Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => The O' Club => Topic started by: BOBO on February 08, 2021, 05:36:14 AM

Title: Radar Detectors
Post by: BOBO on February 08, 2021, 05:36:14 AM
Anybody use them, or know much about them?

Last week I finally unlocked my first stimulus (inflation creation) payment from last fall and immediately ordered a Valentine One Gen 2.

I really hope that I didn't just do something really stupid.  I don't drive particularly fast and I haven't had a speeding ticket since 2005 or so but the idea of reporting speed traps to Google Maps through the Waze app was just too much for me to resist.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Meatwad on February 08, 2021, 06:07:12 AM
I dont bother with any of them, let the speeding suckers get their ticket
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Rich46yo on February 08, 2021, 06:49:47 AM
If you also have a Lidar jammer simple radar wont do much. The newer speed guns are difficult to beat. Laser Jammer's might be illegal in your state, or one your passing thru. I dont know much about jammers but I do know you have two kinds of radar you might be looking at. And of course there's the Bear in the Air on the highway which your never going to beat.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Maverick on February 08, 2021, 09:59:32 AM
They are petty much passe now and not all that useful. Even back in the old days when they were cutting edge tech I beat the detectors all the time. I had more than one pissed off driver grab it off the dash and toss it in the back seat. By the time the detector went off I had already clocked them. In addition most jurisdictions are now using lasers so a radar detector won't make any difference.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Spikes on February 08, 2021, 10:09:20 AM
I have one. I normally might go 10-15 over on the highway so nothing too crazy, maybe slightly faster than the flow of traffic.

As Maverick said LIDAR is becoming much more common and is instant. My detector has LIDAR detection as well but if you get lasered it's already too late. The only time you might be safe is if it's laser scatter.

In NY, LIDAR guns aren't particularly common yet from my experience, I've only been lasered a handful of times as opposed to radar.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: guncrasher on February 08, 2021, 11:23:46 AM
Google maps has a function where radar traps are reported. first time I heard it, it confused the hell out of me. glanced at my phone and saw the warning, 20 seconds later i saw the police.


semp
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Rondar on February 08, 2021, 08:58:47 PM
When my wife and I travel sometimes, it gives me a thrill to no end when someone zooms by me on interstate only to see them at the side of the road in a few miles with lights flashing right behind them.  Wife and I call them christmas lights and somebody getting a christmas gift early.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: BOBO on February 08, 2021, 09:06:10 PM
Google maps has a function where radar traps are reported. first time I heard it, it confused the hell out of me. glanced at my phone and saw the warning, 20 seconds later i saw the police.


semp

That's why I bought it.  I'm not much of a speeder but I do consider speeding tickets to be a form of unjust taxation and mild tyranny.  Our speed limits were set based on average stopping distances for cars that were built many decades ago with drum brakes and bias ply tubed tires etc...

I firmly believe that speed enforcement is about revenue for the state and not about highway safety because it's about the only rule of the road that is regularly enforced and almost always requires the offender to pay a fee.  I didn't want stimulus checks because they'll end up costing us much more in the long run than we'll actually receive now so I figure this way I'm doing my civic duty by helping other motorists drive with caution and avoid fines that I consider mostly unjust.

My brother in law does rallies like Gumball and swears by the Valentine One detector.

I did some research before my purchase and found out something interesting about jammers.


Radar jammers are illegal in all states because devices that transmit RF are regulated by the FCC.

Lasers are regulated by the FDA and there are no federal regulations that prohibit jamming lasers but a handful of states have banned laser jamming devices.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Shuffler on February 08, 2021, 10:05:00 PM
That's why I bought it.  I'm not much of a speeder but I do consider speeding tickets to be a form of unjust taxation and mild tyranny.  Our speed limits were set based on average stopping distances for cars that were built many decades ago with drum brakes and bias ply tubed tires etc...

I firmly believe that speed enforcement is about revenue for the state and not about highway safety because it's about the only rule of the road that is regularly enforced and almost always requires the offender to pay a fee.  I didn't want stimulus checks because they'll end up costing us much more in the long run than we'll actually receive now so I figure this way I'm doing my civic duty by helping other motorists drive with caution and avoid fines that I consider mostly unjust.

My brother in law does rallies like Gumball and swears by the Valentine One detector.

I did some research before my purchase and found out something interesting about jammers.


Radar jammers are illegal in all states because devices that transmit RF are regulated by the FCC.

