Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: mERv on March 25, 2026, 08:15:58 PM

Title: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: mERv on March 25, 2026, 08:15:58 PM
NDIsles has never been an action friendly map. In myopinion it has always been a poor map since the changeover to AH3. Why on earth does this map continue to exist in the main arena? It is an action killing map that requires the most time investment out of any map in the game. For all of the complaints out there you would think the same standard to action-killing would apply when we cant break 50 players at any given time during peak. Kenai77 did all he can do to improve it but this is unsalvageable.

NDIsles has to go
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Dadtallica on March 25, 2026, 09:48:02 PM
Nope one of the best OG maps. There was constant action tonight, even though there was only 60 players at 9PM EST.

That’s the real story. It’s going to be a long summer for some individuals.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Shane on March 25, 2026, 09:49:16 PM
This map and several others would greatly benefit from additional cross-water gv spawns.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Dadtallica on March 25, 2026, 09:51:54 PM
This map and several others would greatly benefit from additional cross-water gv spawns.

I’m always advocating for being able to have access to deep bases. I would like to see maps made more in a ribbon pattern than a pie chart. I feel there should be some uncapturable bases, deep in enemy territory for both opposing countries on all sides.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: icepac on March 26, 2026, 07:02:53 AM

How about pt spawns at any field that borders water? .......or, making current pt spawns spawnable.     
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: popeye on March 26, 2026, 08:28:41 AM
I feel there should be some uncapturable bases, deep in enemy territory for both opposing countries on all sides.

Ok, if you like spending all your time defending/resupplying strats.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: mERv on March 26, 2026, 09:41:48 AM
I think what would solve this maps problem may be adding a minimum of 2 more cv group per country and/or 1 m3 spawn per island. Yes this map would fall quickly if a country actually goes on a run. Not sure how that is a bad thing either. What drives action in the MA is the war. What drives action needs to be preserved and encouraged.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Shane on March 26, 2026, 10:05:40 AM
How about pt spawns at any field that borders water? .......or, making current pt spawns spawnable.   

We have the baltic map with an insane number of useless pt spawns.   If anything, the spawns should be made closer to enemy fields/beaches and allow for lvt's as well.

<aside: I'd love to have "dd"  sherman tanks available.  The 75mm lvt is... less than optimal for anything.>

Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Shane on March 26, 2026, 10:06:35 AM
I think what would solve this maps problem may be adding a minimum of 2 more cv group per country and/or 1 m3 spawn per island. Yes this map would fall quickly if a country actually goes on a run. Not sure how that is a bad thing either. What drives action in the MA is the war. What drives action needs to be preserved and encouraged.

and "dd" amphibious shermans!!  https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,411366.0.html


Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Spikes on March 26, 2026, 11:40:49 AM
What drives action in the MA is the war. What drives action needs to be preserved and encouraged.
I'd argue what drives action is being able to see enemies. Blowing up HQs is counter intuitive to this.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: DmonSlyr on March 26, 2026, 11:41:29 AM
Noooooo, there are a couple other maps like bowlMA or Oceania that need to go first. ND is atleast condensed where you can find some kind of action and enjoy fun CV battles off the coast. These huge maps are too overwhelming for most new players returning and if they log in and  see 1 tiny dar and nothing on the other side, its probably gonna be a log for them. Or they can switch teams and realize they made a mistake or didnt switch to the side that achieves their desires and log. We need the maps with condensed action. Condensed action is what most peoole enjoy. Being involved in a battle with larger groups of teams on all sides to make the battle feel large and grow the dar bars. Darbars are what grow the #s. Nothing else, but they have to be balanced for a bit to make the battle fun.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Randy1 on March 27, 2026, 03:48:51 PM
The country that has V4 like the Rooks did last night have no chance of fighting back on tank island.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Max on March 27, 2026, 04:13:40 PM
This map and several others would greatly benefit from additional cross-water gv spawns.

 :aok :rock :salute
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Lazerr on March 27, 2026, 05:32:26 PM
The country that has V4 like the Rooks did last night have no chance of fighting back on tank island.

Yup.. 4 should have remained an air base. Among other issues with the 2nd version of this map.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Eagler on March 28, 2026, 07:49:14 AM
The center island should have one uncaptureable base for each country...

Eagler
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: The Fugitive on March 28, 2026, 12:52:42 PM
I'd argue what drives action is being able to see enemies. Blowing up HQs is counter intuitive to this.

