Aces High Bulletin Board
General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Hazed on August 14, 2000, 05:59:00 PM
-
anyone checked out k/d in f4 compared to all other planes?
(http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif) no particular reason for post but hmmmmmm
-
Hazed,
This was in "least popular planes" topic, posted 8/8/00.
You could update the numbers for the past week if you were really interested! (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/wink.gif)
I'm not interested enough. (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/biggrin.gif)
Well, what happens when we focus on Air-to-Air kills?
Here's a view of the F4U-1C vs the FW190-A5 when you remove ground vehicles and the denfenseless C-47 (simply a big, slow target) from the Tour 7 stats.
F4U-1C
Totals 2316 Kills, 1359 Killed
then subtract ground vehicles and the defenseless flying target...
against M3 36/3
against Panzer 209/123
against M16 226/102
against C47 51/6
Totals 1794 Kills 1125 Killed
k/D is 1.59
Now the FW190-A5
Totals 2093 Kills 1336 Killed
against M3 23/13
against Panzer 13/35
against M16 103/58
against C47 34/2
Totals 1930 Kills 1228 Killed
K/D is 1.57
in an Air-to-Air engagement, the F4U-1C is clearly no more "Uber" than the FW-190-A5.
Now I'm of the opinion that if we are going to compare aircraft as FIGHTERS then we ought to subtract the M3, M16, Panzer and C-47 kills and then run the stats.
If you want to examine the ground attack capabilities, use just the M3, M16 & Panzer kills.
I wouldn't ever include the C-47, unless maybe it was in the "vs Target Drone" stats!
-
One thing you have to take into account is that the F4U-C is not "user friendly". The 190 is much easier to take off, fly and land it.
What am I getting at? Most of the kills the F4U-C get there are either from pilots who know the F4U (Torque, the VMF guys, etc) and do unreal stuff in it, or from those like me who manage to take off with it, get some alt, get like 3 or 4 snapshot kills and then die a very miserable death once we blow our E. In a CHOG I dont need to use ACM... just point, shoot, pray, hail mary! (snapshot kill) and then lawn dart or get shot down hehe.
I also see much more 190's going after buffs than F4U-C's. Maybe that will change someday hehehe.
-
Toad,
If you're not intested, what in the hell did ya post for??? (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif)
Can I have your Budwieser??
-
I'm not interested enough to run the numbers AGAIN, Swag!
(http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif)
Feel free to wear yourselves out though!
-
I have nothing against those who choose to fly the F4u-1c. (I'd rather fight one of them instead of a 190a5, that thing is incredible.) That said, I no longer fly it because it almost feels like cheating to be able to kill anything with just a couple pings. After flying the Hog-C for about 2 tours, I decided to learn the P51. Once I got used to it I found getting kills to be much more fun. You need to do more than just "point and click." (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/wink.gif) Not only that, but the .50s have some hidden advantages of their own that are often neglected. (Much better for high-G tracking shots.) (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif)
------------------
bloom25
THUNDERBIRDS
-
Originally posted by bloom25:
...I no longer fly it because it almost feels like cheating...
Totally agree, flought that during tour 1, but never more (except for testing).
-
Hazed, I flew this plane exclusivly in Tour 4 (5?) for analysis of its guns. Then they patched Aces High. IMO, they fixed the high lethality of the guns. However, within 400 yards, these guns will rip your wings off quite well, but so will the 190A8 with 4x20mm...so, whats your point?
Fly it for a tour, tell me if the Hispanos don't equalize the FM performance. BTW, the FM will apparently be fixed, so I salute all those before me that flew this pig before I became attached to it (F4U-1C and D model)
Incidently, when I flew the A8 for a tour, my K/D Ratio was equal in both planes, I flew them the same way...both are pigs in ATA when you have the disadvantage.
[This message has been edited by Ripsnort (edited 08-15-2000).]
-
Originally posted by Ripsnort:
...However, within 400 yards, these guns will rip your wings off quite well, but so will the 190A8 with 4x20mm...so, whats your point?
