Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Gaboon on November 13, 2008, 10:17:14 PM

Title: P-51B and D models
Post by: Gaboon on November 13, 2008, 10:17:14 PM
I was just reading through some threads and in game I would have to say the P-51 is by far the best plane in the game. At speed and 1 notch a flaps it will turn on a dime. The ammo load is very good and if your a crack shot the kills will pile up fast. The fuel load out is the key to its performance in my opinion. I usually took a load out of 75% with drop tanks for bomber hunting and 50 to 75% for fighter cap sweeps. My longest mission was 1 hour and 47 minutes with 15 bombers and 6 fighters with out rearming. Most kill mission with out rearming was 23 being 6 bombers and 17 fighters. In the hands of a good stick the Pony is near unbeatable. Best pony pilot I ever came across is Steve. The hubbub about the F4u is quite true the flight model is stretched as thin as a rubber band but still I'll fly the Pony over any others. I must say this though I have flown the f4u4 and I landed 15 and still had a ton of ammo left. I am not sure of what the ammo load out difference is between the Pony and the Hog but i'll still take the Pony.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: MjTalon on November 13, 2008, 10:58:53 PM
15 Bombers without re arming.... :lol


INteresting
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Shane on November 13, 2008, 11:08:36 PM
15 Bombers without re arming.... :lol


INteresting



welllllllll... it is possible if he took out the lead bomber and the drone(s) went in as freebies...

maybe it was in offline mode?   or an old H2H room  :noid



Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Larry on November 13, 2008, 11:12:26 PM


welllllllll... it is possible if he took out the lead bomber and the drone(s) went in as freebies...

maybe it was in offline mode?   or an old H2H room  :noid





Or vulches.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 13, 2008, 11:12:53 PM
I was just reading through some threads and in game I would have to say the P-51 is by far the best plane in the game. At speed and 1 notch a flaps it will turn on a dime. The ammo load is very good and if your a crack shot the kills will pile up fast. The fuel load out is the key to its performance in my opinion. I usually took a load out of 75% with drop tanks for bomber hunting and 50 to 75% for fighter cap sweeps. My longest mission was 1 hour and 47 minutes with 15 bombers and 6 fighters with out rearming. Most kill mission with out rearming was 23 being 6 bombers and 17 fighters. In the hands of a good stick the Pony is near unbeatable. Best pony pilot I ever came across is Steve. The hubbub about the F4u is quite true the flight model is stretched as thin as a rubber band but still I'll fly the Pony over any others. I must say this though I have flown the f4u4 and I landed 15 and still had a ton of ammo left. I am not sure of what the ammo load out difference is between the Pony and the Hog but i'll still take the Pony.

Thanks for the  kind word.  1v1, I think the f4u is a better plane but the 51 has some very sweet points and is well suited to the MA: great views, stellar high speed handling, long legs.  23 kills, in one clip out does my best by far, that's impressive. My best in one clip is 13 or 14.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Gaboon on November 13, 2008, 11:29:26 PM
Killing bombers is one thing i know how to do and do it very well if you dont believe me just ask 999ooo and his bomber mate I am sure they will vouch for my bomber attack tactics. If you have patience and know how to attack a bomber it will go down and you wont be touched 99% of the time. Airjer was one of those 15 bombers that day ask him also. Agood aim comes into play also most of my fighter kills are on very short burst taking a wing off or dead in the head on high deflection shot.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Saxman on November 14, 2008, 12:03:13 AM
Gaboon,

Ammunition loadouts are as follows:

F4U-1/1A4x400rds/gun and 2x375rds/gun
F4U-1C2x230rds/gun and 2x232rds/gun
F4U-1D/46x400rds/gun
P-51B2x280rds/gun and 2x350rds/gun
P-51D6-gun package: 4x270rds/gun and 2x400rds/gun
4-gun package: 2x500rds/gun and 2x400rds/gun
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Lusche on November 14, 2008, 12:05:10 AM
What's your ingame handle Gaboon?
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Gaboon on November 14, 2008, 12:12:37 AM
Was the same as my Forum
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Lusche on November 14, 2008, 12:18:34 AM
Thank you.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 01:52:10 AM
Was the same as my Forum
You have been assimilated (http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3248/3028639155_4b15b5bb33_o.gif)
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Noir on November 14, 2008, 02:16:37 AM
expect to see your stats überanalysed pretty soon.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Lusche on November 14, 2008, 02:28:14 AM
expect to see your stats überanalysed pretty soon.

