point of fact but they have an enforcement issue.  If I went and flew over the City and buzzed people and was being dangerous....they would track me down.  The stuff I do might just get some of the commercial guys tee'd off...that is a risk.  I know most of them.  :)

I tried to fly once right at the end of the summer down at Grotto Bay Beach.  I couldn't understand why the drone was taking so long to connect to the GPS until I looked closely at the screen and realized the whole area was restricted.  I was about a mile from the airport.  I have no desire to get hurt, get into trouble or more importantly hurt anyone else. 

Title: Re: Let's talk Drones
Post by: NatCigg on December 19, 2016, 06:37:09 PM
I've been drawn in by the 400$ price tag on the P3 standard. Almost to cheap to avoid.  I want good range so the lightbridge seems like a must have upgrade. I see they sell the P3 pro refurbished with the mandatory extra battery for 750.  Another 200 and I get the P4.  Crappie, back to a thousand dollars and to much risk vs. ROI.   :bhead