The point is that these guns will rip your wings off within 900 yards with great precission.
-
Originally posted by MANDOBLE:
The point is that these guns will rip your wings off within 900 yards with great precission.
Prove it, show me film. I have film downing a 900 yard A/C with my F4U, however, it took the ENTIRE magazine and he was flying straight and level, I believe you can do this in any P51 as well.
[This message has been edited by Ripsnort (edited 08-15-2000).]
-
At 300 yards, hispanos are as the should be: extremely lethal. So are the MG151/20. But at 600 yards, its a very diffeerent picture, the hispanos are very strong while mausers are almost impossiblle to kill with. Most people from my understanding dont have a problem with the hisps at close range, but perhaps their damage at medium to long range is a little high. It certainly is easier to get a kill at 700 yards in a f4u-1c than a 190a8.
-
Ah Toad! You're right! Pretty boring info!
(http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif)
-
Rip,
I respect all pilots in all rides, but lately < last 2 weeks> I have noticed more F4U drivers starting to shoot at D1.0 + . Last night at 2 different times, 2 different pilots < 1 bish, 1 rook >. I was pinged at D 800 < fuel leak >, and D1.0 < this guy was spraying from 1.4 to 1.0 on my FE, sorry but Dweebish > and caused a fuel leak on my beautiful, beloved G10! < Bastige, shot me on my ditch >. My point is this. One of the advantages of my G10 is her climbing ability. I love the roper dope and use climbing to my advantage. Many times planes come within D1.5 before they stall and I can pounce them. I would think 1500 METERS would be a safe distance between 2 planes. It's not with the cannon hog....Somethings wrong.
{The A8 does NOT have the amazing E retention the 1C has. There are more chances to bring your guns to bare in an 1C than an A8. Apples and Oranges}
BTW, I might have film of the D1.0 shot. I will check.
<S>
Ash
I./JG2
-
Swager....see I told ya! (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/wink.gif)
...and this argument will NEVER end.
At first K/D is used as the ultimate arbiter of "uberness".
You take out ground vehicles and target drones and suddenly K/D is an unreliable indicator of "uberness." LOL!
I'm glad it's a game........and ONLY a game.
Enjoy!
-
Ash, as I said in my post above:
"I have film downing a 900 yard A/C with my F4U, however, it took the ENTIRE magazine and he was flying straight and level, I believe you can do this in any P51 as well."
Me thinks its an ego thing, someone "thinks" they're safe at d1.0-d1.5, although the actual distance is probably d700 yards on the enmies FE. So, one gets shot down because they 'assumed' they were safe, thus, "The guns are porked!" statements.
Here's an easy fix, make D2.0 the 'safty margin' because I can kill you at D1.0 with both a HogC and a P51. (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif)
-
Originally posted by Ripsnort:
Incidently, when I flew the A8 for a tour, my K/D Ratio was equal in both planes, I flew them the same way...both are pigs in ATA when you have the disadvantage.
Rip the problem is that for each pilot who rides the F4U1C in the right way (as you, as Indian, As Apache, as Torque...) there are three that fly it as a pure and endless dweeb.
There are people here who use the F4U1C as a long range praying bird. People who dont mind firing half his rounds on 900 yard shots as long as they hit their prey...and of course if they hit it the prey falls from the sky in 2 or more pieces.
As a matter of fact I'll tell you a secret. First day I came here, first kill I got, was in a SpitfireIX near the Ex-field of F3. I killed the guy firing from 800 yards and hitting it when he was 1.1K away.2 pings and his wing went bye bye (as usually happens with hispanos)
Those days I also thought that the range was in feet not yards,so I wasnt surprised.
I repeat...FIRST DAY I CAME HERE. No rudder pedals and a yoke. 1K kill from a complete newbie who still was crashing one of two take offs.
That with a plane with 125rounds per cannon. The F4U1-C has 480,and 4 not 2 cannons.
now you see my point?. If a dweeb newbie Like the one I was can do that...with a bit of practice you will be the Turbolaser master.