 :D
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: uptown on November 14, 2008, 06:24:54 AM
I'd have to say the Dpony is the best all around plane in the game imo, but I believe F4Us rack up more kills on me then any other single aircraft. But I probably kill more 51s then any other plane too. Not counting bombers.

5 or 6 kills with one clip is about all I can come up with. But I see skatsr get 10 or 12 all the time in one run.

I landed 5 kills with a Bpony last week I think. But 2 of them augered while blinded by ACM  :lol

just checked...Dponys killed me the most, F4us close 2nd.I've kill more spit16s then any other fighter.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: bongaroo on November 14, 2008, 08:17:36 AM
If the Ki-84 didn't risk loosing it's wings at high speed it would be the best plane in the set...actually I still think it's better  :D
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: lyric1 on November 14, 2008, 09:24:17 AM


welllllllll... it is possible if he took out the lead bomber and the drone(s) went in as freebies...

maybe it was in offline mode?   or an old H2H room  :noid




I know how he gets that many a squad member of mine uses the same method he would average 20-40 rounds per bomber. I know he has killed a bomber with two 50 cal rounds as well.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: whiteman on November 14, 2008, 10:54:33 AM
Gaboon,

Ammunition loadouts are as follows:

F4U-1/1A4x400rds/gun and 2x375rds/gun
F4U-1C2x230rds/gun and 2x232rds/gun
F4U-1D/46x400rds/gun
P-51B2x280rds/gun and 2x350rds/gun
P-51D6-gun package: 4x270rds/gun and 2x400rds/gun
4-gun package: 2x500rds/gun and 2x400rds/gun

I run out of gas before i run out of ammo in the HOG, C-HOG I'll only use half the ammo if I'm looking for other fighters.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 10:54:45 AM
I know how he gets that many a squad member of mine uses the same method he would average 20-40 rounds per bomber. I know he has killed a bomber with two 50 cal rounds as well.
I'd like to see how someone fires just 2 rounds.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 11:15:41 AM
Tap the primary trigger. Sounds like a lot of luck and practice.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 11:19:53 AM
Tap the primary trigger. Sounds like a lot of luck and practice.

then kill a buff at this precise moment... this I'd have to see to believe. :)
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: TwentyFo on November 14, 2008, 11:23:26 AM
Killing bombers is one thing i know how to do and do it very well if you dont believe me just ask 999ooo and his bomber mate I am sure they will vouch for my bomber attack tactics. If you have patience and know how to attack a bomber it will go down and you wont be touched 99% of the time. Airjer was one of those 15 bombers that day ask him also. Agood aim comes into play also most of my fighter kills are on very short burst taking a wing off or dead in the head on high deflection shot.

I don't care who you are or how much E you have, I will smoke your airplane. I rarely lose all my airplanes to one player.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 11:24:26 AM
I don't care who you are or how much E you have, I will smoke your airplane. I rarely lose all my airplanes to one player.

I'm resisting the urge.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: dunnrite on November 14, 2008, 11:25:01 AM
I'm resisting the urge.

I was hoping you wouldn't.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Chalenge on November 14, 2008, 11:36:30 AM
then kill a buff at this precise moment... this I'd have to see to believe. :)

I only had two bullets left and came in hot from his 11 as usual and the head shot killed him.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 11:36:59 AM
I only had two bullets left and came in hot from his 11 as usual and the head shot killed him.

film? screenie?
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: dunnrite on November 14, 2008, 11:37:28 AM
I was hoping you wouldn't.

wouldn't resist that is.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Lusche on November 14, 2008, 11:56:21 AM
I don't care who you are or how much E you have, I will smoke your airplane. I rarely lose all my airplanes to one player.

Actually Twenty is indeed one of the few players that can consistently prevent me from killing all three of his buffs. Usually I limp home after 1 or 2 kills...  :furious
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: JB11 on November 14, 2008, 12:02:00 PM
I agree w/Steve.  Seeing is believing.  Not betting a penny.

Best all-around is the F4U-4.....hands down.  Damn it hurt to say that!!!!

 :salute 11
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 12:09:13 PM
Actually Twenty is indeed one of the few players that can consistently prevent me from killing all three of his buffs. Usually I limp home after 1 or 2 kills...  :furious

Must.....  resist......... arghhh.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: dunnrite on November 14, 2008, 12:13:33 PM
Must.....  resist......... arghhh.

