Aces High Bulletin Board
General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Lusche on July 24, 2026, 09:49:06 AM
-
Well, I've been playing a bit lately, and until yesterday I was using Autoswitch, so I was always fighting for the country with the fewest players.
I kept track of it a little, so I can tell you which side was outnumbered the most often:
(https://i.imgur.com/KFHSXCa.png)
Interestingly, Autoswitch doesn't really work very well anymore. As the numbers are way too low to allow for battles on every front, I often found myself kicked from the only battle on the map to a chesspiece without any activity at all on all of it's fronts. And not only the country ganged upon is not only not the one with the fewest players, but at low numbers times a country can have most players in arena but least number of active ones at the same time.
One example: I enter the arena, getting put on Knight side. But not a single player on any side is "inflight" at all. So I roll my tank to a Bish town and lazily keep shooting at buildings. After 15 minutes, suddenly some more Knights show up and join me in the perceived "capture attempt". Still no Bish reaction, and as I tower after having used up my HE rounds, I get autoswitched to - Rooks.
Over the next hour or so, I see 4 Knights capturing Bish base after base, against no resistance at all, while all I can do is watching the map from Rookland. I was even doing a 9k bombing run against Knight targets, but they just ignored me (smart from a strategic point of view).
I could have disengaged Autoswitch to manually jump to Bishops, but I would have stuck there for the next 6 hours, while after one hour the Bish would wake up and quickly totally outnumber both other sides combined.
While this is a more extreme example, similar was happening quite often even during US prime time. Two sides locked in battle, while the third either milkruns undefended bases or is not doing anything at all, with no red darbars to be seen anywhere.
I think it would be sensible to drastically reduce the time limit for switching sides again.
-
Interestingly, Autoswitch doesn't really work very well anymore. As the numbers are way too low to allow for battles on every front, I often found myself kicked from the only battle on the map to a chesspiece without any activity at all on all of it's fronts.
Which wouldn't have happened with two-sides because there would be one shared frontline.
Yes, I know, it will never happen.
-
Interestingly, Autoswitch doesn't really work very well anymore. As the numbers are way too low to allow for battles on every front, I often found myself kicked from the only battle on the map to a chesspiece without any activity at all on all of it's fronts. And not only the country ganged upon is not only not the one with the fewest players, but at low numbers times a country can have most players in arena but least number of active ones at the same time.
Two sides locked in battle, while the third either milkruns undefended bases or is not doing anything at all, with no red darbars to be seen anywhere.
I think it would be sensible to drastically reduce the time limit for switching sides again.
This has been remarked on repeatedly the past few years; I'll agree the switch timer should be reduced to 1 hour (maybe 2) even tho' I don't jump sides frequently.
It is much harder to get the former balance of all fronts having action (reduced numbers, crowd/action following, etc) so that feast or famine can be quite "meh." This is why we see some calling for two sides instead of three, but that's not going to resolve what is fundamentally players' gameplay decisions.
<edit: :noid as i was writing this, guess what was suggested, two sides! :rofl >
-
Did the roster look like this?
Are these Bishop players on knight towersitting to affect eny so the rest of the bish can fly late war planes?
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55393347844_f9ef7133db_w.jpg)
-
Well, I've been playing a bit lately, and until yesterday I was using Autoswitch, so I was always fighting for the country with the fewest players.
I kept track of it a little, so I can tell you which side was outnumbered the most often:
(https://i.imgur.com/KFHSXCa.png)
Interestingly, Autoswitch doesn't really work very well anymore. As the numbers are way too low to allow for battles on every front, I often found myself kicked from the only battle on the map to a chesspiece without any activity at all on all of it's fronts. And not only the country ganged upon is not only not the one with the fewest players, but at low numbers times a country can have most players in arena but least number of active ones at the same time.
One example: I enter the arena, getting put on Knight side. But not a single player on any side is "inflight" at all. So I roll my tank to a Bish town and lazily keep shooting at buildings. After 15 minutes, suddenly some more Knights show up and join me in the perceived "capture attempt". Still no Bish reaction, and as I tower after having used up my HE rounds, I get autoswitched to - Rooks.
Over the next hour or so, I see 4 Knights capturing Bish base after base, against no resistance at all, while all I can do is watching the map from Rookland. I was even doing a 9k bombing run against Knight targets, but they just ignored me (smart from a strategic point of view).
I could have disengaged Autoswitch to manually jump to Bishops, but I would have stuck there for the next 6 hours, while after one hour the Bish would wake up and quickly totally outnumber both other sides combined.
While this is a more extreme example, similar was happening quite often even during US prime time. Two sides locked in battle, while the third either milkruns undefended bases or is not doing anything at all, with no red darbars to be seen anywhere.
I think it would be sensible to drastically reduce the time limit for switching sides again.
Thanks for this Lusche. I agree 100%. I was hoping there would be a time change adjustment soon after the last thread with Kenaii.
IMO, with low #s anything can be manipulated. I cant figure out the defense problem/phenomenon for the life of me.