And I can tell the name of a guy who flies a lot F4U1C in MA,who is here before I came, and whose only tactic is to climb to 25K, and start head oning low cons. no ACM no E-fighting. Simply HO and zoom away. He raises 3-4 kills this way on the MA, he has killed me a lot of times...still he has to kill me from anything near my 6.
THat is what C hog brings to AH. Dweebish-like pilots in quakehogs. No challenge here, simple HO and long range shooting.
As I told Apache the other day, F4U1-C is NOT a dweeb plane, but a plane flown by a lot of dweebs.
Damnit I raised a 4 kill sortie in F4UC the second time I flew it!!!! and I still had problems landing and taking off with a spit!!!
(http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/frown.gif)
[This message has been edited by RAM (edited 08-15-2000).]
-
I still don't understand your point, are you saying that the Hispanos are porked? The F4U-1C is porked? I thought we had this debate 2 months ago, prior to the fix?
Sounds to me like some ego's are getting shot down in this thread...I've flown all the planes in AH, and when I get shot down, I can in most cases base the death upon my own stupidity of A) Allowing myself to let a enemy get on my six, and B) not allowing enough distance and internal energy, thus allowing a plane to shoot me down.
I would guess that most cases mentioned involve one plane running and one plane chasing...I say "Bravo" to the guy who can accurately hit me at D1.0 or further, since I know it took a helluva lot of ammo to do so, whether he be in an F4U or a P51 or a A8.
If you don't like the historical fact that Hispanos were superior to the Mauser 20mm, then I suggest you either try to re-write history, or start flying planes with Hispano's, theres been enough evidence referenced to by the members of this community in the fire-power of Hispano's vs. Mausers.
[This message has been edited by Ripsnort (edited 08-15-2000).]
-
Ram:And I can tell the name of a guy who flies a lot F4U1C in MA,who is here before I came, and whose
only tactic is to climb to 25K, and start head oning low cons. no ACM no E-fighting. Simply HO and
zoom away. He raises 3-4 kills this way on the MA, he has killed me a lot of times...still he has to
kill me from anything near my 6.
Whats the difference between him and hristos in a G10, or Cita in a P38, doing the same thing???? And define a HO...it does take you to turn your nose to him for an HO, does it not?
BTW, that player you speak of has a 3 to 1 K/D ratio in the hog,(2.41 overall) which is not good compared to others in the hog.
[This message has been edited by Ripsnort (edited 08-15-2000).]
-
Originally posted by Ripsnort:
I still don't understand your point, are you saying that the Hispanos are porked? The F4U-1C is porked? I thought we had this debate 2 months ago, prior to the fix?
The hispanos do amazing amounts of damage with one ping. YEs they have been fixed. Before with one ping you went down. now there are 2 pings needed, at least. Big improvement, huh?.But well there is people saying that it *should* have this power, so I wont pull this thing any more.
No,rip, my point is not the C hog porked. nor the Hispanos porked. My point is that the simple presence of a stable aircraft (f4U) with 4 lazer cannons (hispanos) is a mix that makes gameplay a joke. Last week I have seen 1K+ shooting in a regular basis and I by myself have been killed that way multiple times.
THe thing is-the F4UC is destroying this game's fun. 1K kills have nothing to do with egos. no skill involved here rip. Only pray&spray.
IF a dweeb cant kill me in a close combat I dont understand why can he kill me at 1K when I am moving away while turning a bit.
The fact is: 1K kills were possible in RL, but not very probable.
With Chog here is the inverse. If you set a long convergence the 1K kill is probable.
Because range counters because no wind, because what you want. The fact is that those kind of kills and the HO dweebs are killing this game.Period.
Sounds to me like some ego's are getting shot down in this thread...I've flown all the planes in AH, and when I get shot down, I can in most cases base the death upon my own stupidity of A) Allowing myself to let a enemy get on my six, and B) not allowing enough distance and internal energy, thus allowing a plane to shoot me down.
