Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Hardware and Software => Topic started by: Hwkeye on December 06, 2008, 06:24:25 PM

Title: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Hwkeye on December 06, 2008, 06:24:25 PM
Has anyone got some experience with it and can give me some pros and cons??
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: The Fugitive on December 07, 2008, 10:05:46 AM
I'd guess about 20% of people flying today use it in the game. I did the poor mans version and built my own. Do a search for for it on the boards and you will find a bunch of info and profiles.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: SIK1 on December 07, 2008, 11:56:42 AM
I feel that it is well worth it. It does take some getting use too, and some tweeking of the profiles. Once you get it set up so that it is comfortable for you, you'll find that it is hard to live without.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Hwkeye on December 07, 2008, 03:52:41 PM
Is there any limitation on the resolution I can run in AHII with these IR tracking devices?  I was reading some of the other post and a couple of comments led me to believe there is some limitations with respect to the resolution of the screen. 
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Mace2004 on December 07, 2008, 03:54:01 PM
Is there any limitation on the resolution I can run in AHII with these IR tracking devices?  I was reading some of the other post and a couple of comments led me to believe there is some limitations with respect to the resolution of the screen. 
Nope, no limitations for TrackIR, it doesn't know or care what your screen resolution is.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Lusche on December 07, 2008, 03:57:55 PM
Is there any limitation on the resolution I can run in AHII with these IR tracking devices?  I was reading some of the other post and a couple of comments led me to believe there is some limitations with respect to the resolution of the screen. 

You may be confusing TrackIr with VR Goggles/Helmets and similar display devices. TrackIR is an input device. It's more related to a mouse. (actually TrackIr software has an mouse emulator included too)
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Hwkeye on December 07, 2008, 04:24:23 PM
Convinced!  I should have the Pro4 at the house later this week! (Merry XMAS to me!)
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Mace2004 on December 07, 2008, 04:55:43 PM
Good choice. 

Go here to help you get set up>>>> http://trainers.hitechcreations.com/files/mace/Track%20IR2.doc (http://trainers.hitechcreations.com/files/mace/Track%20IR2.doc)
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Qrsu on December 07, 2008, 10:43:44 PM
TrackIR is an amazing tool. It took me a bit to get used to it, work the kinks out with positioning/sensitivity but in the end it's great. Being able to track enemies through smooth panning views all around the aircraft without fiddling with hat switches or numpads is worth it. Enjoy.  :aok
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: DustyR on December 07, 2008, 11:16:16 PM
I"ve had mine about 2 weeks and it has made a large improvement in ACM.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: bmwgs on December 08, 2008, 12:11:32 AM
I'll go the flip side here.  I bought it, tried it, and sold it.  I guess for being a fat old man it requires a bit more movement than I wanted to do.  Several of my Squad Mates have it and love it.

Fred's Opinion,

Fred
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: SIK1 on December 08, 2008, 12:28:05 AM
If you feel like you are moving your head to much try making the profile more aggressive. I barely have to move my head up/down, or side to side to get full range. I do have to move my head fore and aft a fair amount, but I did that intentionally because when I had it set real aggressive I got a rocking motion on screen.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: bmwgs on December 08, 2008, 12:41:03 AM
If you feel like you are moving your head to much try making the profile more aggressive. I barely have to move my head up/down, or side to side to get full range. I do have to move my head fore and aft a fair amount, but I did that intentionally because when I had it set real aggressive I got a rocking motion on screen.

Actually I did.  I tried the profiles every way they could be done.  I guess I should have stated I have some nerve and muscle damage that get a bit painfull when making sudden movements of my head.  I think it a good system but its just not for me.

Fred
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Wolfie on December 08, 2008, 07:59:03 AM
Have Trackir 4 with pro clip. Love it.  :aok
There is no going back for me.

 :salute
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: HomeBoy on December 08, 2008, 10:30:48 AM
TIR was a steep learning curve for me.

I bought it after some 10 years of playing AH using POV hat and going to bed at night with my thumb throbbing from all the working the coolie.

I spent a good month trying every sort of configuration I could think of.  I almost gave it up.  Then I read Mace's description of the "dead zone" issue (my biggest problem) and after I started using his profile things started to get more natural.  At first, I  hated Mace's profile because it gave me that "sitting on a ball" feeling which felt really unstable to me.  I forced myself to stick with it and after about a week things just sort of slipped into gear.  Now (some two years later), it is as natural for me as can be.  I love it!  I would NEVER go back to the coolie hat!