IMO, it all comes down to maps. The maps that are too large cause these imbalances the most during low #s, and you are stuck because you cannot go fight the battle on the other side of the map, nore can you tell who is winning the battle to make an accurate switch assessment to help the side that's needed. Too many fields adds confusion and makes maps stay for 2 days longer than needed.
Smaller maps equals bigger battles in smaller areas where everyone knows where the fights and paths are, and everyone can join a battle on the map if their side has no action.
-
Did the roster look like this?
Are these Bishop players on knight towersitting to affect eny so the rest of the bish can fly late war planes?
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55393347844_f9ef7133db_w.jpg)
:rofl :rofl
-
Yep auto switch was taking me out of the fight..
I start on knights now and usually find enough action for my hour of ma but will switch if they are just attacking an empty base..
Eagler
-
When a squad(s) throws 1.5-2 bars at with 5 defenders because they are being gang bang, whats the use in defending it? They just log.
That could have been 2-3 other battles.
This mentality to waist 2-3 bars on almost no defenders in a complete wast to the game play.
I’ve many times have had 6-8 on my 6 trying to kill me. <blank stare> lets talk about lameness.
It’s a bad joke and destructive, players just log off.
How sbout large squads don’t do mass milk runs. I’ll never understand the fun in 30 players shooting empty beer cans. I do not
Our sqd will split up and work 2-3 bases over putting 2-3 bars on a milk run
But wait, there’s more,… the denials are coming.
However, I stand with throwing 2-3 bars at next to no one is ridiculous. They put everything int one single battle. But its nit a battle at all. Its just shooting stuff.
Auto side switched is highly flawed during gang bangs. If the victim side has higher numbers than each of the gang bang sude they lise players to auto switch and get slapped with eny in top of being ganged. It’s always been bad. We just notice it more because of lower numbers than 8-10 yrs ago at its peak.
-
On a numbers side note;
Based on primetime number patterns..,,
FSO nights used to bring 130 in game. That is a winter number as well.
This summer and since event time change, it now brings 140-150 logged in game.
I don’t recall which Friday, one of the last 2 I think,…. 70 (used to be 50-60) in FSO, 82 in MA= 152
TAKE NOTE: These are mid- summer numbers. The according to past patterns, the numbers should be lower, not higher.
If we get this nudge in summer, maybe we get a winter spike putting us at an average if 120-140 in the MA. <crossed fingers>
The last two scenarios seemed to fill faster, than some prior.
BACK TO SUBJECT
Critical mass, when the game starts improving is 110-120.
Anything below that game play descends, usually.
So to study game-play below CM or higher than CM are vastly different results, on average. The mire above CM the more the game plays as designed, a better game.
If I did a study always below CM it would be depressing
If done above CM it’s encouraging.
That’s why no settings should changed based on below CM game-play. >IMO<
IMO, Louche’s charts combine both. I love when claim is supported with numbers.
-
Did the roster look like this?
Are these Bishop players on knight towersitting to affect eny so the rest of the bish can fly late war planes?
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55393347844_f9ef7133db_w.jpg)
That's not a good look.
How would you fix that, though? Eliminate country switching?
People that may (or may not) do shady stuff to capture cartoon bases will find workarounds, regardless.
-
That's not a good look.
How would you fix that, though? Eliminate country switching?
People that may (or may not) do shady stuff to capture cartoon bases will find workarounds, regardless.
True, but luckily there isn't that many that feel the need to.play like that. I had suggested that a timer be added to thos3 sitting in the tower and when the time was.up they are removed from the eny calculation. Hitech liked the idea, but I guess he hasn't gotten around to fixing it. I think he could come up with a way for the auto switch to only switch to a lower number side that has fighting going on.
I know the side switch time is a touchy subject but I'm sure it could be set up to work with population numbers. Low numbers it has a short switch time, and as the numbers increase so do the switch time limits.
I would think if hitech could spend time in the arena he could come up with a few ways.to tweak the game to make the fronts work better with the smaller numbers.
-
Five Stages of Grief
Denial The initial reaction where individuals may refuse to accept the reality of the loss. They may feel numb or believe the event is mistaken.
Anger Feelings of frustration and helplessness can lead to anger, which may be directed at oneself, others, or even the deceased.
Bargaining In this stage, individuals may attempt to negotiate or make deals to reverse the loss, often reflecting on "what if" scenarios.
Depression This stage involves deep sadness and a sense of hopelessness as the individual begins to understand the extent of the loss.
Acceptance Acceptance does not mean the pain is gone, but rather that individuals learn to live with the loss and find a way to move forward.
I think we are stuck in the Bargaining stage.
-
players just log off.
Seems to work. Game suggests fun - not frustration.
-
like I've been saying, it's ridiculous to have ENY when the numbers are so low. It's WAY too easy to manipulate - like one guy can log off for a second while his squad grabs some ENY affected planes, or a couple guys sit in the tower on the other side. Two or three people should never be able to manipulate the ENY. ]
Get rid of ENY unless numbers are in the 200s
Make it so players in the tower have ZERO affect on ENY
I don't like ENY period, but it's just retarded to have this BS going on when the numbers are so low.
