Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Custom Sounds => Topic started by: Vraciu on April 01, 2025, 10:52:03 AM

Title: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on April 01, 2025, 10:52:03 AM
I know awhile back we were discussing this and nobody understood what I meant when I spoke of The Merlin Hum.   

https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,393097.msg5220149.html#msg5220149

It is a very special sound that audio equipment can't pick up quite the way your ears do.  It's a kind of descending, thrumming, hum with just a touch of Doppler Effect to it.

Well, I found a video that captures about 90% of the sound.   When you hear it in real life you are never the same again.   It gives you goose bumps.


https://youtu.be/NFBaBZjOh7s?si=veP0YFW1gaH4roZN

The sequence is at 0:40, the hum is 0:47-0:48 before the exhaust crackle and whistling blanket it.


https://youtu.be/NFBaBZjOh7s?si=veP0YFW1gaH4roZN


Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Baloo on April 01, 2025, 11:53:15 AM
Th p38 sounds Challenge was using are awesome...wish it didn't have the errors though
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on April 01, 2025, 12:15:38 PM
The distinctive whistling sound heard from a P-51 Mustang is caused by the airflow over the gunports, specifically the gun ejectors on the underside of the wings.  This is an external sound. Its generally created at certain speeds and angle of airflow. It can come and go.

The only way to isolation it and triggered is to make a synthetic sound and layer it in. But it might need a speed triggered to be proper

That could be a hard, but not impossible, to record a real one that can form a loop. It has to make a steady loop. Most recording would be fade in fade out because they are always passing.

IF I take up FMOD , that would be my first project to defeat. Single planes can be done. Its def a challenge, no pun intended. Find a 3 sec steady sound and its worth looking into. If I can isolate it.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on April 01, 2025, 12:21:08 PM
I'm not talking about the whistle though, which I don't like.   (The whistle is actually blocking it along with the exhaust at 0:49).

I'm talking about the hum.   This usually gets blanked out by either the whistle or the exhaust (in this case by both).   It's a unique sound that you don't fully hear on recordings and don't always hear in real life.    I think the closure rate has a lot to do with it.

But they caught a bit of it here.

I grew up listening to this sound and it never gets old.   When you hear it you feel like you won the lottery, it's that special.  And again,  it is not the whistle or the crackle.   It's a descending thrumming hum not a screech.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on April 01, 2025, 01:43:47 PM
I'm not talking about the whistle though, which I don't like.   (The whistle is actually blocking it along with the exhaust at 0:49).

I'm talking about the hum.   This usually gets blanked out by either the whistle or the exhaust (in this case by both).   It's a unique sound that you don't fully hear on recordings and don't always hear in real life.    I think the closure rate has a lot to do with it.

But they caught a bit of it here.

I grew up listening to this sound and it never gets old.   When you hear it you feel like you won the lottery, it's that special.  And again,  it is not the whistle or the crackle.   It's a descending thrumming hum not a screech.

Oh that may be easy buy boosting 125hz to 300hz on the EQing, peak arch seems to be around 200-220ish. It would be an arch of the freqs, maybe only 2-3db boost at the peak of the arch. In that slice of time you're just hearing the engine itself, the exhaust and whistle is not pointed directly at your ear. As the plane passes the whistle is point at you...after it passes the exhaust is pointed at your ear. SO yes, this is PROBABLY doable.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on April 01, 2025, 02:02:44 PM
[ Invalid YouTube link ]

an old lamer beginner vid I made.

Listen to the 51 at 4:41 and 5:24, 7:24, imagine that sound with the 125 > 220hz > 300 peak boost. I think that would fill the gap you're talking about.
That said, if I worked o it at all it would be putting that whistle in there, like it or not, it's a characteristic. It's either authentic or it's not.

Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on April 01, 2025, 03:00:52 PM
The whistle is overdone in all recordings.  In real life audio equipment grabs that but your ear doesn't.

The hum is masked by technology not physics.   Fifty years of listening to Mustangs, FWIW...

(I'll take a look at that later when I have better speakers than my phone.)

Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on April 01, 2025, 04:11:23 PM
I’ll make a video and EQ it and you tell me if it sounds right. Many times someone EQed never heard the real thing enough. If I nail it I’ll know exactly what I need to do in FMOD, when I get to it.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: xanax on April 01, 2025, 04:32:11 PM

The sequence is at 0:40, the hum is 0:47-0:48 before the exhaust crackle and whistling blanket it.



Yeah, it's a low-end "warbling" sound to my un-trained ear and vocabulary. It instantly brings back memories from the Reno Air Races. It's quite distinct and sounds really cool. You hear it right on the marks you suggest before the howl/whistle overtakes it.

"Merlin Hum"..... I walked through a renaissance faire once and saw a dude wearing robes and wizard hat chanting out loud while waiving a chopstick. I really had to fight the urge to give him an Arthurian legend wedgie, snap his chopstick and shove him into a mud puddle. I think he too was doing a "Merlin Hum." Nerd!
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on April 01, 2025, 05:42:04 PM
I’ll make a video and EQ it and you tell me if it sounds right. Many times someone EQed never heard the real thing enough. If I nail it I’ll know exactly what I need to do in FMOD, when I get to it.

Will do.  Looks like Xanax can help, too.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on April 01, 2025, 05:42:45 PM
Yeah, it's a low-end "warbling" sound to my un-trained ear and vocabulary. It instantly brings back memories from the Reno Air Races. It's quite distinct and sounds really cool. You hear it right on the marks you suggest before the howl/whistle overtakes it.

"Merlin Hum"..... I walked through a renaissance faire once and saw a dude wearing robes and wizard hat chanting out loud while waiving a chopstick. I really had to fight the urge to give him an Arthurian legend wedgie, snap his chopstick and shove him into a mud puddle. I think he too was doing a "Merlin Hum." Nerd!


 :rofl
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on April 02, 2025, 06:45:11 AM
Keep in mind, if p51 gun ports were removed the 51 will not whistle.

I hit the proper frqs. But its still too smooth. You might only get that growl when the plane pulls up?

Also, physics do apply in all things audio. Recording sound at airshows and airports, If its over concrete, higher freqs will be exaggerate, hence masking the growl. Concrete and buildings are very reflective.

Only real way to do it right is over grassy field.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on April 02, 2025, 05:31:04 PM
I've watched Mustangs fly in every conceivable configuration.  Gun ports.  No gun ports.  Taped gun ports.  Two seats.  One seat.  Cavalier conversions.  Desert.  Grass.  Concrete.  Bs.  Cs.  Ds.  Ks.   Cuffed props.  Uncuffed.

It's recording tech (noise reduction/protection?) more than any other factor that masks the hum.   Films from the 70s actually do a better job than 99.9% of what we see today.

I've even seen multiple film of the same air show from identical locations (or from the other end of the field), like this one, and all of them sound different, with only one catching the hum.

It's the mic not the terrain.    The sound wave propagates in all directions.   Grass is not making any audible difference to the human ear.

Old Red Nose is making the hum at 0:07 but the mic is not good enough to fully capture it.   On the second pass it doesn't catch it at all.   But your ear hears it fine.

https://youtu.be/Ga53BtyIUt4?si=semJX9Yp1uKbGZnq




Here again at 0:40, 1:51, 3:09, 3:50, and 3:58, the hum is being generated but the mic is grabbing the noise around it instead or it's being blanked by noise filtering.

https://youtu.be/1xrWUlDyUUs?si=ZsxgAicNCfQ0RNjo

Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on September 23, 2025, 11:34:31 AM
Dude, you are talking to a 45 yr experience sound engineer. You are wrong on several levels. Sound is 100% physics. Everything affects it. The reason you can even hear sound waves is because of air and physics. No air, no sound. Every surface can change it. Humidity in the air can slow the vibrations you gear.. temperature affects sound. Buildings and glass will absolutely change it. Any reflective surface can change it. The only way to avoid it is in a field of nothing but grass, even grass can affect it dissolving frequencies. We haven’t even touched hiow different mic diaphragms will absolutely change it.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: icepac on September 23, 2025, 04:40:49 PM

