Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aircraft and Vehicles => Topic started by: tommygun on July 11, 2007, 07:45:02 PM

Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: tommygun on July 11, 2007, 07:45:02 PM
Many of you have said the P38G can be a very good fighter in a turn fight against Zero's and others. What about the P38L?:confused:
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Viking on July 11, 2007, 08:06:54 PM
No P-38 is good in a turn fight with a Zeke. The 38G is the lightest of the Lightnings, but it's still a pig.
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Viking on July 11, 2007, 08:09:03 PM
Check out this site: http://www.gonzoville.com/ahcharts/index.php


Seems the site is down at the moment. Check later.
Title: Re: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: CAP1 on July 11, 2007, 09:07:02 PM
Quote
Originally posted by tommygun
Many of you have said the P38G can be a very good fighter in a turn fight against Zero's and others. What about the P38L?:confused:


from what i'm told, the 38G is the best in a slow turnfight....and i have been succesefull in it a couple of times. but ya need to remember...it has no wep, and isn't too fast.

 now, in benny moore's 8 player room, i fought him me in a 38J him in an L....and he handed my but to me.......then explained why the L was better....with its boosted aielrons.......but if you're lookin to kill spits, an zekes....ya might not wanna turn with them...they both have significantly smaller turn radiuses than any of the 38's........i don't slow down with either of them anymore in the 38..........

<>

john
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: ForrestS on July 11, 2007, 10:52:33 PM
You can kill any plane with the 38L u just have to be very good at knowing your plane and predicting what there going to do.

For example you can out climb a zero with a P38L.

It also accelerates faster than a zero.

It has basicly 2 of everything. And all of its guns are on the nose so aiming is very easy.

It has hydrolicly boosted ailerons so it turns very good at high speed. Beware tho it can compress.

FYI u HAVE to use flaps in a turning dogfight. Just stay right above the stalling speed.

I often get in a turning dogfight and realize i cant win so i raise my flaps and out run or out climb the enemy.


O ya Yamamoto was killed by a P-38
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: CAP1 on July 11, 2007, 11:34:07 PM
Quote
Originally posted by ForrestS
You can kill any plane with the 38L u just have to be very good at knowing your plane and predicting what there going to do.

For example you can out climb a zero with a P38L.

1)maybe i misjudged their E, but where i manage to climb till i'm hanging on flaps waiting till the bogie stalls below me, the zeke is ALWAYS right there shootin me

It also accelerates faster than a zero.

2)i'll have to try that.....i didn't think that much weight could........

It has basicly 2 of everything. And all of its guns are on the nose so aiming is very easy.

3) would you believe i find aiming with wing guns a bit easier? biggest advantage to nose guns to me, is if i have a bogie running, i can sometimes hit him at 1k, making him do things to dodge..which normally lets me get closer.......

It has hydrolicly boosted ailerons so it turns very good at high speed. Beware tho it can compress.

4)the boosted aielrons make a BIG difference

FYI u HAVE to use flaps in a turning dogfight. Just stay right above the stalling speed.

5)i've done ok with this in the G, but never in the J or L......if anyone can give pointers, or asistance?
 

I often get in a turning dogfight and realize i cant win so i raise my flaps and out run or out climb the enemy.
6)i got into a fight like that against a spit..i think it was a 9, but not really sure...he came at me with alt, i dodged, and got a quick snap on him..only light pings i saw though......but he stayed in the fight rather than goin back up....i was able to hold his 6, but without fail, just as i was managing to pull enough lead to fire, he semed to be able to gain some ground....we repeated this for about 2 minutes, and i noticed a buddy of his comming in.....so as we were comming round towards his base, he reversed the turn from left to right..i continued left till i was headed home, pulled up flaps, hit wep and ran very bravely!


O ya Yamamoto was killed by a P-38
YES!!

<>
john
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: ForrestS on July 12, 2007, 12:12:19 AM
wait?:huh

Were you compliminting me or insulting me?
Title: Re: Re: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Ack-Ack on July 12, 2007, 01:13:09 AM
Quote
Originally posted by CAP1

 now, in benny moore's 8 player room, i fought him me in a 38J him in an L....and he handed my but to me.......then explained why the L was better....with its boosted aielrons.......but if you're lookin to kill spits, an zekes....ya might not wanna turn with them...they both have significantly smaller turn radiuses than any of the 38's........i don't slow down with either of them anymore in the 38..........

<>

john



Take whatever Benny says about the P-38 and how to fly the P-38 with a very large grain of salt.  

The only reason why he beat you while flying the L and you in the J was because he was the better pilot.  It had nothing to do with the boosted ailerons on the P-38.

As for turn fighting with a Zeke, the P-38 can hang with it for about a turn or so, maybe 2 if the P-38 pilot is good enough.  After that, the Zeke is going to be all over the P-38 in a turn fight, no matter the Lightning model or pilot skill.  