I've never worried about being outnumbered. I don't care. I DO care when I'm outnumbered AND I have to fly a crap plane while the gang-bangers are in LA7s and Ponies - and that happens frequently because the ENY does not work with low numbers. I'll log off every time when the ENY kicks in hard AND we're outnumbered in the actual fight that's on the map.
-
There definitely needs to be more active ENY calculation based on people in flight, not tower. JOKERs shouldn't be allowed to switch to autoswitch when they are done for the day and tower sit on another team to help bish. AFK timers would help prevent this, but tower sitting should also not impact ENY. I personally have no issues with ENY since I pretty much only fly 30+ ENY planes, but it seems like such a big problem for much of the player base it should be addressed. Currently there is no mechanism or punishment for people sitting in flight (cybro) either so more would just do that if tower sitters are taken out of the equation.
-
These GB hordes bring their own ENY mess. The gang bangs at already higher numbers make players log which ensures them eny, then they cry about it. They eat their own feet
-
What time of the day was the sample taken Lusche?
One interesting side story I read in your post Lusche is the reluctance for some players to take offensive action. Defensive play can produce better scoring if no horde is involved is my guess for those players that avoid offensive action. I do see it in prime time play but the number of players that prefer defensive play are limited but are very consistent in their game play.
I had proposed in the past using heavy clouds to reduce the number of bases that could be captured on the days map automatically based on number of players. Jimmy made note that was not as easy of a solution as it sounds.
-
(https://s3.amazonaws.com/armstrongeconomics-wp/2013/11/Dead-Horse.jpg)
-
Maps definitely make a difference more and more each day. And no not necessarily the size, but the layout is more important.
Maps like last nights Grinder2 with giant empty spaces in the middle makes it hard for people to move around. When things are slow on the rook side, I like to go mix it up with the other two because that’s usually where the Darbar is. Four sectors is my limit.
-
(https://s3.amazonaws.com/armstrongeconomics-wp/2013/11/Dead-Horse.jpg)
:rofl :rofl
-
a lot of tactical considerations here, and I still can't find a fight most nights ;) - most of the time two countries fight, there is enough juice for one decent furball a week left in the game, on one front line, on a good week ;) :bolt:
-
Fix the stupid radar so defense is viable and it stops feeding hordelings.
Maps need to be smaller. There shouldn’t be more bases than players.
Tower sleepers need to be booted.
-
Fix the stupid radar so defense is viable and it stops feeding hordelings.
Maps need to be smaller. There shouldn’t be more bases than players.
Tower sleepers need to be booted.
Fix Radar, and only smaller maps would make me consider a few nights in the arenas per month, Euro TZ sucks with anything but small maps.
-
is there an issue with radar? I've not noticed.
-
Lets pretend its in the 1940's, and you get a 21 century network centric all-seeing radar (read year 2029 with satellites and high flying AWACS ) that can see all of the battlefield, even behind mountains.
Now you cant hide, get altitude without being jumped, you cant fly in behind an attacking force unnoticed and create some havoc - even outnumbered (like it used to be).
You can even rely on an radar that tells you where the enemy is if you lost sight of the enemy in a dogfight - currently - not like it should be in a wwII sim (and like it used to be).
is there an issue with radar? I've not noticed.
-
You can tell which way a plane is pointed...
My guess is HT fears removing the easy play dar settings would scare away more players than it would make happy..
Eagler
-
Lets pretend its in the 1940's, and you get a 21 century network centric all-seeing radar (read year 2029 with satellites and high flying AWACS ) that can see all of the battlefield, even behind mountains.
Now you cant hide, get altitude without being jumped, you cant fly in behind an attacking force unnoticed and create some havoc - even outnumbered (like it used to be).
You can even rely on an radar that tells you where the enemy is if you lost sight of the enemy in a dogfight - currently - not like it should be in a wwII sim (and like it used to be).
You can also instantly tell bombers from fighters regardless of size, so a TBM taking off from a CV will instantly have a "come and get me" sign lit. Or you can tell a Mossie XVI from a Mossie VI by just looking at the map. Goons can't hope to evade detection by skillfully hugging terrain when the enemy can just fly around with his map open.
-
You can tell which way a plane is pointed...
My guess is HT fears removing the easy play dar settings would scare away more players than it would make happy..
Eagler
By doing so, he’s encouraging the lopsided gameplay that is occurring. Diminishing intangibles like cockpit visibility and cloud cover. Ruining the diversity of the game by pushing players into more competitive aircraft. Making SA a view of the clipboard. Relegated the C-47 to the trash bin. Diminishing the tactical effectiveness of radar towers (and therefore strats). Making invisible tree hugging GVs portable radar towers. Lumping players in smaller areas because being the point of the spear against any number advantage becomes borderline suicidal. Painting bomber formations on indirect routes (even outside of radar coverage) for everyone to see. Discouraging players from ranging too far from their friendlies.