Cmon steve, you know you want to.  :D
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Lusche on November 14, 2008, 12:20:57 PM
Must.....  resist......... arghhh.

Don't resist young Skywalker...

(http://media.gamespy.com/columns/image/article/550/550110/the-top-10-unannounced-star-wars-games-and-guides--20040921033110332.jpg)
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: shreck on November 14, 2008, 12:24:43 PM
If the Ki-84 didn't risk loosing it's wings at high speed it would be the best plane in the set...actually I still think it's better  :D

HAYATE is quite limited untill the fight degenerates below 300 mph, even then most corsairs will easily own it till you can drain every last bit of E out of them! Spits, 38s, and nikis are also regular ki killers unless the ki driver is a good one. Don't get me wrong , the ki is a killer but it has some very strong limitations!!
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Saxman on November 14, 2008, 12:25:25 PM

Best all-around is the F4U-4.....hands down.  Damn it hurt to say that!!!!


It gets easier with time. Recognizing the truth is the first step. :D
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Race on November 14, 2008, 12:33:56 PM
      If your patient and kill by just flaming them you could easily get 25-30 buff kills. I have got 10 in a Poni B with out rearming...with 150 rounds or so left. I know on average if wait on the trigger I can kill a fighter with just 30-40 rounds total. Surviving long enough to get those kills might be another matter. If Steve ever wants to test 24 I wouldnt mind trying it either. At lower alts I feel like my buff hunting skills are pretty sharp.

BTW Thanks for those 51B/D fights Steve....dont know if I have seen a D keep up (and beat at times) with me like that before then!

Race
"Ryan"
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: bongaroo on November 14, 2008, 12:36:39 PM
HAYATE is quite limited untill the fight degenerates below 300 mph, even then most corsairs will easily own it till you can drain every last bit of E out of them! Spits, 38s, and nikis are also regular ki killers unless the ki driver is a good one. Don't get me wrong , the ki is a killer but it has some very strong limitations!!

Besides the part loss problem due to high speed I don't really agree with any of your assessment.  I constantly chew spits and nikis up in the Ki84; especially the nikis.  They try to play the turning game and lose when I take them vertical and whip out the wonder flaps.  P38s flown by a better pilot does give me fits.  Well flown Hogs are tough for anyone to beat but I fair very well against them in a Ki.

Below 12k and above 15k the Ki-84 has very impressive flight characteristics.  

Amazingly enough the plane that gives me the hardest time is a decently flown Yak.  Go figure.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: shreck on November 14, 2008, 01:06:23 PM
Besides the part loss problem due to high speed I don't really agree with any of your assessment.  I constantly chew spits and nikis up in the Ki84; especially the nikis.  They try to play the turning game and lose when I take them vertical and whip out the wonder flaps.  P38s flown by a better pilot does give me fits.  Well flown Hogs are tough for anyone to beat but I fair very well against them in a Ki.

Below 12k and above 15k the Ki-84 has very impressive flight characteristics.  

Amazingly enough the plane that gives me the hardest time is a decently flown Yak.  Go figure.

Assessment is probably closer than you think! most allied birds "if well flown" will get advantaged position on hayate fairly quick "if" the fight starts at higher speeds then it is a defensive game till the hayate can merge E states--> which also doesn't take that long!! But a good allied driver will have a couple shots if he is aggressive before the tables are turned on him! Now if the allied driver saddles up slow at the merge, then all bets are off and it will be over quickly for him :aok Also the flaps are hardly wonderflaps as you call them, deploying at 170 mph hardly makes them "WONDER" controll surfaces!!

Yaks are meal time!!---> aint that right chanzz  :aok  <S>
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: PFactorDave on November 14, 2008, 01:21:11 PM
 I constantly chew spits and nikis up in the Ki84; especially the nikis.  


Amazingly enough the plane that gives me the hardest time is a decently flown Yak.