The most recent (about two months ago) mod I've made to my HOTAS setup was to assign the "pinky button" (CH FighterStick) as a macro command that I call my "Gunnery button".  Here's what it does:

  1. Holds the forward view button (KB8).   Mace talks about the effect of this in his doc.  It locks the forward view but allows the side-to-side, up/down, and in/out views to work.  Great for setting up for gunnery.

  2. Turns on Zoom.   Whatever zoom setting you previously used will be in effect.  I also have a HAT on my Pro Throttle assigned to changing the zoom setting so I can zoom in and out while I hold the pinky button in.

  3. Centers TIR.  Now that the forward view button is being held and Zoom Mode is on, the TIR is centered so that my view is straight down the gunsite and I'm all set for firing.

When I press and hold the pinky button, the macro performs the three steps just mentioned.  When I release the pinky button, the forward view button is released and Zoom Mode is turned off.  This allows me to very quickly return to maneuvering.  When I want to quickly get back to "guns ready", I simply press and hold the pinky button again.  It's really worked out great.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Fulmar on December 08, 2008, 12:43:41 PM
I'd guess about 20% of people flying today use it in the game. I did the poor mans version and built my own. Do a search for for it on the boards and you will find a bunch of info and profiles.

20%? Really?  Out of what the 5000 player base, a 1000 have TIR?  I think maybe 3-4 (including my FreeTrack) in my 30+ person squad have it, which would be 10%....
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: wngover on December 08, 2008, 05:38:11 PM
I have Trackir 3 with pro clip. Can't even think of flying without it.  Overtime it will be second nature.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Wingnutt on December 08, 2008, 11:18:34 PM
TIR4 + Track Clip Pro here, if it broke, I wouldn't play the game till I got another..  it takes a little getting used to, but within 10 hours or so of use you will love it.

its one of those upgrades you look back on and say "how did I ever get along without that?"
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: humble on December 08, 2008, 11:43:36 PM
TIR was a steep learning curve for me.

I bought it after some 10 years of playing AH using POV hat and going to bed at night with my thumb throbbing from all the working the coolie.

I spent a good month trying every sort of configuration I could think of.  I almost gave it up.  Then I read Mace's description of the "dead zone" issue (my biggest problem) and after I started using his profile things started to get more natural.  At first, I  hated Mace's profile because it gave me that "sitting on a ball" feeling which felt really unstable to me.  I forced myself to stick with it and after about a week things just sort of slipped into gear.  Now (some two years later), it is as natural for me as can be.  I love it!  I would NEVER go back to the coolie hat!

The most recent (about two months ago) mod I've made to my HOTAS setup was to assign the "pinky button" (CH FighterStick) as a macro command that I call my "Gunnery button".  Here's what it does:

  1. Holds the forward view button (KB8).   Mace talks about the effect of this in his doc.  It locks the forward view but allows the side-to-side, up/down, and in/out views to work.  Great for setting up for gunnery.

  2. Turns on Zoom.   Whatever zoom setting you previously used will be in effect.  I also have a HAT on my Pro Throttle assigned to changing the zoom setting so I can zoom in and out while I hold the pinky button in.

  3. Centers TIR.  Now that the forward view button is being held and Zoom Mode is on, the TIR is centered so that my view is straight down the gunsite and I'm all set for firing.

When I press and hold the pinky button, the macro performs the three steps just mentioned.  When I release the pinky button, the forward view button is released and Zoom Mode is turned off.  This allows me to very quickly return to maneuvering.  When I want to quickly get back to "guns ready", I simply press and hold the pinky button again.  It's really worked out great.

Icant find Maces profile anywhere, I'd also love to know how to create the macro you mention....
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: SIK1 on December 08, 2008, 11:59:54 PM
+1 on the macro.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Mace2004 on December 09, 2008, 09:54:26 AM
Icant find Maces profile anywhere, I'd also love to know how to create the macro you mention....
Snap, go to my post above (#7) and follow the link to my TIR writeup. My profile is at the end. As far as Homeboy's macro is concerned I like the idea of automatically setting zoom on but disagree that you should also "Center" TIR at the same time. The reason is that "Center" has nothing to do with your forward view. It only gives TIR a reference cfor when your head is pointing at the center of the screen. If you're maneuvering to a guns solution you may not be looking directly at the center of the screen when you select the macro thus giving TIR a false reference point and it does nothing to stabilize your forward view since you've already selected forward view which locks the view directly forward. Also, I have mapped forward view to the first trigger detent. The second detent (full trigger pull) is "Fire All". I mapped "Fire Secondary" to a different stick button. This way when I'm approaching guns I cage the view forward and just need a little more trigger pull to fire. I do think I may try out adding the auto zoom and see how that works for me. I have an X52 Pro which has the double trigger detent and I believe many other sticks have this feature also. If not you'll have to map this function to another button.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: humble on December 09, 2008, 10:42:51 AM
I've got the X52 as well....Thx
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: HomeBoy on December 09, 2008, 12:48:53 PM
I'm not sure I'm quite catching on to Mace's objection to putting "TIR Center" into the "prepare to fire" macro.  For me, I position my head where I typically center TIR before I pull the pinky button.  This sets me up looking right down the gunsite exactly like I want.  I can't imagine anything better than that and it has reduced my workload considerably.  Of course, there are plenty of times when I don't want to use this macro while firing.  One example is when I'm leading the target in a deflection shot and want plenty of peripheral vision (like dropping down on a formation of bombers).  If all I want is to "cage" the forward view (or any of the views for that matter), I use my coolie hat as I still have my coolie hat setup for traditional views.  It's the best of all worlds as far as I'm concerned.