If you do find yourself in a turn fight, the best place to be is on the deck and in a stall fight.  You'll probably lose but if you throw in vertical maneuvers like stall loops, you may live long enough to get a quick snap deflection shot or get away.  The P-38 has a better stall characteristics and isn't fighting torque and also has better acceleration and climb rate so you can almost disengage at will.  It's best to use Energy tactics such as Boom and Zoom or one of the various Rope-A-Dopes when fighting the Zeke.


ack-ack
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: CAP1 on July 12, 2007, 05:15:32 PM
Quote
Originally posted by ForrestS
wait?:huh

Were you compliminting me or insulting me?


neither.........simply mentioning my experiences in it, and kinda fishing for more information....i try to learn as much as i can before going up so i can try to put it to use:aok

if you took it as an insult, i do apologize..i didn't intend it that way:aok
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: ForrestS on July 12, 2007, 11:35:25 PM
No its ok. :D

Was i wrong about anything i said?
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Guppy35 on July 12, 2007, 11:46:01 PM
38G is a different animal then the 38L

I have no problem killing 38Ls with the G if the 38L driver makes the mistake of turning with the lighter G.

If he flies smart and uses his speed and climb, he can control the fight.

But the majority of players in the arenas don't fly to their strengths and get sucked into doing things they shouldn't against planes that can kill them if they fly the way that plane works best.

38G vs a Zero is the same thing.  If you get sucked into turning slow with a Zeke you are dead.  You can turn at higher speeds with him, but you have to avoid getting too slow.  Like any 38 vs the Zeke you use the speed and climb to control things.

That being said, I turn with Spits consistantly.  Had a 1 v 2 against 2 Spit 8s on the deck last night and augered one and shot down the other even though they bounced me.

You can turn with N1Ks, Ki-84s etc in the G as well.

Again I have to qualify that by saying a good stick in either of those birds will play it differently and the outcome can be different.

I havent flown tons this tour, but so far this average 38G stick is:

10-2 against Spit 16s
7-0 against Spit 8s
10-3 against N1Ks
3-1 against Ki-84s
6-1 against AM65bs

Anyone who flies with me will tell ya I'm below em to start and turning on the deck with em 99% of the time too.
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Masherbrum on July 13, 2007, 12:33:40 AM
I agree with Ack-Ack and Corky.
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Bronk on July 13, 2007, 04:32:28 AM
Quote
Originally posted by Guppy35


I havent flown tons this tour, but so far this average 38G stick is:

10-2 against Spit 16s
7-0 against Spit 8s
10-3 against N1Ks
3-1 against Ki-84s
6-1 against AM65bs

Anyone who flies with me will tell ya I'm below em to start and turning on the deck with em 99% of the time too.


It's his gunnery technique....

























Spray and pray.:D


Bronk
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: dedalos on July 13, 2007, 01:02:35 PM
Quote
Originally posted by Guppy35

You can turn with N1Ks, Ki-84s etc in the G as well.
 


Nop :p
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: balance1 on July 13, 2007, 02:13:33 PM
well me, I like the the G better and according to drgonzo's flight stuff it is (turning wise) superior to the J or L, and I just like it better, BUT I also LOVE the P-47D-11, yes I am a jug man, and after looking in the flight comparisons I was shocked to discover the P-47D-11 is superior to the P-38G in all ways exept climb rate!  but anyway I say fly the 38G, I like it better anyway.
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Masherbrum on July 13, 2007, 04:39:11 PM
Quote
Originally posted by dedalos
Nop :p
I can turn with those rides in a Ki61, but I have done it with a G.   "It's all about the angle of attack".
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Ack-Ack on July 13, 2007, 04:53:18 PM
Quote
Originally posted by Masherbrum
I can turn with those rides in a Ki61, but I have done it with a G.   "It's all about the angle of attack".


I think people confuse the term "turn fight" to mean just turning in flat circles when it actually refers to turning to get an angle.  Which is why its also referred to as Angles Fighting which is the more accurate term.

And I agree, it's all about the angle of attack.  That's how the P-38 is able to get the better of some of the better turning fighters.


ack-ack
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Masherbrum on July 13, 2007, 05:03:08 PM
Quote
Originally posted by Ack-Ack
I think people confuse the term "turn fight" to mean just turning in flat circles when it actually refers to turning to get an angle.  Which is why its also referred to as Angles Fighting which is the more accurate term.

And I agree, it's all about the angle of attack.  That's how the P-38 is able to get the better of some of the better turning fighters.


ack-ack
:aok
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Guppy35 on July 13, 2007, 07:20:13 PM
Quote
Originally posted by dedalos
Nop :p


Seems to me we split it 2-2 when you and I went at it in your Ki-84 and my 38G?  Still have those films too :)
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: DoLbY on July 13, 2007, 08:24:16 PM
This is definetly not my field when it comes to the 38 but I've always (well, normally) had good fights in the ''L'' model :aok
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: Hoarach on July 13, 2007, 08:48:32 PM
Well the G you cant see out of compared to the L.  The L does have the boosted ailerons but its heavier.  The L also has wep which will help out depending how long the fight goes.  The G turns tighter than the L.  I prefer my L though as I just have better luck in it.

Im still out to prove the L can be used for something besides suicidal porking.
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: clerick on July 14, 2007, 09:03:18 AM
Quote
Originally posted by Guppy35
I havent flown tons this tour, but so far this ABOVE -average 38G stick is


There Dan, i fixed your typo.
Title: P38G vrs P38L
Post by: clerick on July 14, 2007, 09:05:01 AM
Quote
Originally posted by balance1
yes I am a jug man...,


I'm more of a leg and hips man myself.