I have pretty good luck against N1Ks also, as long as I can avoid that HO, and I am far from a skilled pilot.  I have the most trouble vs 109s for some reason, so I tend to avoid them when possible if other targets are an option.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: caldera on November 14, 2008, 01:27:53 PM
I fly the Ki-84 a lot and have to agree with shreck. Against a well flown F4u, P-51 or Spit, you have to hang with them and wear them down until they're slow. Then you can give them fits. The Ki is dead meat in a medium/high speed turn fight. The flaps are not very usefull either, unless you're about to stall. I have trouble with yaks too but i fear the P-38 the most.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 02:03:00 PM
Are you trimming the 84 manualy, at med-high speeds? I don't remember it being dead meat in those circumstances except when combat trim limited its elevator authority.  It doesn't fly great above 400, but it's not dead meat either.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: TwentyFo on November 14, 2008, 02:15:39 PM
Are you trimming the 84 manualy, at med-high speeds? I don't remember it being dead meat in those circumstances except when combat trim limited its elevator authority.  It doesn't fly great above 400, but it's not dead meat either.

Speaking of trim. I started using elevator trim around 3 months ago and finally got comfortable with it. I love the results it has given me and has allowed for a lot better flying. My question is whether the using manual rudder trim allows for improved flying? If so when should it be used and which planes benefit the most from it?
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 02:29:08 PM
The rudder's trim rarely hampers flying as much as the elevator's, in my experience.  Only in planes with lots of torque or that get very sideways (p-factor I think) like the Il2 and F4U and 152 does it really pay off to spend the time trimming the rudders. Most of the time you're just as well (if not better, since it's faster) simply pushing your pedals or twisting your stick to get the nose where you want it.  Trim is a slow thing, so it's only really attractive for comparably slow situations.. Like if you plan ahead of time to make a move where the bit of extra control authority will make a difference (and again this small a difference can be found in e.g. merely reducing your action/reaction time by a few fractions of a second), or if you've got a twisty stick that's quite a bit more bothersome to twist one way or the other.

It's really up to you.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: caldera on November 14, 2008, 02:40:24 PM
Are you trimming the 84 manualy, at med-high speeds? I don't remember it being dead meat in those circumstances except when combat trim limited its elevator authority.  It doesn't fly great above 400, but it's not dead meat either.

I meant it is dead meat with me flying it. It seems to turn best at low speeds while using the uber acceleration in the verticle to decrease the turn.
I've never used trim - except elevator up to keep from augering. With the twisty-stick, I don't even use the rudder a whole lot. It feels awkward.
I also fly with the stall limiter on. I know that stuff supposedly limits the aircraft, but I'm not that terrible in it.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: VansCrew1 on November 14, 2008, 02:58:43 PM
I was just reading through some threads and in game I would have to say the P-51 is by far the best plane in the game. At speed and 1 notch a flaps it will turn on a dime. The ammo load is very good and if your a crack shot the kills will pile up fast. The fuel load out is the key to its performance in my opinion. I usually took a load out of 75% with drop tanks for bomber hunting and 50 to 75% for fighter cap sweeps. My longest mission was 1 hour and 47 minutes with 15 bombers and 6 fighters with out rearming. Most kill mission with out rearming was 23 being 6 bombers and 17 fighters. In the hands of a good stick the Pony is near unbeatable. Best pony pilot I ever came across is Steve. The hubbub about the F4u is quite true the flight model is stretched as thin as a rubber band but still I'll fly the Pony over any others. I must say this though I have flown the f4u4 and I landed 15 and still had a ton of ammo left. I am not sure of what the ammo load out difference is between the Pony and the Hog but i'll still take the Pony.

Thats a little far fetched i think. The P51 has a little a 1K/D with all planes. 12423 vs 11488 This in mind doesn't really sound like much. But most of the "Dweeb planes"(spit 16, LA7, Nik) have around a 1.0 to a 1.1K/D. And the P51D(1.08) has the second highest K/D under the Nik(1.1). But what ive seen in the MA the most player can get on average  between 2 to 5 kills in a run. I think you may be stretching the line saying you killed 15 bomber and 6 fighters in one run with no rearms. Unless about half were proxies. Ive flown a pony as my main ride for close to a year and even if you know the sweet spots on bombers your bound to get a oil or pilot hit or gun damage. The most kills ive ever had was 18 in a P51 w/ no rearms but that was in the Tank Town map and it was a giant cherry pick over A1.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Bronk on November 14, 2008, 03:05:03 PM
Must.....  resist......... arghhh.
Dooo eeet man.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 05:42:45 PM
     If your patient and kill by just flaming them you could easily get 25-30 buff kills. I have got 10 in a Poni B with out rearming...with 150 rounds or so left. I know on average if wait on the trigger I can kill a fighter with just 30-40 rounds total. Surviving long enough to get those kills might be another matter.  At lower alts I feel like my buff hunting skills are pretty sharp.

