Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => The O' Club => Topic started by: oakranger on March 31, 2009, 01:21:22 AM

Title: CSA
Post by: oakranger on March 31, 2009, 01:21:22 AM
So, i was watching this show about what the last 140 year look like is the the south won the American Civil War.  WOW!

blacks will remand slave up to now.
Native Americans Indians got treated a lot worst then they where originally.
We invade South America around 1900
Support The Nazi Government and had Hitler at the white House.
Oh, we attack Japan and whiped them out.
We hated Canadians, that not change even now.
Southern Bapits seemed to be the most domitaed religion



Man, i am glad that the Union won.  I would hate to be a under the Confederated State or America.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: MORAY37 on March 31, 2009, 03:41:39 AM
If I could understand your post.... I would agree or disagree.

But, I guess...

Huked un fonics dndn werk fur me
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: AWwrgwy on March 31, 2009, 04:20:33 AM
If I could understand your post.... I would agree or disagree.

But, I guess...

Huked un fonics dndn werk fur me

(http://img10.imageshack.us/img10/1299/grammartime.gif)

Without seeing it, and not entirely sure what you typed, I'd have some doubts about some of that "alternate history"

wrongway
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: 1pLUs44 on March 31, 2009, 06:24:41 AM
He means, what the last 140 years would have looked like if the South had actually won the Civil War.

Oddly enough, I live in a Pro-Union county of Texas (at the time)

Quote
Williamson County was marked by political divisions during the secession crisis, divisions that were carried over into the Civil War and Reconstruction.qv Unionist sentiment was strong in the county, and a resolution denouncing secession was adopted by a Texas Constitutional Union partyqv meeting in Round Rock in 1860.

Here's the Civil War Murder of 8 men, 3 or 4 from Georgetown during the Civil War. Their relatives lived in the Georgetown Area till the 1980s as far as I am aware of. The Sawyer Cemetery isn't on a map anymore though, but it wasn't covered by Lake Georgetown. (May be on the Corps of Engineers property though)

Quote
In July 1863 eight Williamson County men were caught by Confederate troops while traveling to Mexico and were hung near Bandera, Texas, and other Unionists were persecuted during the war.

http://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/online/articles/WW/hcw11.html

This doesn't really show too much about the detail, but chances are, if you just search "Sawyer Massacre, Civil War" you can definitely find a little bit more information. (Locals call it a Massacre, but others may call it just a "hanging", in the book about Williamson County, "Land of Goodwater", it has a lot of information on the subject.

Edit: After a quick search, I found a lil more information on the subject:

http://www.texasescapes.com/TexasHistory/TexasHistoricTrees/Bandera/BanderaTragedyTree.htm

Also found the letter to the editor from one of the G-G-Grandkids.

Quote
Dear Editor, Your article suggests that the men hanged outside of Bandera TX, in July of 1863, were going to Mexico to avoid conscription into the Confederate Army. I would like to point out that records indicate at least two of the men were in the [Confederate] army and on a forty-day pass.

William M. Sawyer, my paternal great, great, grandfather, had enlisted in the Confederate Army July 8, 1862, in Gurly's Regiment, Co. D, Texas Partisans of the Texas Cavalry (later designated the 30th Texas Cavalry, C.S.A) His brother, Coston J. Sawyer was also in the Texas Cavalry, Co. A, of Morgans Squadron.

These men in no way [were] guilty of any wrongdoing. They willingly gave up their arms and agreed to accompany Major Anderson to Camp Verde, but were murdered enroute.

Your article also fails to note that on April 24, 1866 the State of Texas indicted Major Anderson for murder and highway robbery. Major Anderson had of course long since disappeared.
- Sincerely, Jason Sawyer, December 08, 2003
 

bottom of that page
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: Treize69 on March 31, 2009, 06:28:58 AM
Harry Turtledoves "Timeline 191" version is much more believable. And coherent.

http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,259370.0.html
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: Reschke on March 31, 2009, 08:34:21 AM
So, i was watching this show about what the last 140 year look like is the the south won the American Civil War.  WOW!

blacks will remand slave up to now.
Native Americans Indians got treated a lot worst then they where originally.
We invade South America around 1900
Support The Nazi Government and had Hitler at the white House.
Oh, we attack Japan and whiped them out.
We hated Canadians, that not change even now.
Southern Bapits seemed to be the most domitaed religion



Man, i am glad that the Union won.  I would hate to be a under the Confederated State or America.