The unlimited hydroplanes make the best merlin/allison/griffon sounds.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on June 18, 2026, 11:57:47 PM
Dude, you are talking to a 45 yr experience sound engineer. You are wrong on several levels. Sound is 100% physics. Everything affects it. The reason you can even hear sound waves is because of air and physics. No air, no sound. Every surface can change it. Humidity in the air can slow the vibrations you gear.. temperature affects sound. Buildings and glass will absolutely change it. Any reflective surface can change it. The only way to avoid it is in a field of nothing but grass, even grass can affect it dissolving frequencies. We haven’t even touched hiow different mic diaphragms will absolutely change it.

And you're talking to a guy that has more time listening to Merlins in his sleep than you have while awake.  53+ years.   I grew up with them, which is part of the reason I'm the only one on this board that even knows what sound we're talking about here.

Grass and concrete have zero impact on when/if you hear the hum in its full glory.   It can be heard at any temperature, on any surface, and in every level of humidity from the sticky sea level ocean air of Harlingen to the arid high desert sky of Reno.

Most mics do a terrible job replicating the human ear.   Noise filters, mic covers, composition of the mic itself, etc. all play a role in screwing this up.

You can hear it on one pass in still air and not hear it with a subsequent pass from the exact same direction.   Then hear it again from the same or different direction later--or not.   Mics will pick up the sound 1% of the time at most, even when your ear hears it clearly.    That's an equipment issue not a humidity/surface composition issue.

Airspeed, groundspeed and RPM are the three main factors that impact one's ability to hear the sound*, not humidity, grass, or concrete.  These factors are not even rounding errors.

--
*Doppler Effect also has to play a role if I had to guess.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on June 19, 2026, 09:54:39 AM
And you're talking to a guy that has more time listening to Merlins in his sleep than you have while awake.  53+ years.   I grew up with them, which is part of the reason I'm the only one on this board that even knows what sound we're talking about here.

Grass and concrete have zero impact on when/if you hear the hum in its full glory.   It can be heard at any temperature, on any surface, and in every level of humidity from the sticky sea level ocean air of Harlingen to the arid high desert sky of Reno.

Most mics do a terrible job replicating the human ear.   Noise filters, mic covers, composition of the mic itself, etc. all play a role in screwing this up.

You can hear it on one pass in still air and not hear it with a subsequent pass from the exact same direction.   Then hear it again from the same or different direction later--or not.   Mics will pick up the sound 1% of the time at most, even when your ear hears it clearly.    That's an equipment issue not a humidity/surface composition issue.

Airspeed, groundspeed and RPM are the three main factors that impact one's ability to hear the sound*, not humidity, grass, or concrete.  These factors are not even rounding errors.

--
*Doppler Effect also has to play a role if I had to guess.

Don’t attempt to teach me about audio and the physics of it. You clearly do not understand it. Audio is 100% physics. Stay in your lane

I have heard mic pick up what you are explaining.

The right mic will pick up 20hz to 20khz
The human ear can’t hear that whole spectrum.
You are lucky to hear below 30hz or above 10khz

Human hearing damage begins at birth
A mic never has hearing damage
No two humans hear exactly alike. The same with mics, even if the same model

The higher the freq in a sound the more directional it is
Lower freq in a sound the more omni directional it is

The whistle comes from gun ports facing forward
The growl comes from exhaust facing rear
Air passing over surfaces can create sound too.

Reflective surfaces matter in a clean pure recording of exterior sounds.

This is fact and physics
Physics is math, its absolute
Without air sound may not exist
In space scream all you want, it won’t be heard

Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Dadtallica on June 19, 2026, 09:59:40 AM
This will be LOL I’m in!  :cheers:
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on June 19, 2026, 11:55:13 AM
Don’t attempt to teach me about audio and the physics of it. You clearly do not understand it. Audio is 100% physics. Stay in your lane

I have heard mic pick up what you are explaining.