Lasers are regulated by the FDA and there are no federal regulations that prohibit jamming lasers but a handful of states have banned laser jamming devices.

You have to take in to account the people behind the wheel today. They have a lot of gadgets consuming the attention. Note I did not call them "drivers". Drivers actually drive when driving.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: guncrasher on February 08, 2021, 10:05:23 PM
I dont speed.  I may do like 5 mph over the speed limit on the freeway but that's about it.  I am never in a rush, unless there's an emergency.  last emergency was 14 years ago.

around here everybody drives 15 to 20 miles and even more over the speed limit.  that is crazy and stupid.  ever seen 4 different cars rearend other cars and block 3 lanes of traffic on the freeway because they were driving so fast they didnt see traffic up ahead going 40 miles an hour.  I have seen that.  I used to drive a lot when I used to install doors and windows and would drive 100 to 150 miles a day.  used to see at least 1 person dead in a week or week and a 1/2 on the freeway.  sometimes I saw accidents involving several cars where you couldnt even tell how many cars were involved.

just today me and my wife took a friend to get a covid second shot, accident on the way there.  on the way back I could see on google maps that another accident up ahead.  there were so many big rigs and cars speeding that it was ridiculous.  I got off the freeway and came home on the streets.

honestly I believe there should be detectors on the freeway where if you went 9 miles over the speed limit a ticket would automatically get deducted from your bank account.

maybe I am older and I dont really drive that much anymore.  last week i had the oil changed on my car last week.  the mechanic asked me when i changed it last because the oil was clean and he had almost stopped draining the oil and just add more.  told him I bought the car last july and had taken 2 trips to laughlin which both round where about 1k miles.  when I checked i realized i had driven a little over 2k miles since july.

not gonna go into the revenue thing but I just wish people would slow down.  but they arent gonna do it, so I dont know what else...


semp
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Shuffler on February 08, 2021, 10:07:48 PM
I dont speed.  I may do like 5 mph over the speed limit on the freeway but that's about it.  I am never in a rush, unless there's an emergency.  last emergency was 14 years ago.

around here everybody drives 15 to 20 miles and even more over the speed limit.  that is crazy and stupid.  ever seen 4 different cars rearend other cars and block 3 lanes of traffic on the freeway because they were driving so fast they didnt see traffic up ahead going 40 miles an hour.  I have seen that.  I used to drive a lot when I used to install doors and windows and would drive 100 to 150 miles a day.  used to see at least 1 person dead in a week or week and a 1/2 on the freeway.  sometimes I saw accidents involving several cars where you couldnt even tell how many cars were involved.

just today me and my wife took a friend to get a covid second shot, accident on the way there.  on the way back I could see on google maps that another accident up ahead.  there were so many big rigs and cars speeding that it was ridiculous.  I got off the freeway and came home on the streets.

honestly I believe there should be detectors on the freeway where if you went 9 miles over the speed limit a ticket would automatically get deducted from your bank account.

maybe I am older and I dont really drive that much anymore.  last week i had the oil changed on my car last week.  the mechanic asked me when i changed it last because the oil was clean and he had almost stopped draining the oil and just add more.  told him I bought the car last july and had taken 2 trips to laughlin which both round where about 1k miles.  when I checked i realized i had driven a little over 2k miles since july.

not gonna go into the revenue thing but I just wish people would slow down.  but they arent gonna do it, so I dont know what else...


semp

I have seen a pileup at less that 30 mph with people looking at flashing lights on the side of the road. LOL
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Vulcan on February 08, 2021, 10:08:13 PM
Most radar these days is digital/instant on. Cop just hits a button and gets a reading. The only way you pick them up is if they are hitting cars ahead of you (and the signals for instant on are quite strong).

LIDAR (Laser), is basically IR frequency, 905nm (iirc). Jammers are basically like a big torch that effectively blinds them. I have an old Bel LaserPro 905 I have had for over 20 years, works a treat, has saved my butt a couple of times.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: guncrasher on February 08, 2021, 10:20:33 PM
I have seen a pileup at less that 30 mph with people looking at flashing lights on the side of the road. LOL

in june my car got totaled while waiting at a red light, had been there for like a minute.  I didnt feel getting rearended, I just saw my car moving forward and I thought my foot was on the gas, I actually looked down and saw my foot on the brake.  I got off the car and walked up to the car in front of me and I apologized to the lady, i told her not sure what happened my foot was on the brake.  not until a guy came behind me and told me he got distracted and hit my car.  big suv, didnt have a dent on his car, mine the trunk and sides were crumbled.  that's when i realized I was rearended.  I was mad, had just paid off the car a few days before.