I still say darbar was enough but there is a compromise. Make proximity radar (AWACS) available in the tower but not in flight. Let’s players find and even be directed to fights but doesn’t ruin the game.
-
There is nowhere near enough people playing this game to return to the old dar system. What we have now is just fine. This complaint needs to be put away for good.
-
By doing so, he’s encouraging the lopsided gameplay that is occurring. Diminishing intangibles like cockpit visibility and cloud cover. Ruining the diversity of the game by pushing players into more competitive aircraft. Making SA a view of the clipboard. Relegated the C-47 to the trash bin. Diminishing the tactical effectiveness of radar towers (and therefore strats). Making invisible tree hugging GVs portable radar towers. Lumping players in smaller areas because being the point of the spear against any number advantage becomes borderline suicidal. Painting bomber formations on indirect routes (even outside of radar coverage) for everyone to see. Discouraging players from ranging too far from their friendlies.
I still day darbar was enough but there is a compromise. Make proximity radar (AWACS) available in the tower but not in flight. Let’s players find and even be directed to fights but doesn’t ruin the game.
Coming back to the game around 2020, I was very surprised on the dar feature. Thought at first it was pretty cool and the concept did encourage folks to jump into battle. I honestly think that this was put into effect for the good intention. As usual, folks will find ways to dummy down the game (Like the unseen GVs that park hours in a bush just to flash a base).
-
You can also instantly tell bombers from fighters regardless of size, so a TBM taking off from a CV will instantly have a "come and get me" sign lit. Or you can tell a Mossie XVI from a Mossie VI by just looking at the map. Goons can't hope to evade detection by skillfully hugging terrain when the enemy can just fly around with his map open.
Let's not forget Cybro doing his darned best to announce the presence of the enemy fleet. :bhead
-
There is nowhere near not people playing this game to return to the old dar system. What we have now is just fine. This complaint needs to be put away for good.
If there are 10 players in the MA, there are enough. I will never give up on this argument. Even if it’s 2v1, it gives a large advantage to the side with the greater (local) numbers and is leading to a nearly constant seal clubbing of one side. It’s intuitive without even having to fully understand it. If players can’t comprehend that this is more of a detriment than a feature, it’s my job to point that out continuously until it changes or the game fails completely.
Coming back to the game around 2020, I was very surprised on the dar feature. Thought at first it was pretty cool and the concept did encourage folks to jump into battle. I honestly think that this was put into effect for the good intention. As usual, folks will find ways to dummy down the game (Like the unseen GVs that park hours in a bush just to flash a base).
Players can still jump into fights if they have access to AWACS in the tower. They shouldn’t have it in the cockpit unless they’re in a friendly radar ring. The GV issue especially rubs me the wrong way because that player asleep on the couch or eating Cheetos in the kitchen isn’t just flashing the base. They’re painting me on radar showing my type, direction of travel, and that I’m not particularly high to players inbound who are not even in my sector yet.
-
Problem with the current radar is that we never got any way to make suggestions. It was either this way or the old way. I completely agree a lot with what LilMak is saying. The DOT dar is extremely noobish. The only thing that really needed to change was the radar tower strength. That is why the dots never showed up in the previous way. Everyone killed radar first thing with a couple of cannons. Make the radar 5-10k to take down and youd have your dot dar most of the time. IT WAS THE SIMPILIST SOLUTION. For me, I like some indicators to know where the fight is and how many enemies there are, but currently its very tough to be sneaky or not get ganged once you appear on their screen. You can say, well that "encourages a fight" but it also disincentivizes people to want to fly such long distances to get jumped by 3 yak3s, 2 190Ds, and Spi16 just to make sure you have no chance at all. These things do have to be considered.
-
Problem with the current radar is that we never got any way to make suggestions. It was either this way or the old way. I completely agree a lot with what LilMak is saying. The DOT dar is extremely noobish. The only thing that really needed to change was the radar tower strength. That is why the dots never showed up in the previous way. Everyone killed radar first thing with a couple of cannons. Make the radar 5-10k to take down and youd have your dot dar most of the time. IT WAS THE SIMPILIST SOLUTION. For me, I like some indicators to know where the fight is and how many enemies there are, but currently its very tough to be sneaky or not get ganged once you appear on their screen. You can say, well that "encourages a fight" but it also disincentivizes people to want to fly such long distances to get jumped by 3 yak3s, 2 190Ds, and Spi16 just to make sure you have no chance at all. These things do have to be considered.
