Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Hardware and Software => Topic started by: Halo46 on March 20, 2008, 03:06:20 PM

Title: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Halo46 on March 20, 2008, 03:06:20 PM
Greetings All,

I hope to take advantage of your combined intellect and knowledge base. Listed below are the components I have put together for my new rig. This is my first build so if something looks amiss let me know as well please. It was my intention to use an Intel Core 2 Duo E8400 Wolfdale CPU with it, but I missed the chance when Tiger Direct and Newegg ran out of stock.

I am looking for an equal/similar alternative option while staying in the same price range or a contact for where to find the E8400 (that is not priced $500.00 as I hope to get a new monitor as well) so I can purchase next month. Any help will be appreciated. Thanks.


Antec 900 case
Intel BOXD975BX2KR LGA 775 Intel 975X ATX Intel Motherboard
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3250310AS 250GB 700 RPM SATA 3.0 Gb/s Hard Drive
Ballistix Tracer 240 pin DIMM (with LEDs), DDR2 PC2 5300 memorymodule BL2KIT12864AL663 2 X 2 GBs
GeForce 8800GT superclocked 512MB GRRR3 PCI E Vid card
Sound Blaster X Fi xtremegamer sound card
Windows XP PRO with SP2C OEM
Liteon 52x32x52 CD/DVD Combo Drive
Ultra X-Connect 500-Watt ATX Dual 80MM Fan Titanium-Black UV Clear Sides Modular Power Supply

Currently this will be primarily a gaming computer. I do not about the future.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Condor on March 20, 2008, 03:18:57 PM
Intel E6750 appears to the best bang for the buck at $189 (NewEgg).  I'm doing my first buils also and that's whatI will buy unless E8400 CPUs become available at a decent price in the next couple of weeks.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: HomeBoy on March 20, 2008, 03:46:45 PM
Halo,
I agree with Condor about the 6750.  That's a pretty decent alternative to the 8400.  You could do a 6850 for about the price of an 8400 which is an even better choice for a little more money.

What is your thinking on the Intel mobo?   Are you wanting to keep SLI as a possibility?   Are you wanting X38 so PCI-e 2.0 is there?  If neither of those are that important to you, you might want to look at the Abit IP35 Pro mobo?   It's on rebate right now at newegg for $135.   It gets great reviews and you can't beat that price.  I don't know much about the Intel board.  I've had both Abit and Asus and both of them are great for overclocking.  Overclocking will buy you time down the road.

I would try to talk you into going to a Raptor as a system drive.  I used to do RAID0 all the time and a Raptor is just as good without the complexity of the second drive.  Performance is way greater than a 7200 RPM drive.  Course you could RAID0 two Raptors for some insane performance (I guess, I've never tried that).

That Ballistix Tracer memory is great for overclocking and you can't do better than the GeForce 8800GT.  That Antec 900 is absolutely the best deal on a case you can find.  Your PS might be on the light end of things especially if SLI is in the upgrade path down the road.

Looks like a great system the way it is though.   I'm just making some comments.  If you buy exactly what you've listed you'd have a great system.

Good luck.
-hb
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Halo46 on March 20, 2008, 04:40:02 PM
Thanks guys, appreciate the input. The components have all been purchased minus the CPU. I got the PS for only 29 dollars so figured I would upgrade in the future and SLI is what I am looking forward to in future as well. Rapter sounds interesting, will need to learn more about that. Thanks alot, I will check out those CPUs.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Dragon on March 21, 2008, 02:38:49 PM
I'm using the 6750 also due to best bang for the buck, even with Vista Home Pro, it's very quick.  I almost got the Ball mem with the lights, but as I have a closed box, saved the 70 bucks and went without.  I don't know if was my board (ASUS P5nesli) or not but I had problems loading XP with 2 gig of RAM.  Recommend using 1 stick till all programs and updates are installed, then add second. 
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Getback on March 21, 2008, 03:43:52 PM
Halo,

I use the Abit pro. It seems awfully good for the bucks. I also have the E8400. I purchased it for $211 and it was originally suppose to be for $183 from some artilces I have read. If I were buying today and I had the money I would get the E8400 again. You just wouldn't believe it. It runs cooler than a cucumber and seems to be able to handle the onboard sound with out stuttering. I didn't buy a sound card and I have the best sound I ever had. So put back the sound card and splurge on the chip. If for some reason you need the sound card later you can buy it then.

I saw the chip at a site for $211 but guess what it was sold out.

I really wish you could sit at my computer and play AH. You would be a believer! My kill ratio has improved, my hit % has improved and it's just a lot more fun.

That's all I know and I hoped I helped.

Best wishes on the build.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Condor on March 21, 2008, 03:47:22 PM
If only the E8400 were avaialble  Those vendors who don't state up fron that it is out of stock specify a 6 to 12 week delivery time. 
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Getback on March 21, 2008, 04:29:45 PM
If only the E8400 were avaialble  Those vendors who don't state up fron that it is out of stock specify a 6 to 12 week delivery time. 

I'd wait. It's that good.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: humble on March 21, 2008, 04:40:09 PM
Thanks guys, appreciate the input. The components have all been purchased minus the CPU. I got the PS for only 29 dollars so figured I would upgrade in the future and SLI is what I am looking forward to in future as well. Rapter sounds interesting, will need to learn more about that. Thanks alot, I will check out those CPUs.