I have flown, too all and every plane of the planeset. And I quite know to fly decent in each one ,except typhoon (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/biggrin.gif).
I agree with your A point.I disagree with your B point. You have read 3 times why so I wont repeat it.
And again no egos involved. Whenever I am killed by a skillful enemy in whatever plane, a S! is on the buffer in the same second as I die. Whenever I am killed at 1K from a spraying Hispanodweeb the second after it he gets a Dweeb! call on the buffer.
For each one what he earns. a S! or a DWEEB!.
Strange, that very few times I've been killed by top pilots in long range shots...Fariz is the last one I recall...
From 1K as he admitted. And with ONE shot.
I would guess that most cases mentioned involve one plane running and one plane chasing...
For me half the time it happens is when I am getting separation to start a vertical reverse (Hammerhead, immelmann, whatever)...
or in the vertical itself.
If you don't like the historical fact that Hispanos were superior to the Mauser 20mm, then I suggest you either try to re-write history, or start flying planes with Hispano's, theres been enough evidence referenced to by the members of this community in the fire-power of Hispano's vs. Mausers.
Most things I've read about hispanos here is about its high muzzle speed and good ballistics.
Nothing about its explosive performance.
Curious I have read a lot about Mauser's hitting powers(and saw a lot of photos too) on Bombers and I have read nothing like that about hispanos...
Maybe who is rewritting here the history is not me.
But...who knows?. my point is not the hispanos. My point is a plane that destroys AH's gameplay.
And F4U1-C does it.
-
I think the f4u-1c is a more than fair airplane versus fighters. It has shortcomgings that can be easily exploited. The one thing where the f4u-1c iss unfair IMHO is buff killing (they are much better buff killers than the german birds, both tougher and better armed) and tank busting; For air 2 air engagements, while the hispanos have good hitting power, i can usually avoid them unless it is a very skilled pilot, in which case he derserves to shoot me down.
Just don't say mausers are just as good as hispanos. They aren't. But they shouldn't be either. The mausers i the 190 have crappy ROF due to syncronization and they are slower round. They SHOULD be weaker. I am no B-17 pilot by any means, but i went buff hunting in a f4u several times and it was much easier than in a luftwaffe bird. Which kinda takes the fun historical aspect out of the game. For me, it was fun to scramble with StSanta and Coop and other knights all in g10s to intercept a incoming bish B17 raid because it felt more historical. Unfortunately, the best interceptor isn't a german bird.
-
THe thing is-the F4UC is destroying this game's fun. 1K kills have nothing to do with egos. no skill involved here rip. Only pray&spray.
But the guy running from the F4U-1C is using skill? ROTFLOL!!!
-
And F4U1-C does it.
Oh, the F4U-1C does it all? Have you flown it an entire tour?
It sucks in climbing, A5 blows it away in climbs.
It sucks in turning, A5, again, can out turn it.
It can't run from half the planes in AH nor can it dive away from half the planes in AH...
So, whats it good at again? Ah, Cannons...hispanos at that, the same guns on the Spit...except X4, which is twice the hitting power of a spit.
A5 IMO is the ultimate Dweeb plane. But you won't catch me acting like a 5 year old calling my death a "Dweeb shot"...
[This message has been edited by Ripsnort (edited 08-15-2000).]
-
Originally posted by Ripsnort:
But the guy running from the F4U-1C is using skill? ROTFLOL!!!
Uh...yeah. for me the thing that makes me not have a high K/D is that I never know when to let the engagement. So I stay with 4-1 odds too much time.
To know WHEN to disengage in combat is too part of the flying skills.
IMO, of course.
BTW many 1K kills happen to me when I am BnZooming.
I am sure you never BnZ eh rip? 'cause is a lack of skill.
uh,yeah.
-
Originally posted by Ripsnort:
Oh, the F4U-1C does it all? Have you flown it an entire tour?