The right mic will pick up 20hz to 20khz
The human ear can’t hear that whole spectrum.
You are lucky to hear below 30hz or above 10khz

Human hearing damage begins at birth
A mic never has hearing damage
No two humans hear exactly alike. The same with mics, even if the same model

The higher the freq in a sound the more directional it is
Lower freq in a sound the more omni directional it is

The whistle comes from gun ports facing forward
The growl comes from exhaust facing rear
Air passing over surfaces can create sound too.

Reflective surfaces matter in a clean pure recording of exterior sounds.

This is fact and physics
Physics is math, its absolute
Without air sound may not exist
In space scream all you want, it won’t be heard

Wow, such searing commentary--and yet completely wrong.  Mostly just TLDR.   :ahand

Mics SOMETIMES pick it up, otherwise the examples I posted wouldn't exist, "sound engineer" (LOL). Unfortunately,  99% OF THE TIME THEY DO NOT.

Your theoretical classroom nonsense doesn't apply to what happens in real life.    I've witnessed it repeatedly for five decades.

We're not talking about whistles and exhaust.   We're taking about a (Doppler?) hum that is so distinct yet subtle you with all your alleged experience have no clue what it is.  My wife can hear it.  My kids can hear it.  Anyone who knows what to listen for can hear it.   But you,  our resident "sound engineer" (HA HA HA) can't (double HA HA HA).

If anyone needs to stay in their lane it's you--your preferred method, apparently, is in the middle of the stripe going the wrong way.  I had more aviation experience by the time I was five than you ever will in two lifetimes.   Harass/stalk someone else.   You bore me.

/Discussion
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on June 19, 2026, 12:07:15 PM
Wow, such cearing commentary--and yet completely wrong.  Mostly just TLDR.   :ahand

Mics SOMETIMES pick it up, otherwise the examples I posted wouldn't exist, "mister soind engineer" (LOL). Unfortunately,  99% OF THE TIME THEY DO NOT.

Your theoretical classroom nonsense doesn't apply to what happens in real life.    I've witnessed it repeatedly for five decades.

We're not talking about whistles and exhaust.   We're taking about a (Doppler?) hum that is so distinct yet subtle you with all your alleged experience have no clue what it is.  My wife can hear it.  My kids can hear it.  Anyone who knows what to listen for can hear it.   But you,  our resident "sound engineer" (HA HA HA) can't (double HA HA HA).

If anyone needs to stay in their lane it's you--your preferred method, apparently,  is in the middle of the stripe going the wrong way.   I had more aviation experience by the time I was five than you ever will in two lifetimes.   Harass/stalk someone else.   You bore me.

/Discussion

Listen Doxxer law breake, you broke more laws than I did. I should iwn your house. So shut it
After what you did to me I deserve a gold metal for gaving more than inr word with you.

Figure it out, you’re on your own.

Dunning-Kruger Effect is in epic proportions

Maybe a pen*s extension will solve your problems
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on June 19, 2026, 12:20:15 PM
*Yawn*
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Animl-AW on June 19, 2026, 12:51:37 PM
Doxing isn't always a standalone crime but becomes illegal when it crosses into existing laws like stalking,
harassment, threats, or identity theft; however, some states (like CA, IL, AL) are creating specific doxing laws, and it's a federal offense to dox government employees due to national security, often prosecuted under related offenses with potential jail time, fines, and civil penalties.
When Doxing Becomes Illegal

    Intent to Harm: If done with intent to threaten, harass, intimidate, or incite violence, it can lead to prosecution for those specific crimes.
    Stalking/Harassment: Sharing info to cause distress or fear falls under cyberstalking or harassment laws.
    Identity Theft: Using personal info (like SSNs) for fraud is illegal.
    Threats: If the shared info leads to threats of serious bodily harm, it's a crime.

Federal & State Laws

    Federal Offense: Doxing government employees is a federal crime.
    Evolving Laws: Some states, like California, Illinois, and Alabama, have specific anti-doxing statutes, allowing civil suits or criminal charges. Colorado also has laws targeting doxing with potential threats.