This proximity radar (also so-and-so killed so-and-so) was intended for it to be easier to find the enemy and make the arena seem more busy/populated. I get it. It worked. Too well. It really didn’t have much to do with radar towers themselves (which are too soft). The unintended consequences are it absolutely decimated defense in the game which is reactive. If you’re up against a larger force, it no longer matters what direction you come from. Altitude is a factor but how much altitude can you gain if you’re reacting to an attack where a squad has already been climbing for 10 minutes? Then, the SECOND you come in icon range with any of the attackers (not even made a turn to engage yet), every aircraft on the enemy side is instantly aware of you. Bombers change course to avoid you, fighters pick up perfect vectors to intercept you. Where you could have had couple passes to let a dogfight mature before magic radar, you might have one (if you’re lucky two) turns before the entire enemy force is barreling down on you now. There’s little incentive to defend if you’re just relentlessly getting swatted down before you can even close the distance and get guns on the first icon on your screen. So you end up with what we have now. A cycle of players attacking with fewer and fewer defenders even attempting to stem the tide. Then you have two sides just beating mercilessly on one and it has very little to do with which chess piece you fly for. Team 1 and team 2 are beating up on team 3. Team 3 can only muster any kind of defense against team 2. Meanwhile team 1 is just rolling bases and any token defense is just obliterated. Players on team 1 are getting bored, and team 3 is getting beat so bad it’s frustrating. So logging ensues. It’s also starting to resemble a middle school dance when two decent sized forces meet. Both are standing against their own walls waiting for a single player to cross into the middle. The first player who crosses the dance floor is bait for their own team and ruthlessly bounced by the enemy.
If the goal of proximity radar is/was to make it easier to find a fight, the tower is the place to do that. If you can see all the proximity targets from the tower (and only the tower) then you launch in your preferred location and start looking out the glass instead of at the clipboard.
-
I think the fix here is to have the proxy radar in tower only.. as stated previously.
-
Yeah, great points on the radar issues. When I asked, I was assuming there was a technical problem - but I agree that the god-mode radar is too much.
I played in my first ever FSO the other night. No radar at all and icons visible only within 1k yards. That was fun! I really liked that. I think I even ducked into a cloud once and got out of a hairy situation.
I think there needs to be some radar so people know where a fight is, in general - that's it. I would love having very limited radar.
-
Yeah, great points on the radar issues. When I asked, I was assuming there was a technical problem - but I agree that the god-mode radar is too much.
I played in my first ever FSO the other night. No radar at all and icons visible only within 1k yards. That was fun! I really liked that. I think I even ducked into a cloud once and got out of a hairy situation.
I think there needs to be some radar so people know where a fight is, in general - that's it. I would love having very limited radar.
I think the radar settings in FSO are just about perfect. You gotta have your head on a swivel and you have to really look around which to me, seems more realistic and adds some excitement. I like the kill shooter setting as well as you need to watch out for friendlies when you are prayin' and sprayin' like me.
Last week in FSO I re-upped along with some AK's and a couple squad mates and we headed back to where the big fight was. We were gaining alt in the puffy clouds and I was surrounded by friendlies. I figured it'd be safe to take my eye off the sky for a bit and watch a second of the ball game on the TV across the office. Sure enough, 4 seconds into doing that, one of the AK's is yelling for me to break. Of course I was late in doing so and Finny had deftly jumped me and sawed my tail off. Settings that lead to perils such as that along with the camaraderie of folks flying in such conditions is why I'm still here.
-
Mak and Lazer have it about right on the radar settings I think.
Keep the bardar in the air, just not the dots from prox dar, only ground dar.
IMO GVs don't need any further help hiding, leave it as is, but that's just me.
Wiley.
-
With all due respect to all, this talk is all great, but impotent. You still have to convince Hitech to get any changes. :bolt:
-
With all due respect to all, this talk is all great, but impotent. You still have to convince Hitech to get any changes. :bolt:
This ^^^
The MA is for practice, it's game based. If you want more reality, the sim based, it's in events, so it IS available. Move
I'd be fine with Dot-Dar. But it really doesn't bother me at all.
I have zero idea how numbers matter in any dar, other than used as a vehicle for a repeat.
60-70 fly FSO, it has zero negative effects, in fact it has positive effects, as were just posted.
We roll over the same subjects weekly. It's become agonizing.
As I've said before, many times,... if the game were gone tomorrow, you'd wish it back with all it's flaws.
-
With all due respect to all, this talk is all great, but impotent. You still have to convince Hitech to get any changes. :bolt:
The solution is obvious, we must sentence Dale to actually play in the MA for two weeks on a trial-basis :banana:
-
Let me put this another way. In the context of the game, attackers can be thought of as predators and defenders prey. Proximity radar has upset the balance of the ecosystem which now heavily favors the predators. This translates to fewer prey animals. Mostly because there isn’t tall grass to bound around in. Predators will continue love it until the prey dries up completely.
There’s evidence this is happening by the way the MA is playing out with a virtualy continuous two sided beat down of one side. There is probably some metric HT used to determine whether the radar change had the desired effect (sorties/kills per hour?) in the MA. This probably verified his results. But the quality of the MA as whole went down significantly. And those qualities are mostly intangible and hard to quantify. Players quit because of it. It’s documented on these message boards.
For the record. I’m not asking for Dale to revert back to dot radar. The icon radar (bomber/fighter/direction of flight) is something that I can live with…within active radar rings or in the tower before launch. What sucks is every single player is an individual radar tower in flight and it’s an arena setting. Not code. If the argument is that the MA should be gamey, then let’s even up the score. I want every single GV was displayed on my radar the same way they show me if it’s within my icon range. I’m sure nearly everyone reading this can understand intuitively why that’s is a bad idea. It’s the exact same thing for aircraft. Zero difference. None.