BTW Thanks for those 51B/D fights Steve....dont know if I have seen a D keep up (and beat at times) with me like that before then!

Race
"Ryan"


Hey Ryan, those fights in the DA were a blast the other night. Seems to me your B pony beat my D more often than not... good stuff!

Quote
If Steve ever wants to test 24 ......
   Been there, done that.

The dark side is pulling at me.... .. must   resist.......     the dark side   *gurgle*... *ack*   arrrrrrghghhhyeaahhh.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Bronk on November 14, 2008, 06:42:44 PM


The dark side is pulling at me.... .. must   resist.......     the dark side   *gurgle*... *ack*   arrrrrrghghhhyeaahhh.

*pushes steve aside

Like this!!
(http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d191/AZC4guy/twentyfo.jpg)
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 07:08:41 PM
Blahahahahahahaha!  Feel the ecstacy of the dark side course thru your veins... muhahahahahaha!
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Lusche on November 14, 2008, 07:10:35 PM
 :rofl
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Widewing on November 14, 2008, 07:23:58 PM
Medium altitude is where the Ki-84 really performs well. By medium alt, I mean between 10k and 15k. Up there, you are not dealing with control stiffening and aero loading as this is a function of IAS (indicated air speed), not TAS (true airspeed). The lower it gets, the more control stiffening and aero loading becomes an issue. Control stiffening can be overcome by trim. Aero loading cannot be overcome, except by paying close attention to your speed.

Where the Ki-84 is at greatest risk is when speeds are just below corner velocity. At a speed near that, most American fighters can get one or more notches (for lack of a better term) of flaps out. This enables them to cut the corner and pull lead. Inasmuch as the Ki-84 can't begin deploying flaps until dangerously slow (danger in that it is a sitting duck for the third man in), its pilot must get the fight into the vertical and use the Ki-84's strengths to break down the opposition's E, where it can dominate the fight by forcing the fight up hill.


My regards,

Widewing
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Ack-Ack on November 14, 2008, 07:26:23 PM


welllllllll... it is possible if he took out the lead bomber and the drone(s) went in as freebies...

maybe it was in offline mode?   or an old H2H room  :noid





Or the bomber bug that pops up now and then.


ack-ack
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Ack-Ack on November 14, 2008, 07:29:00 PM
I'd like to see how someone fires just 2 rounds.

It's easy to fire off single rounds, just do what moot suggested, tap the trigger really fast and you'll fire off an individual round. 

As for taking out a buff with 2 rounds, I have to call BS unless it was a Golden BB shot to the cockpit for a pilot kill.


ack-ack
Title: P-51B and D models
Post by: Race on November 14, 2008, 07:48:57 PM
   I dont understand how people use trim for anything other than maintaining neutral balance on the plane. The only time I ever touch the trim is if I start to compress. If a surface has 30 degress of movement it seems like 5 degrees of trim and 25 of stick movement is the same. Personally I laugh at the thought of playing with trim while hovering 2 mph above stall speed in a luftberry or some other manuever. A well calibrated/scaled stick should beat any of that mess. KISS should apply here for most but thats just me.

I got a question for people...say your in a 30 degree per second turn maintaining a set altitude in a 51 Bravo

Whats better...

A. 4 notches of flaps with little to no stick input.
or
B. 1 notches of flap with 2/3rds evelator input.

Which has more drag vs lift?

Edit: Just to be clear the trim isnt involved.

Race
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 08:17:14 PM
Yep.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Ack-Ack on November 14, 2008, 08:25:11 PM
   I dont understand how people use trim for anything other than maintaining neutral balance on the plane.

Most players from some reason believe the urban myth that adjusting trim like elevator trim will make you turn tighter than just by pulling back on the stick.


ack-ack
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 08:27:57 PM
It does increase turn rate when combat trim is actualy limiting full authority potential.  E.g. in the mossie at some speeds (around 350 IIRC).
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Steve on November 14, 2008, 08:31:16 PM
It does increase turn rate when combat trim is actualy limiting full authority potential.  E.g. in the mossie at some speeds (around 350 IIRC).