What is this show that you speak of in broken english terms and who were the idiots that wrote it? I might be interested in finding out more.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: druski85 on March 31, 2009, 08:41:05 AM
And here I opened this thread expecting to see some nice pictures of community supported agriculture....

Acronym fail.  (I went to insert an acronym fail picture, but every one I found would have me Skuzzified in a heartbeat :( )
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: avionix on March 31, 2009, 08:44:07 AM
Huked un fonics dndn werk fur me

Phonics isn't even taught in schools anymore.  It is all sight reading.

Haven't seent his show yet.  Not sur eif I would watch it, but all of the claims are guesstimates at best.  No telling what would or would not have happened.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: Bodhi on March 31, 2009, 09:39:29 AM
What is this show that you speak of in broken english terms and who were the idiots that wrote it? I might be interested in finding out more.

The idiot that wrote it is Spike Lee and it's called Confederate States of America. 

It's actually pretty funny.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: allaire on March 31, 2009, 10:42:09 AM
Spike Lee? Really? Bwah hahahahahahahahahahaha that is the funny as hell.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: Saxman on March 31, 2009, 10:56:43 AM
He means, what the last 140 years would have looked like if the South had actually won the Civil War.

Oddly enough, I live in a Pro-Union county of Texas (at the time)

Here's the Civil War Murder of 8 men, 3 or 4 from Georgetown during the Civil War. Their relatives lived in the Georgetown Area till the 1980s as far as I am aware of. The Sawyer Cemetery isn't on a map anymore though, but it wasn't covered by Lake Georgetown. (May be on the Corps of Engineers property though)

http://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/online/articles/WW/hcw11.html

This doesn't really show too much about the detail, but chances are, if you just search "Sawyer Massacre, Civil War" you can definitely find a little bit more information. (Locals call it a Massacre, but others may call it just a "hanging", in the book about Williamson County, "Land of Goodwater", it has a lot of information on the subject.

Edit: After a quick search, I found a lil more information on the subject:

http://www.texasescapes.com/TexasHistory/TexasHistoricTrees/Bandera/BanderaTragedyTree.htm

Also found the letter to the editor from one of the G-G-Grandkids.
 

bottom of that page

You can't beat Missouri for "the civil war within the Civil War" infighting. Especially with characters like the James brothers running around. To say the situation here was unique would be an understatement.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: oakranger on March 31, 2009, 11:10:11 AM
The idiot that wrote it is Spike Lee and it's called Confederate States of America. 

It's actually pretty funny.

Spike lee wrote that?  HA

Now i quesion it.  Really, how would the last 140 year look like for is country if the south did won the war?
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: Hawker25 on March 31, 2009, 11:38:04 AM
actually is was written and directed by Kevin Willmont. He is a film professor at KU. I remember when it first came out i was in college there and they had some screenings of it on campus.  I thought it was an interesting movie, but i always liked the what if this major event had gone differently style of movie.  They show it on IFC sometimes.  I think it is worth at least one watching if you like history at all.  I would like to have seen what it could have been if it had had a real budget behind it.  I think it was pretty well written but you can tell they had low budget actors which detracted from the movie to a degree.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: sluggish on March 31, 2009, 12:32:51 PM
Whenever I've been down south I've seen rebel flags and bumper stickers that proclaim the south shall rise again so it could still happen...
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: Ack-Ack on March 31, 2009, 12:48:55 PM
What is this show that you speak of in broken english terms and who were the idiots that wrote it? I might be interested in finding out more.

Confederate States of America is the name of the what-if documentary.


ack-ack
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: AWwrgwy on March 31, 2009, 01:31:40 PM
IMDB categorizes it as Comedy/Drama. 

That says a lot for "accuracy" I suppose.

Just the little info I read on there, the first question it raises is, why would what's left of the Union cease to exist if the South was successful in gaining it's independence?  It is like Great Britain ceasing to exist after the Revolutionary War.

I'll have to see if I can find it somewhere and watch it.



wrongway
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: oakranger on March 31, 2009, 01:39:11 PM
actually is was written and directed by Kevin Willmont. He is a film professor at KU. I remember when it first came out i was in college there and they had some screenings of it on campus.  I thought it was an interesting movie, but i always liked the what if this major event had gone differently style of movie.  They show it on IFC sometimes.  I think it is worth at least one watching if you like history at all.  I would like to have seen what it could have been if it had had a real budget behind it.  I think it was pretty well written but you can tell they had low budget actors which detracted from the movie to a degree.

You went to KU.  i sorry to hear that.
Title: Re: CSA
Post by: Reschke on March 31, 2009, 04:07:18 PM
Thanks homies!