-
Some great points made in this thread. Maybe we should report all the good ones so Dale has to look at them as it seems that's the only way he'll notice them.
-
With all due respect to all, this talk is all great, but impotent. You still have to convince Hitech to get any changes. :bolt:
The same as it has always been for the entire life of the game. He's the only one you have to convince, the rest is just noise.
The solution is obvious, we must sentence Dale to actually play in the MA for two weeks on a trial-basis :banana:
How do you know he doesn't?
Wiley.
-
currently its very tough to be sneaky or not get ganged once you appear on their screen. You can say, well that "encourages a fight" but it also disincentivizes people to want to fly such long distances to get jumped by 3 yak3s, 2 190Ds, and Spi16 just to make sure you have no chance at all.
These are good points, and I think they once again show the difference between the group that wants to capture the map, and the group that just wants to have dogfights. The ganging certainly is nothing new; if anything, it is not as bad now as back when we had those massive squad nights (anyone remember the name of the one that was held once each week?). The ability to "sneak" or "outwit the other side" is important to the first group, and seems counter-productive to the second group. I like the current radar system because it makes it easy to find fights, but I respect the people who want to defend (or attack) bases as part of The War. We need both groups.
- oldman
-
60-70 fly FSO, it has zero negative effects, in fact it has positive effects, as were just posted.
That means nothing though. Scheduled events where people show up (more or less) on the same page about what they will be doing at that time are just not comparable to the main arena. The settings they use for Monday Night Madness also work well for what it is, they would be a horror show in the main.
Like Mak and Violator, most of what I want to do is defense. I like to fly to control airspace. The description of the two lines of alt monkeys with empty space in the middle until someone commits is exactly what I've been seeing the last few weeks.
Not sure which is worse, in the times before this dar, I can remember defense basically being nothing but NOE whack-a-mole because attackers could hide what they were doing trivially. It was not tremendously fulfilling either.
IMO as far as gameplay goes, defending a base with aircraft is your worst option most of the time. The best defense is generally resupply. To my mind, that should not be, but it's the way things have evolved over time.
Wiley.
-
How do you know he doesn't?
Because changes would have been made if he did :rock
-
As far as I know, Hitech has not been in the game much, except during the recent outage issues. I have suggested to him, that he got on the game anonymously for 20 to 40 minutes a week. As far as I know, that has not happened.
I am not aware of any Arena settings for the Proximity Dar, of course I could be wrong.
-
As far as I know, Hitech has not been in the game much, except during the recent outage issues. I have suggested to him, that he got on the game anonymously for 20 to 40 minutes a week. As far as I know, that has not happened.
I am not aware of any Arena settings for the Proximity Dar, of course I could be wrong.
I have no reason to believe there isn’t a setting for it. I also give HT enough credit that it could’ve gone catastrophically wrong when he implemented it and he would have needed a quick way to undo it. I fully believe it would show in events like FSO and scenarios if it wasn’t adjustable. Of course he could chime in and tell me how wrong I am…
-
That means nothing though. Scheduled events where people show up (more or less) on the same page about what they will be doing at that time are just not comparable to the main arena. The settings they use for Monday Night Madness also work well for what it is, they would be a horror show in the main.
Like Mak and Violator, most of what I want to do is defense. I like to fly to control airspace. The description of the two lines of alt monkeys with empty space in the middle until someone commits is exactly what I've been seeing the last few weeks.
Not sure which is worse, in the times before this dar, I can remember defense basically being nothing but NOE whack-a-mole because attackers could hide what they were doing trivially. It was not tremendously fulfilling either.
IMO as far as gameplay goes, defending a base with aircraft is your worst option most of the time. The best defense is generally resupply. To my mind, that should not be, but it's the way things have evolved over time.
Wiley.
In the old days I’d defend with a spit 25% fuel. Now days I will not up a capped base. I come up another and go after the enemy source base. I hate defending a capped base.
-
I’m sorry you guys are all wishing for things that are just from days past and to need it let go.
I play for an hour or two a night if I get that time at all, which I feel is probably the norm for a lot of people. The less guessing I have to do the better.
There just is not enough people anymore. It’s barely getting over 95 a night here in the summer already. Yes I know there’s the occasional spike for this night or that squad here and there, but it’s getting less and less and less. No need to rehash this conversation.
-
I’m sorry you guys are all wishing for things that are just from days past and to need it let go.
I play for an hour or two a night if I get that time at all, which I feel is probably the norm for a lot of people. The less guessing I have to do the better.
There just is not enough people anymore. It’s barely getting over 95 a night here in the summer already. Yes I know there’s the occasional spike for this night or that squad here and there, but it’s getting less and less and less. No need to rehash this conversation.
Not gonna let it go. There are enough people. You wouldn’t have to guess but you might have to look out the window.