YEs I did. Dont remember the K/D ratio but for a guy who doesnt know to takeoff wasnt that bad.
It can't run from half the planes in AH nor can it dive away from half the planes in AH...
Is the 4th faster plane on the deck, the third forgetting the Typhoon (no need to run more than this one, BTW). It can outrun anything but a G10 and P51 on the deck...
and they have problems to do it.
Cannons...hispanos at that, the same guns on the Spit...except X4, which is twice the hitting power of a spit.
that is exactly for me the reason because the spitfire is the second dweeb plane on AH.
A5 IMO is the ultimate Dweeb plane. But you won't catch me acting like a 5 year old calling my death a "Dweeb shot"...
Because I am sure you'll never see a 190 firing at 1K.
BTW A5 dweeb plane?...lol
But well is your opinion (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif)
-
Dammo people, bash Hristo all ya want, but for the gods sakes, do it for the right reasons.
Hristo's kills come 90% from the rear, and he's been quite vocal about "no HO's guys" when we've flown with him.
I know how he flies. I am his wingie, and we've flown quite a few sorties together.
Many perceive him as an arrogant bastard who gloats over his kills. Fine; you're entitled to your opinions. But that has nothing to do with how he flies, and he does not, like the other famous F4U driver (I know who (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/biggrin.gif)) just reverse for the HO or go for the HO every time.
These are just the facts. And, I have films to back up my words.
------------------
StSanta
JG54 "Grünherz"
"If you died a stones throw from your wingie; you did no wrong". - Hangtime
-
Hey Ram, nothing personal, okay? Its just that when this topic was brought up before, I went out and tested the F4U-1C, and consistently got deadly hits with my drone friend at D1.1-D1.5. After the fix I can get strikes at D1.0, but it takes ALOT of ammo,and ALOT of 'hit sprites' to do so now, so, IMO, they fixed something.
The Hog D and C are at quite a disadvantage against alot of fighters in AH, so, having 4X 20 hispanos seems to equalize it.
I'm outta here for two weeks, so take care, fly fast, and keep D2.0 between you and the bandit! <S>
Santa, I was referring to the HO shot itself, some do it more than others, but it TAKES TWO to get killed...I can successfully avoid ALL HO shots today...and I do, unless I'm out of options (low and slow) I simply referred to good pilots vs rookies who spray and pray, the fact being, if you get HO's, its your damn fault.
------------------
Ripsnort(-rip1-)
=CO= VMF-323 ~Death Rattlers~
"Know your limits and then go beyond.."
Click here for VMF-323 Death Rattlers info (http://Ripsnort60.tripod.com/vmf323inquirer.html)
Click here for 15th Panzer info (http://Ripsnort60.tripod.com/panzerinquirer.html)
(http://ripsnort60.tripod.com/ripsnort323.gif)
I spare no class or cult or creed,
My course is endless through the year.
I bow all heads and break all hearts,
All owe homage-I am Fear.
-------------General Patton
[This message has been edited by Ripsnort (edited 08-15-2000).]
-
THe thing is-the F4UC is destroying this game's fun. 1K kills have nothing to do with egos. no skill involved here rip. Only pray&spray Yes Ram and there is skill involved in a G10 climb or run tactic, or 1905 warp induced barrel rolls. The F4u pilot is a dweeb for using his adv but the G10 pilot is an ace when he just runs and climbs.
-
Rip,
You can't have alot of ego flying the G10 and I always check my ego in the tower when I fly. But, I'm surprized you think a 1000 meter < >3000 feet! > or even a 700 meter < >2100 feet! > snap shot should be the norm and not the exception for this sim. I have nothing but respect for everyone that has posted here. You folks are the best F4U1X pilots on line. I don't think anyone is trying to minimize any pilots skill or capability. Especially those posting here. However, everyone's ego aside, including yours Rip, the F4U1C's 20mm are just too lethal.
OTR,
Ash
I./JG2
-
Ash, with all due respect, re-read my posts, I said it takes all my ammo to down a plane at D1.0 !! And even at that, its not a garanteed kill.