All I can say is try it and see what you think.  If it doesn't suit you, change it or abandon it.  That's the beauty of HOTAS, you can set it up any way you want.  It's even better than Mr. Potato Head.   :)
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Mace2004 on December 09, 2008, 03:24:48 PM
There are two potential problems I see. First, if you're not accurately centered when you hit the macro you're introducing a calibration error. This won't affect your shot but will be apparent after you release the macro. The second is that a snapshot is the same as shooting from the hip. You don't use the sight as much as you point the nose of the plane in front of your target and let him fly into your bullets. By forcing your view to the gunsight (especially with zoom on) you may very well lose sight just before you fire. By selecting just forward view you get the sense of where your nose is pointing without losing the lateral/vertical displacement of your view  If using center the way you are works well for you that's fine, it's just that people understand the effect of that setup.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: humble on December 09, 2008, 05:09:31 PM
So for the macro your running the X-52 software? I just use the AH mapping to the x-52 as of now...
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Hwkeye on December 11, 2008, 06:01:31 PM
Well I got my tracker today and I am glad to know I can rely on everyone's help.  I have learned a lot just following the thread.

Thanks guys!  :aok
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Bino on December 12, 2008, 08:14:51 PM
...It's even better than Mr. Potato Head.   :)

LOL Homeboy!

I have the older TrackIR3, with the add-on clip.  It only took me about an hour to fall in love with the ability to lean up/down left/right forward/back to see around the cockpit frames in a 109, or to see *almost* to the six view in a Corsair, or to peer around the engine as I called the ball on final to a CV, etc.

FYI, here is a link to my profile (http://kenshelby.us/doc/Bino_Aces_High_Profile.xml)
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: HomeBoy on December 14, 2008, 11:47:40 AM
If I had it all to do again, I would certainly give Freetrack a hard look before purchasing TrackIR.

Freetrack 2.2 looks pretty darned impressive.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Fulmar on December 14, 2008, 11:57:17 AM
I've never seen (in person) or tried TrackIR, but I assume it is more responsive than FreeTrack.  However, since my flight time in AH doesn't warranty a triple digit expenditure, for the $25 I did fork over for FreeTrack, it was well work it.  I love to mess with electronics (for being an novice) and especially mess with computers.  Other than some construction swear words, I thoroughly enjoyed building my rig.  I've probably have gotten close to 100 flight hours on the setup and it still works like it did the first day, even though I may be rough with it at times.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: humble on December 15, 2008, 10:46:39 AM
If I had it all to do again, I would certainly give Freetrack a hard look before purchasing TrackIR.

Freetrack 2.2 looks pretty darned impressive.

I have both and there is a fairly significant difference IMO....
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Hwkeye on December 16, 2008, 12:13:05 AM
Well just a quick SITREP on my TIR experience,

I am really liking it!  My kill ratio seems to be up and my SA is much better too.  In a furball I am better able to track my prey and happily I haven't gotten any dizziness or headaches that some have mentioned.  I am now officially a fanboy for TIR!
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: RedDg on December 16, 2008, 10:13:42 AM
Like what?
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Hwkeye on December 18, 2008, 04:41:39 PM
TrackIR by Naturalpoint.

http://www.naturalpoint.com/trackir/ (http://www.naturalpoint.com/trackir/)
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Eagler on December 19, 2008, 06:47:29 AM
I like the product but hate the 6 view with it
It is great except for that - a crappy six view gets me killed every time I try to fly with it
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Lusche on December 19, 2008, 09:53:24 AM
I like the product but hate the 6 view with it
It is great except for that - a crappy six view gets me killed every time I try to fly with it

That only means you haven't set up it correctly yet.