-
I trust the progression that’s already been shown several times by the fella who started the thread in the first place.
-
I’m sorry you guys are all wishing for things that are just from days past and to need it let go.
I play for an hour or two a night if I get that time at all, which I feel is probably the norm for a lot of people. The less guessing I have to do the better.
There just is not enough people anymore. It’s barely getting over 95 a night here in the summer already. Yes I know there’s the occasional spike for this night or that squad here and there, but it’s getting less and less and less. No need to rehash this conversation.
You been saying the same thing for a very long time.
I honestly don’t think you pay attention to MA numbers. I posted it on 200 knowng you’re playing. We are over 95 many times. Last 2 FSO night we hit exactly the same number two weeks in a row 152. Many nights we hit over 100 EXCEPT Wed or Thurs, because no ine seems to have sqd nights thise days.
I’m burnt out on proving you wrong over and over. If you want to stick to dooms day that’s your choice
But its summer numbers and we still hit 110 to 152 in game. Prove me wrong.
152 is absurd for summer.
His numbers do not mention actual MA numbers, different subject.
-
Regardless of is this bothers you, or doesnt.. it creates pretty lame gameplay as mentioned by lilmak.
Not having to look around, and having some toejambag sitting in a tree with a tank marking your position is lame.
I was one that advocated for this type of dar prior to being implemented... now i will eat crow and admit the cons outweigh the pros.
-
That is a terribly wide sweeping generalization. There is not lame gameplay all around. The same people are playing every single day.
This game is subjective, it’s not up to me whether or not you should enjoy it.
I prefer to know what’s in the air, you don’t have to.
-
I am all for Moving back to the old radar settings.
If for no other reason, it is a move back towards combat simulation and from away from Arcade type game play.
The hunt is part of the reason I started playing combat flight sims in the first place.
CAV
-
I was one that advocated for this type of dar prior to being implemented... now i will eat crow and admit the cons outweigh the pros.
Initially I didn’t really care. People were more upset about the kill messages. It didn’t take long for me to see what was developing and detest it.
-
One thing that should be done is eliminate ground vehicles AWACS capability. Since airplanes only get a vague red square where the invisible GV is lurking, make it the same for GVs looking at their map for airplanes: they get the same vague red square. Quid pro quo, ground critters.
-
I think the radar settings in FSO are just about perfect. You gotta have your head on a swivel and you have to really look around which to me, seems more realistic and adds some excitement. I like the kill shooter setting as well as you need to watch out for friendlies when you are prayin' and sprayin' like me.
Last week in FSO I re-upped along with some AK's and a couple squad mates and we headed back to where the big fight was. We were gaining alt in the puffy clouds and I was surrounded by friendlies. I figured it'd be safe to take my eye off the sky for a bit and watch a second of the ball game on the TV across the office. Sure enough, 4 seconds into doing that, one of the AK's is yelling for me to break. Of course I was late in doing so and Finny had deftly jumped me and sawed my tail off. Settings that lead to perils such as that along with the camaraderie of folks flying in such conditions is why I'm still here.
Yeah, I agree! The kill shooter setting as well. Yes, all good
-
Yeah, I agree! The kill shooter setting as well. Yes, all good
Kill shooter adjustment wouldn’t work in the MA. You’d have folks with beef on the same team shooting each other. Imagine you’re 200 off an enemy’s 6 with your finger on the trigger when your teammate kills you to kill the enemy. Too many griefers for that to work. Even in FSO it can get dicey. I remember one time someone “accidentally” fired of a rocket when 20 players were launching on the runway. Funny one time. Not funny if there’s some guy in the tower who thinks it’s funny to kill you repeatedly as you spawn on the runway.
One thing that should be done is eliminate ground vehicles AWACS capability. Since airplanes only get a vague red square where the invisible GV is lurking, make it the same for GVs looking at their map for airplanes: they get the same vague red square. Quid pro quo, ground critters.
One exception I could live with would be a PT boat. Actually has a radar mast. Can only be used by boats who can’t hide under trees.
AWACS overall just needs to go away…in flight. Sitting in the tower it’s fine. Allows players overall view of where to go and find action. Could actually be used to verbally direct friendlies/squadies (ATC) while you’re sipping your beer in the tower. The balance (pre AWACS) was much better and radar could be countered to eliminate the defensive advantage. There is no countermeasure for AWACS.
-
In the old days I’d defend with a spit 25% fuel. Now days I will not up a capped base. I come up another and go after the enemy source base. I hate defending a capped base.
This may have been your personal SOP long before AWACS, but it’s essentially a perfect summary of what AWACS has done to the MA. Instead of individual players doing this, entire teams are doing it.
Defense against a larger force is becoming suicidal but it no longer has anything to do with proximity to a capped base. If one or two players try to intercept a decent sized darbar, they’re going to get swatted down because the larger force has an exponential advantage. The solution previously was to up a base that isn’t capped and attempt to flank or harass the attack. AWACS has turned the airspace itself into a “capped base” because, before you close the 6k icon distance and fire a single bullet, every single enemy in the area is already converging on an exact single piont. You! They don’t even have to “see” you to do this.