The original "X-connects" didnt come with a PCI-e power connection. Basically they were designed when the AGP standard was in vogue. In addition they have a single 12V 34@ rail with no active PFC. They also didnt have a 24 pin supply to ther MB if I recall (you'd need to check on that). I've owned to ultra PS's and wasnt overly impressed by either. I had one in my gaming box for awhile and literally just tossed it one day on overall "feel"....didnt even bother keeping it for a lesser box.

There are alot of good resonably cheap PS's out there. The lastthing you want to do is toast a good build on a bad choice in power supply. Running a gaming rig on a power supply just because you got it cheap might turn into a $500+ mistake. You can get a good PS for $70 or so...use the X-connect as a doorstop and get something reasonable....just my 2 cents...
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: TX58 on March 21, 2008, 08:39:49 PM
 Might try the Xeon E3110. It is supposed to be the exact same chip. http://www.circuitremix.com/index.php?q=node/122 (http://www.circuitremix.com/index.php?q=node/122)
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Getback on March 21, 2008, 08:46:50 PM
http://www.excaliberpc.com/Intel_BX80570E3110_Xeon_E3110_3.00GHz/BX80570E3110/partinfo-id-584805.html


Found a site that has the xeon 3110. I found several sites that said it is the same as the e8400.

Whew! that took some doing to find it. According to the the site, they have 95 in stock.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: TX58 on March 21, 2008, 08:47:03 PM
 BTW The E3110 is gettin hard to find, as word gets out but, they are currently in stock here http://www.excaliberpc.com/Intel_BX80570E3110_Xeon_E3110_3.00GHz/BX80570E3110/partinfo-id-584805.html (http://www.excaliberpc.com/Intel_BX80570E3110_Xeon_E3110_3.00GHz/BX80570E3110/partinfo-id-584805.html)

 Whoops Getback beat me to it.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Getback on March 21, 2008, 08:48:36 PM
 :lol :lol Tx we found the same site. Makes me feel good about my efforts.

Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Halo46 on March 21, 2008, 09:37:12 PM
thanks fellas for all the info and advice. I am going to check them out for sure. Humble, you were talking about the PS, I don't know much about them and used the online power calculater at Newegg, it recomended 450 watts, I will take another look at that.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Getback on March 22, 2008, 09:40:49 AM
BTW The E3110 is gettin hard to find, as word gets out but, they are currently in stock here http://www.excaliberpc.com/Intel_BX80570E3110_Xeon_E3110_3.00GHz/BX80570E3110/partinfo-id-584805.html (http://www.excaliberpc.com/Intel_BX80570E3110_Xeon_E3110_3.00GHz/BX80570E3110/partinfo-id-584805.html)

 Whoops Getback beat me to it.

That would be by a very small fraction of a second. When I posted mine and went back to review it yours was there too.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: humble on March 22, 2008, 04:45:07 PM
thanks fellas for all the info and advice. I am going to check them out for sure. Humble, you were talking about the PS, I don't know much about them and used the online power calculater at Newegg, it recomended 450 watts, I will take another look at that.

This is the power supply I think you have...

http://www.ultraproducts.com/product_details.php?cPath=37&pPath=157&productID=157 (http://www.ultraproducts.com/product_details.php?cPath=37&pPath=157&productID=157)

If so it has no 24 pin connector for MB and no PCI-e 6 pin 12V connector either. So if your 8800 needs an additional 6 pin 12V conection your out of luck. The 34@ on the 12V rail should be plenty but I'd have to double check based on how much the 8800 actually draws...the 12V rail can draw up to 408W's so if the card has alot of draw and you choose a CPU that draws 125W+ underload then your in trouble since I dont see any indication that the 500W is continuous power and not a more phoney "peak power" rating. what makes this worse is the fac that if you add it up the card "offers" 650W across all rails...if it had 500Ws of continous power this would be "OK" but you might have a PS that has 500W peak and only 450 or so continous.

Any CPU drawing more then 92Ws is technically under powered on the 3.3V rail I think (anyone who knows for sure clarify or correct me) further if you can draw the 125W that I read on toms some of these draw at peak then you only have 375Ws total...just take out another 25Ws to run everything else and you 've got 350W for the 12V rail which is just under 30@'s...but if you only produce 450 continous watts then you only have 300W's fro the 12V rail which is 25@'s which I think is under minimum recommendation for the 8800 series. So you have a PS that might cause issues with many of the CPU's (the 8400 only draws about 65W's however) and the VC you have.

Its not about "watts" its all about amps on the required rail. Multiply the volts X @'s to get the watts on each rail and look for continious power ratings. A good 500W continious power PS is often better then some "phoney math" 650 or 700W PS's...
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: BaldEagl on March 23, 2008, 04:56:28 AM
You'll need somewhere in the mid to upper 30's in amperage on the 12V rails to run a 8800 card (plus some extra for the rest of the system).  If you don't have it you'll likely experience BSOD's or black screens under load.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Halo46 on March 23, 2008, 02:43:45 PM
Thanks for all the info guys, appreciate it a lot.
Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Getback on March 25, 2008, 04:47:40 PM
NewEgg.com will have the E8400 available on Friday, March 28, 2008. I doubt if it lasts long.

Title: Re: Alternate CPU Options
Post by: Halo46 on March 31, 2008, 01:47:51 PM
Alright guys, thanks for the input. The local Fry's has them for around $225, will pick one up in the am...thanks again.