Hmmm I turn combat trim off when I start to get slow.
Title: P-51B and D models
Post by: Race on November 14, 2008, 08:32:36 PM
     I would seriously like to see some hard data on that. The only time I can see it helping is near compression speeds. It really depends on how the trim tabs are modeled I think. If they move the whole surface the limit should be set to a certain number regardless of trim. However if they actually modeled trim tabs then I could see max input plus trim actually helping. In a poni I never really have a problem with elevator authority. Combined with flaps and speed there isnt a spot in the profile that I cant stall or black out in.

Race
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Ack-Ack on November 14, 2008, 08:34:08 PM
It does increase turn rate when combat trim is actualy limiting full authority potential.  E.g. in the mossie at some speeds (around 350 IIRC).

Adjusting elevator trim will not make you turn tighter, it's already been proven countless of times and even HiTech has posted explaining why it doesn't work.  It's all in the mind of the player, think of it as a placebo for the virtual flyer.


ack-ack
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Race on November 14, 2008, 08:38:25 PM
Its not "hard data" but thats close enough.

 :D

Any comments on my question?

Race
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 08:50:17 PM
AKAK I am talking about a specific problem with the mossie combat trim, the same as the Ki84.  It won't allow you to pull as hard as it could.  It's trimmed for neutral flight.  As soon as I've got my CH gear sorted out I'll post a film of it.  You litteraly can't stall the mossie without trimming the elevator around 340mph ias or so. Trim it, and you can.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Ack-Ack on November 14, 2008, 08:52:14 PM
AKAK I am talking about a specific problem with the mossie combat trim, the same as the Ki84.  It won't allow you to pull as hard as it could.  It's trimmed for neutral flight.  As soon as I've got my CH gear sorted out I'll post a film of it.  You litteraly can't stall the mossie without trimming the elevator around 340mph ias or so. Trim it, and you can.

CC...misunderstood your previous post.


ack-ack
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: PFactorDave on November 14, 2008, 09:02:14 PM
AKAK I am talking about a specific problem with the mossie combat trim, the same as the Ki84.  It won't allow you to pull as hard as it could.  It's trimmed for neutral flight.  As soon as I've got my CH gear sorted out I'll post a film of it.  You litteraly can't stall the mossie without trimming the elevator around 340mph ias or so. Trim it, and you can.

May I request that you make said film with the KI84, simply for my benefit.  I've heard this before about the KI, but would really like to see it in action.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: moot on November 14, 2008, 09:27:52 PM
I might be wrong on the Ki84 and confusing it with compression. I only remember making the same mental note as the mossie, thinking about making a fourth control mode with manual trim mapped to the joystick so I could pull more than combat trim allowed.  It's not hard to test for yourself.  Fly with combat trim and try pulling +G into a stall. If it doesn't happen, try trimming it some more.  If combat trim is limiting the 84 as it does the mossie, you'll be able to stall it out when trimmed but not when CT'd.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Yenny on November 14, 2008, 09:30:14 PM
I hate 51 so NERF IT !
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Scotch on November 14, 2008, 10:08:22 PM
Combat trim limits the ki84. There are threads about this. Use the search function.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: lyric1 on November 14, 2008, 11:50:45 PM
I'd like to see how someone fires just 2 rounds.
All in the head & she goes boom.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Oldman731 on November 14, 2008, 11:57:26 PM
Inasmuch as the Ki-84 can't begin deploying flaps until dangerously slow (danger in that it is a sitting duck for the third man in), its pilot must get the fight into the vertical and use the Ki-84's strengths to break down the opposition's E, where it can dominate the fight by forcing the fight up hill.

Key.  Don't believe that there are any Allied fighters, including the Spits, that can keep up with the Frank using this technique.

- oldman
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: AKHog on November 15, 2008, 12:00:15 AM
A. 4 notches of flaps with little to no stick input.
or
B. 1 notches of flap with 2/3rds evelator input.

Which has more drag vs lift?

You ask two questions, first what is better, then you ask what has more drag vs lift.

4 notches of flaps has more drag AND lift than 1 notch, simply because you are increasing the angle of attack and increasing the coefficient of drag and lift by modifying the airfoil. Which one is better is a much more complicated question, depending on how you define better. Rate of turn, radius of turn, control in turn, or energy retained in turn are all different in each situation and could all be better or worse depending on what your position in the fight is.

Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: MORAY37 on November 15, 2008, 03:29:04 AM
Medium altitude is where the Ki-84 really performs well. By medium alt, I mean between 10k and 15k. Up there, you are not dealing with control stiffening and aero loading as this is a function of IAS (indicated air speed), not TAS (true airspeed). The lower it gets, the more control stiffening and aero loading becomes an issue. Control stiffening can be overcome by trim. Aero loading cannot be overcome, except by paying close attention to your speed.

Where the Ki-84 is at greatest risk is when speeds are just below corner velocity. At a speed near that, most American fighters can get one or more notches (for lack of a better term) of flaps out. This enables them to cut the corner and pull lead. Inasmuch as the Ki-84 can't begin deploying flaps until dangerously slow (danger in that it is a sitting duck for the third man in), its pilot must get the fight into the vertical and use the Ki-84's strengths to break down the opposition's E, where it can dominate the fight by forcing the fight up hill.


My regards,

Widewing

Absolutely correct Wide.  Stop telling peeps how to fly the '84 though.....She'll own anything except a really good 109 driver, if flown correctly.  Lusche gave me the goose the other night and I'm still peeved about it...especially since I now know we've got the Ki84 modelled with Jap fuel from late war.  I got Lusche, errr, Snailman in a down and dirty the other night( he started out the fight with 3K over me) and started taking the fight uphill after a few E bleeding turns, only to watch him catch me in the vert in a 109G6. ( Kind of annoying that it's modelled with crap fuel, when all late war axis aircraft had crappy fuel as it was.)  Looking up the figures, (from allied testing in war) I should have had almost 600 feet per minute more climb than he did at that point in fight.... instead he followed me up and stuck until he tatered me.  Very well flown, anyone else... and I would easily have converted the six oclock.  I've used the same manuevers with many others with MUCH more alt and waxed em....   :mad:
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Bronk on November 15, 2008, 06:31:18 AM
Key.  Don't believe that there are any Allied fighters, including the Spits, that can keep up with the Frank using this technique.

- oldman
A good Spit Mk VIII driver will give a good 84 driver fits.
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Lusche on November 15, 2008, 10:33:05 AM
Absolutely correct Wide.  Stop telling peeps how to fly the '84 though.....She'll own anything except a really good 109 driver, if flown correctly.  Lusche gave me the goose the other night and I'm still peeved about it...especially since I now know we've got the Ki84 modelled with Jap fuel from late war.  I got Lusche, errr, Snailman in a down and dirty the other night( he started out the fight with 3K over me) and started taking the fight uphill after a few E bleeding turns, only to watch him catch me in the vert in a 109G6. ( Kind of annoying that it's modelled with crap fuel, when all late war axis aircraft had crappy fuel as it was.)  Looking up the figures, (from allied testing in war) I should have had almost 600 feet per minute more climb than he did at that point in fight.... instead he followed me up and stuck until he tatered me. 

http://www.mediafire.com/?gjkrd0tnznm

Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: MachNix on November 15, 2008, 01:33:49 PM
Thanks for the film, Lusche.  It is nice to see what an aircraft can do. <S>
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: Oldman731 on November 15, 2008, 08:07:44 PM
A good Spit Mk VIII driver will give a good 84 driver fits.

We've had this match-up a couple of times in AvA, any Spit v. the Nik and Frank.  Spits get clobbered, doesn't seem to matter which one people fly.  Hey, it's one of my rare chances to fly a Spit without shame, and I always end up spinning to terra firma.  I don't think my experience has been unique, for once.

- oldman
Title: Re: P-51B and D models
Post by: bongaroo on November 16, 2008, 01:23:23 PM
Are you trimming the 84 manualy, at med-high speeds? I don't remember it being dead meat in those circumstances except when combat trim limited its elevator authority.  It doesn't fly great above 400, but it's not dead meat either.

QTF, a whole new world in the Ki84 opened up for me when I started using manual trim at high speeds.  Amazing how quickly you can push the blackout and really cut in with need angles at those higher speeds.  400+ and it's getting close to ripping itself apart.

To bad its modeled with the inferior fuel the Japanese had to use.  It tested very close to the performance of the p51d after the war with proper fuel.  I have a lot of respect for it's design.

The P-38 is much more of a challenge for me to fly.  I default to the Ki-84 if I'm not having fun or becoming frustrated.