I agree with this about 400% Radar should NEVER be able to shut down. Dar goes down and you has a mass exodus for the door.

The center island should have one uncaptureable base for each country...

Eagler

I agree with this about 400% The center isle of this map was designed for "instant action" and is one of the few that has that. GV battles, and mini furballs (as we dont have true furballs any more  :( ) are what the center island is all about. It would also be a spot to use to take back the bases on the island that were lost due to early morning or late night mini hordes.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Randy1 on March 29, 2026, 01:51:16 PM
I think ndisles was one of the first attempt to force GVer's into planes.  Same with the Crater map.  It failed miserably.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: DmonSlyr on March 29, 2026, 08:35:43 PM
ND is alright, I think it has really fun CV battles and a center island furball island that actually works. I think more maps should be created with islands and water streams for fun CV battles and pacific feel. CV battles attract a lot of folks and create large battles with short time to action. We need another map like that in order to retire Oceania which is a map too large for the current #s and should be removed. NDisles atleast provides condensed action and fun furballs. Thats what most folks want.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Spikes on March 29, 2026, 08:40:08 PM
I think ndisles was one of the first attempt to force GVer's into planes.  Same with the Crater map.  It failed miserably.
How? It is literally one of like two maps with a dedicated GV area in the middle.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Molsman on March 29, 2026, 08:51:26 PM
if your going to have a dedicated GV only area on the Map If Ndisles was that Map up on saturday night then I saw from the Air Fields on the Map or just make 1 Aifield for team but then again that also generates a lot of great fights without island jumping for fights.


thats just my 2 cents
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: JimmyD3 on March 29, 2026, 08:53:49 PM
How? It is literally one of like two maps with a dedicated GV area in the middle.

The problem is the new Tank Town, it is nothing like what we had in AH2. Most GV-ers don't care for it. The original Tank Town setup in AH2 had gv bases instead of small air bases in the middle. iirc they were also uncapturible.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: The Fugitive on March 29, 2026, 10:05:17 PM
How? It is literally one of like two maps with a dedicated GV area in the middle.

It was setup that way originally, much like the crater map. Both had a very GV center. They have both been changed so much so that we no longer get that GV action in the center of the map. Isles had mounds that you could "use the high ground" in a GV in the center. Crater was so much more GV centric before Greebo redid it.  most players were in GVs in the center crater trying to pop tanks as fast as they could before they got popped them selves.

Now, were they changed to get players in the air..... dont know, but they were changed and it did kill the GV action on those two maps.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Spikes on March 30, 2026, 12:30:42 PM
It was setup that way originally, much like the crater map. Both had a very GV center. They have both been changed so much so that we no longer get that GV action in the center of the map. Isles had mounds that you could "use the high ground" in a GV in the center. Crater was so much more GV centric before Greebo redid it.  most players were in GVs in the center crater trying to pop tanks as fast as they could before they got popped them selves.

Now, were they changed to get players in the air..... dont know, but they were changed and it did kill the GV action on those two maps.

Well, the map still has bases with GV spawns, they are just airfields now, right? Since there's only one VH, I can definitely see there being an issue with the VH going down easy thus killing the ability to use GVs in the center. A solution for that might be having a GV spawn from each mega field into the center.

I'd argue that the concept of tank town has sort of been long dead, though. I assume most of it was due to dwindling numbers from the days of old, as I spent hundreds if not thousands of hours in tanks and as close air support on the center of ndisles, trinity, bowl, crater, festerMA? any other old maps. There are still plenty of dedicated GVers, but it's not nearly seemingly the 24/7 action there once was. I feel like I recall even when trinity was in rotation, that tank town was dead and that had the 30K mountains to deter folks from trying to bomb GVs.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: Randy1 on March 30, 2026, 02:48:31 PM
Spikes, keep in mind as well, the majority of the time, one country owns all of tank island now days.  As I have posted before, if your country  came with V4, it is very difficult to get back on the island.  Add to that very long trips to base or townn for GVer's adds in more problems. 

The old Crater map was a GVer's dream map.  No doubt, Crater emptied the skies because the tank battles were so exciting tankers pulled flyers from the air fight to upping a tank.  Add to that long flights to get to the crater had a few flyers logging out because of that.
Title: Re: NDIsles2 performing as badly as Buzzsaw
Post by: icepac on March 31, 2026, 07:46:19 AM

Blame the players who exclusively hover over tank town.