Why It's Tricky

    Publicly Available Info: Doxing often uses information already online, making prosecution difficult unless intent to harm is proven.
    First Amendment: Laws must be carefully crafted to avoid infringing on free speech, often requiring proof of harmful intent.

In Summary: While publishing public info isn't inherently illegal, doxing becomes criminal when it enables stalking, harassment, threats, or identity theft, with specific state and federal laws increasingly targeting it.


https://www.flatriallaw.com/blog/2021/10/what-is-doxing-and-how-can-it-get-you-in-trouble-with-the-law/

I've done sound for 7 presidents with all the clearances. I'm considered a gov employee. Your information can be subpoenaed and your devices seized as evidence, it's SOP for internet crimes. You have been informed
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on June 19, 2026, 01:20:28 PM
The Secret Service wouldn't let you anywhere near a President.  :rofl

Like I told you before, come and get me, tough guy! :neener: :ahand

Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on June 19, 2026, 01:33:51 PM
What do Animal-AW and an SU-57 have in common?

...


 :D
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: icepac on June 27, 2026, 07:06:15 AM
I grew up going to and later crewing at unlimited hydroplane events.   

I was there when Skipp Walther had his fatal crash and have heard all manner of merlins, Allison’s, and griffons.   
I also skipped school a few days earlier and saw Jim Mccormick get cut up badly in the same boat. 

In hydroplane racing a merlin sounded nothing like what you hear when a P51 does a fast pass. 

The boats have a sound like a large truck climbing a dirt road while losing and regaining traction as they pass but were so loud, I could hear them from my house on Key Biscayne or from my classroom at George Washington Carver Jr. high.   

Every merlin I have heard in a flying plane sounds different from each other to me likely because of the plane shape, amount of prop blades, type of exhaust extractors, and the speed of the flyby…..along with many contributions of sounds that the merlin is not responsible for.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Dadtallica on June 27, 2026, 07:09:41 AM
I loved those Hydro races as a kid! I got to sit in the miss Budweiser once and I was the best day ever!
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on June 27, 2026, 06:10:54 PM

Every merlin I have heard in a flying plane sounds different from each other to me likely because of the plane shape, amount of prop blades, type of exhaust extractors, and the speed of the flyby…..along with many contributions of sounds that the merlin is not responsible for.

That said,  gun ports do not contribute to the sound.   They mask it.

One notable example being "Old Red Nose" down in Harlingen when it had faired over gun ports like most Mustangs did way back in the day.  It has gun ports now.   The hum was always there regardless of configuration.  The whistle and shriek hides the hum it doesn't contribute to it. 
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: icepac on June 29, 2026, 03:11:27 PM

I do know that strega and voodoo sound different and long ago you could tell which ratio gearcase they were running by the sound....and rpms.

I bet this sounds different. 

(https://airandspace.si.edu/sites/default/files/images/collection-objects/record-images/NASM-SI-94-4462.jpg)
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Vraciu on June 30, 2026, 09:41:07 PM
I do know that strega and voodoo sound different and long ago you could tell which ratio gearcase they were running by the sound....and rpms.

I bet this sounds different. 

(https://airandspace.si.edu/sites/default/files/images/collection-objects/record-images/NASM-SI-94-4462.jpg)

Haven't heard those two in a long time but my recollection is they had really loud exhaust.   But they're also pumping almost double the horsepower of the standard Merlin.   I also believe the prop tips are supersonic when they're going full bore.   Hard to hear much of anything when that happens.   BT-15s, etc. are loud for that reason, too.

Yeah the extra blades on the G could make a difference.   Guess we'll never know.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: LCADolby on July 01, 2026, 01:41:00 AM
Fk me is Animl in here causing chaos as well... That guy could argue over pain drying.
Title: Re: The Merlin Hum
Post by: Wolf on July 03, 2026, 01:18:01 PM
What do Animal-AW and an SU-57 have in common?

...

 :D

Both like flying?

Neither work well?

Neither are often seen in the air?

Both share callsigns?

Tell us.

:noid