The 6 views you get are the same as with hat views, or even better because you can quickly move left or right to view around the headrest on the other side.

Apart from using a quite agressive profile (several guys have posted theirs on this BBS), it's important to lean forward a bit when initially centering your TIR when looking forward in cockpit.
The effect from this: When you now turn your head to look back, you already have maximum spepration from headrest, such increasing your field of view to the maximum.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Speed55 on December 20, 2008, 10:11:30 AM
I haven't tried it yet, but i just realized that in the options, view menu from the clipboard you can set the trackir to snap mode.  I have a centering button, so now i'm going to map a pan(which is normal), and snap (maybe for gv's and bombers) instead of shutting it off. 
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Mace2004 on December 20, 2008, 02:20:36 PM
I haven't tried it yet, but i just realized that in the options, view menu from the clipboard you can set the trackir to snap mode.  I have a centering button, so now i'm going to map a pan(which is normal), and snap (maybe for gv's and bombers) instead of shutting it off. 
No, I don't think that's the way it works.  Pan and snap are for the normal views.  What I've found works best for GV's is to toggle TIR off and on.  On when you're just looking around from the commander's hatch but you need TIR off in order to properly center the cannon sight.  When you do this you have to have your POV switch mapped to views.  Map both a centering button and pause and you can rapidly switch between normal AH POV hat switch views and TIR.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Speed55 on December 20, 2008, 05:12:23 PM
What I've found works best for GV's is to toggle TIR off and on.  On when you're just looking around from the commander's hatch but you need TIR off in order to properly center the cannon sight.  When you do this you have to have your POV switch mapped to views.  Map both a centering button and pause and you can rapidly switch between normal AH POV hat switch views and TIR.
Pretty much how i've been doing it. Center is on the keyboard, Off is mapped to a hat button. I do a one, two combo real fast so things are centered and trackir is off.
 I'll mess with the snap views later, and let you know if it's worth it or not.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Speed55 on December 22, 2008, 01:56:42 PM
OK, snap mode with trackir didn't work like i thought it would.

Instead of the instant snap you get when using your hat switch, with the trackir enabled  snap mode, there  still is a bit of motion before it would actually snap.  For example, when i would look up, i expected it to immediately to snap to the up position, but instead the view would drift up like it was still in pan mode before it would snap.

Maybe that can be fixed with a future patch.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: ImADot on December 23, 2008, 12:36:25 PM
Why would you want to have the TIR snap to a position (like using the normal view buttons)?  That seems to me to defeat the purpose of using TIR.  I only disable my TIR when in the tower or a GV.  I have no problem moving my view quickly enough to wherever I need it, using TIR with a semi-agressive profile.  I also have no problem with the "6" view in whatever I'm flying.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Speed55 on December 23, 2008, 10:33:23 PM
Because in a gv, or in bombers, you can't use the regular pan view, you have to shut it down and go back to hat views.

If it worked like the regular snap view, then when you use gv's or bombers, you wouldn't have to shut it off at all. 

It's really not a big deal, just something i wanted to try as an experiment.
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Hwkeye on December 30, 2008, 01:22:38 AM
No, I don't think that's the way it works.  Pan and snap are for the normal views.  What I've found works best for GV's is to toggle TIR off and on.  On when you're just looking around from the commander's hatch but you need TIR off in order to properly center the cannon sight.  When you do this you have to have your POV switch mapped to views.  Map both a centering button and pause and you can rapidly switch between normal AH POV hat switch views and TIR.

Mace, How do you 'toggle TIR off and on" while in AHII??  Couldn't seem to find how to do that anywhere. (BTW excellent rundown on how to setup the TIR  :salute)
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: gpwurzel on December 30, 2008, 01:32:56 AM
Open up Track IR, highlight your profile, click on edit, hot keys, assign a button/key to pause, center (and precision if you want - tho I dont use that particular one as it slows trackir down too much for me). In game, if you need to stop it, hit pause and then center to ensure you are looking square thru the sites. Once you need it again, hit your pause button and your away.


hth,


Wurzel
Title: Re: IR Tracker worth it??
Post by: Mace2004 on December 30, 2008, 11:44:11 AM
Wursel has it right.  Map the pause key in the TIR software. Also make sure you have at least center mapped to a stick button. However, like I've mentioned before I do not recommend using the center function to center the view on screen like this because it's purpose is to tell TIR when your head is centered. Just hitting center without first aligning your head will introduce errors. Instead hit pause and then forward view on your view hat. That'll align the view without affecting the TIR center.