semp
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Shuffler on February 09, 2021, 12:37:28 AM
in june my car got totaled while waiting at a red light, had been there for like a minute.  I didnt feel getting rearended, I just saw my car moving forward and I thought my foot was on the gas, I actually looked down and saw my foot on the brake.  I got off the car and walked up to the car in front of me and I apologized to the lady, i told her not sure what happened my foot was on the brake.  not until a guy came behind me and told me he got distracted and hit my car.  big suv, didnt have a dent on his car, mine the trunk and sides were crumbled.  that's when i realized I was rearended.  I was mad, had just paid off the car a few days before.

semp

As bad as that was..... lucky you were not hurt.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: BOBO on February 09, 2021, 05:59:03 AM
I dont speed.  I may do like 5 mph over the speed limit on the freeway but that's about it.  I am never in a rush, unless there's an emergency.  last emergency was 14 years ago.

around here everybody drives 15 to 20 miles and even more over the speed limit.  that is crazy and stupid.  ever seen 4 different cars rearend other cars and block 3 lanes of traffic on the freeway because they were driving so fast they didnt see traffic up ahead going 40 miles an hour.  I have seen that.  I used to drive a lot when I used to install doors and windows and would drive 100 to 150 miles a day.  used to see at least 1 person dead in a week or week and a 1/2 on the freeway.  sometimes I saw accidents involving several cars where you couldnt even tell how many cars were involved.

just today me and my wife took a friend to get a covid second shot, accident on the way there.  on the way back I could see on google maps that another accident up ahead.  there were so many big rigs and cars speeding that it was ridiculous.  I got off the freeway and came home on the streets.

honestly I believe there should be detectors on the freeway where if you went 9 miles over the speed limit a ticket would automatically get deducted from your bank account.

maybe I am older and I dont really drive that much anymore.  last week i had the oil changed on my car last week.  the mechanic asked me when i changed it last because the oil was clean and he had almost stopped draining the oil and just add more.  told him I bought the car last july and had taken 2 trips to laughlin which both round where about 1k miles.  when I checked i realized i had driven a little over 2k miles since july.

not gonna go into the revenue thing but I just wish people would slow down.  but they arent gonna do it, so I dont know what else...


semp

I've lived in two cities that adopted automated speed enforcement.  Accidents were not common before speed cameras were installed.

In both cities rear end collisions suddenly became common after this form of "skynet" traffic enforcement was adopted.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Spikes on February 09, 2021, 08:03:04 AM
That's why I bought it.  I'm not much of a speeder but I do consider speeding tickets to be a form of unjust taxation and mild tyranny.  Our speed limits were set based on average stopping distances for cars that were built many decades ago with drum brakes and bias ply tubed tires etc...

I firmly believe that speed enforcement is about revenue for the state and not about highway safety because it's about the only rule of the road that is regularly enforced and almost always requires the offender to pay a fee.  I didn't want stimulus checks because they'll end up costing us much more in the long run than we'll actually receive now so I figure this way I'm doing my civic duty by helping other motorists drive with caution and avoid fines that I consider mostly unjust.

My brother in law does rallies like Gumball and swears by the Valentine One detector.

I did some research before my purchase and found out something interesting about jammers.


Radar jammers are illegal in all states because devices that transmit RF are regulated by the FCC.

Lasers are regulated by the FDA and there are no federal regulations that prohibit jamming lasers but a handful of states have banned laser jamming devices.
Interesting factoid about the jammers. I know in NY both radar and lidar jammers are illegal, but detectors are not.

All of our major highways upstate are 65MPH, but flow of traffic is pretty much always ~75-80.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: The Fugitive on February 09, 2021, 08:47:17 AM
I'm a vending technician and spend my days driving from location to location repairing vending machines.  I average 125-150 miles a day. I use the Waze app. We have enough people who use it and report speed traps that it is easy to slow down before you get in range. Don't think I've been pulled over in 10 years.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: DurrD on February 18, 2021, 01:39:47 PM
Valentine probably makes the best radar detector.  Personally, I think we should be like Germany and not have any speed limit on the interstates outside of urban areas. And yes Waze works pretty good.  Funny story about that:

I'm a part time police office in a nearby town, and one of the first times I was patrolling by myself I set up on a highway into town to eat my supper where I could watch the road.  I was not actively checking for speed (we don't even have radar/laser or anything in most of our units, and being a tourist town, are discouraged by administration from writing speeding tickets unless it is really egregious which is kind of how I like it anyhow).  Anyhow, I had the Waze app running on my phone, and I looked at it, and the little police icon popped up.  I was like, where is a cop?  Looking all around, then... oh yeah that's me lol.  Doh! 