To state that the Chogs guns are overmodeled is to say that the Spit guns, the Typhoon guns and the Chogs guns are overmodeled.
-
you people realize how unrealistic being able to even discern 800 yards from 1000 is in the first place?
the icon is the problem the laser rangefinder must go and with it will go head ons and other dweeb tactics.
-
Swager, was I right? (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/biggrin.gif)
Cit, I'd love to see icons overhauled but there's also other cues. For example, there's a "shape change" at almost exactly 1k to that could be used as a range cue.
OK, back to the mudslinging guys!
Make those bastiges fly the way you think they should fly!
Hey! Every week lets vote to throw a plane out of the planeset! We'll call it "Aces High Survivor"! Should be way cool by the end of the year...and think of all the work it'll save HTC.
I love this thread! I really, really do! (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/biggrin.gif)
-
P-38 has, I beleive, a single Hispano MkII 20mm cannon. (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/wink.gif)
Sisu
-Karnak
-
Problem: F4U-1Cs guns are "too powerful".
Solution: Don't get in front of the damned thing.
Tip of the day: Go read Shaw's Fighter Combat: Tactics and Manuevering. Study the diagrams, and use them in Aces High. Your survival increases 40%.
-SW
ps: Anyone noticed you don't see as many F4U-1Cs in the arena since the P47 and Fw-190A5 came around? Hmmmmm.... :-)
-
Do you think those guys who fly the f4u1c do so out of adoration or reverence for the plane ? Do you think that they have models of f4u1c's and books about them at home . Or are they simple trying to do better at a game ? I know that it's their 30 bucks, I just wonder sometimes .
-
Originally posted by Torque:
Yes Ram and there is skill involved in a G10 climb or run tactic, or 1905 warp induced barrel rolls. The F4u pilot is a dweeb for using his adv but the G10 pilot is an ace when he just runs and climbs.
First of all Torque I have stated several times you are the best F4U1-C driver in his game. Nothing personal here.
Second, the G10,well flown, doesnt run. The climb is another thing because it is one of its strengths. When you are in your F4U I'm sure that if someone bounces you you'll start the close diving spiral with flaps and gear down to force an overshot no? is one of the strenghts of the F4U. Well G10's climb is its strenght. So YES there is skill in a climbing G10, most of the time.
About the warp rolls I still have to see one. THe only plane that I usually see doing weird little warps is the C205. and I know many people sees the same, still have to hear a strong thing about it like that "warp roll" of the A5.
Remember too that F4U has a rollrate near that of the A8, in fact at very high speed it has a higher rollrate than A8 and A5...
So well...
If the only advantage of the F4U1-C is its guns killing at 1K, excuse me torque, but then you must erase it from the planeset.
But as we both know that it isnt true, then dont come here telling that 1K kills and HO is the only way a Hog can be a good fighter.
Ask Duckwing if you think that way...or Lephturn. They both fly the D hog, they both do wonders with it.
-
wow didnt realise this would spark off such a heated discussion.
i was merely thinking that 4000 odd kills to 2000 odd deaths shows its easier to kill with than other planes with (average) 3000 to 2000
i think it a hard plane to fly well but it sure is easy to kill with if you get on someones 6.Now if i was a better pilot than the average id fly a harder plane..hell i fly 109g2 and im crap (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif) .o490 hit % last time i looked.why do pilots with excellent shooting skills need such powerfull guns?
id just like to say this is an opinion and i didnt want to get anyone annoyed but when im killed by F4's it annoys me sometimes to the point where i take a break to cool off (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/smile.gif) ..no other plane has that effect on me.make your own conclusions.
i must also say that the talk of the f4 being accurate to how it really was is important but it was not used very much in the european theatre so its unrealistic to face them so often when flying LW planes
i prefer to fight p51s and p38s and spits because that more closely mimics reality
(http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/wink.gif)
[This message has been edited by Hazed (edited 08-15-2000).]