Anyhow, when I sit up now, I often stay put until somebody puts it on Waze, and it usually doesn't take long, so yeah the app works really well.  I always move once it shows up though for officer safety reasons, we just had a police officer ambushed in a neighboring town the other day, so I'd just as soon people not be able to find me that way if they are looking for one to ambush. 
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Gman on February 22, 2021, 04:17:35 AM
Radar Jammers are illegal in the two Provinces I live in, in Canada, but laser jammers are legal. 

I too ran a Valentine radar/laser detector for a long time, the original Valentine one, and then more recently the later/newer 2nd gen of that unit.  It was/is excellent.  I bought my first one from Valentine's one page add in Car and Drive circa late 1990s.  The owner/creator had worked for Cinc. Microwave for years IIRC, then left to do it "better", and he did IMO for a long time.  I know that if you have the original V1 detector that the company will upgrade it to the new unit for a much reduced cost.

Now running Escort again after using the battery operated Passport way back in the early 90s, the last time I had used Cincinnati Microwave products.  Primarily because the Escort installed laser shifter needs a compatible detector, and their own 360 installed unit seems to work out best.  I have a portable 360 I use in our other vehicles, but our main highway car has the installed units in it.  Not cheap, close to $2.5k CAD after install, but the company that did it only took a day, and they have the laser and radar guns both the city and highway L/E use in these parts for testing purposes, and I've seen it first hand jam the laser, and give pretty decent long range warning on the radar.  That said, the very newest laser guns some of the dedicated traffic units are using here give a "jam" warning when they get jammed, and they can have less than great sense of humor about the subject should you jam them.  My system has a kill switch for the jammer built in for this purpose, no sense getting pulled over in the well known ticketing areas if you're not speeding in them, while the jammer stills gives the "jam" warning on the L/E laser gun. The rest of the time I leave it enabled, and it works very well.  Really only vulnerable to instant on radar, which isn't used very frequently in my areas of travel, I haven't seen it being used in years.

Don't really speed much (too much), despite the wide open and flat/straight roads in much of Western Canada, but the flow of regular traffic on the highway I drive North/South is usually 125km/hr, 15 over posted, if not faster, so I have my detectors/etc just to prevent that random event of being the one person picked out of the crowd, plus my vehicle I have my installed units in isn't going to get a lot of sympathy votes from L/E either.

edit - DurrD, interesting post, your attitude about speeding should be commended IMO. Hadn't considered how dangerous Waze could be to officers safety, things are different up here, with a bit lower threat level in that regard.  Still, your policy of monitoring your own L/E vehicle on Waze, then getting off the X once someone has made your location, should be made SOP IMO everywhere.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: Rich46yo on February 23, 2021, 05:44:50 AM
I've lived in two cities that adopted automated speed enforcement.  Accidents were not common before speed cameras were installed.

In both cities rear end collisions suddenly became common after this form of "skynet" traffic enforcement was adopted.

Its a shame they took the cop out of the ticket and Ive found its not much more then theft in a lot of cases. Most of all the red light cameras. First off many are not set right and even if they are they dont take into account other conditions at the time because the human has been removed from the equation. I'll tell you from experience these municipalities only want the cash.

They budget in how much cash they project to make from these Intersection bandits and thats why they are there. They dont prevent or stop people from driving goofy, or worse, drunk. And unlike the cop on the street they dont give warnings to good drivers.

I did that job for many years and our policy generally was on a close one a good citizen deserved a warning. These tickets are expensive and it hurts a guy punching a time clock. The city just wanted their cash, thats it plain and simple. Watch commanders never failed to mention "tickets" at roll calls.
Title: Re: Radar Detectors
Post by: BOBO on February 27, 2021, 10:42:26 PM
I'm a vending technician and spend my days driving from location to location repairing vending machines.  I average 125-150 miles a day. I use the Waze app. We have enough people who use it and report speed traps that it is easy to slow down before you get in range. Don't think I've been pulled over in 10 years.

I get a bit of enjoyment out of using the detector and reporting through the waze app.  I've found that my detector gives me a few minutes warning if a cop is using radar while driving towards me and checking speeds.  As long as there are other motorists on the road it seems to do a really good job.