-
Air Warrior was set so you could shoot friendlies, but there were penalties if you did. Like you'd get grounded, if I recall. Seemed to work.
But I don't have a beef with kill shooter really. I don't get why someone have to take damage when shooting a friendly though. Why do you have to take damage? why not just have nothing happen? Or maybe an audible sound when pinging a friendly
No beef with it though.
My beef is mostly with anything added to the game that penalizes any player or attempts to manipulate player behavior in the name of "fairness" or balancing the numbers.
So, ENY sucks. I'll never agree that ENY is anything but crap. lol
-
This may have been your personal SOP long before AWACS, but it’s essentially a perfect summary of what AWACS has done to the MA. Instead of individual players doing this, entire teams are doing it.
Defense against a larger force is becoming suicidal but it no longer has anything to do with proximity to a capped base. If one or two players try to intercept a decent sized darbar, they’re going to get swatted down because the larger force has an exponential advantage. The solution previously was to up a base that isn’t capped and attempt to flank or harass the attack. AWACS has turned the airspace itself into a “capped base” because, before you close the 6k icon distance and fire a single bullet, every single enemy in the area is already converging on an exact single piont. You! They don’t even have to “see” you to do this.
I understand your pov
Well, like many repeat subjects, I’ve come to terms with a change is more likely to not happen. So I try to ignore those subjects (and some people who exhibit compulsive repetition) and often fail (gluten for punishment) and move on.
IMO, it is what it is. <shrug>
Repeats makes me wanna choke lil white bunny rabbits. Is that wrong?
-
Air Warrior was set so you could shoot friendlies, but there were penalties if you did. Like you'd get grounded, if I recall. Seemed to work.
But I don't have a beef with kill shooter really. I don't get why someone have to take damage when shooting a friendly though. Why do you have to take damage? why not just have nothing happen?
Because in a conga line behind you everybody could just blast away happily without having to take the friendlies between him and the target into consideration.
-
I understand your pov
Well, like many repeat subjects, I’ve come to terms with a change is more likely to not happen. So I try to ignore those subjects (and some people who exhibit compulsive repetition) and often fail (gluten for punishment) and move on.
IMO, it is what it is. <shrug>
Repeats makes me wanna choke lil white bunny rabbits. Is that wrong?
It is what it is pretty much applies to every aspect of the game.
Threads like this one generally do nothing, but it's semi-interesting to note how different things have impacted the game and different peoples' experiences, particularly after a change has been implemented for a while.
I was in favor of the AWACs because I was very sick of seeing scouts call out attacks and people ignoring it until it got into radar range. If it isn't a dot on radar, it doesn't exist to a lot of people. It improved people coming to defend because they could see the enemy aircraft. Unfortunate side effect is the two lines of altmonkeys staring at each other and a lot of them reversing if they see something co-alt. Which leads to a possible refinement as Mak and Lazer have suggested, only having it in tower. Although I don't know if it would change much, people still reverse when they see something co-alt coming at them.
But change coming from a forum post these days is... let's be kind and say "unlikely".
The repetitive subjects have different levels too. 2 sided MA for example, HT has said in as many words, "Not going to happen." He has a couple hills he's going to die on. Edit: Side switch timer getting shorter is another.
Those are the threads that irk me.
Not sure where AWACS falls on that continuum, when he was trying different things, it seemed tweakable with settings. But either he doesn't see a problem with the way it currently works, or he doesn't know what the emergent gameplay has become. IMO the latter is where discussion might have a chance, if he A) sees a problem with the way it works and B) sees a solution to it.
But at the end of the day, it's probably just noise.
Wiley.
-
Because in a conga line behind you everybody could just blast away happily without having to take the friendlies between him and the target into consideration.
good point. Makes sense.
-
I understand your pov
Well, like many repeat subjects, I’ve come to terms with a change is more likely to not happen. So I try to ignore those subjects (and some people who exhibit compulsive repetition) and often fail (gluten for punishment) and move on.
IMO, it is what it is. <shrug>
Repeats makes me wanna choke lil white bunny rabbits. Is that wrong?
What you do with your bunnies in the privacy of your own home is your business. I don’t judge. :lol
I get what you’re saying about repeating the same things over again and I know that it’s tiresome to watch me rail against this. But I feel it’s truly detrimental to the game in my bones. This is the hill I will die on. Especially since I understand it would take minimal effort to test or change. I’m not asking for a return to dot radar, a new plane, revamped graphics, or months of work.
For the record, I have many gripes that I’ve voiced issues with…88s, field resupply, feet dry spawns and others. I can live with those and can let them go. This one issue is accelerating the decline of the MA as a viable place to have fun for pilots like myself and others who are here to carve out good fights regardless of score or survival. If I can have a good fight before I get absolutely trounced (win or lose), I’ll be back with a fresh new ride to be a target again. AWACS has severely degraded or, in many cases, completely eliminated my ability to have fun before I get dog piled. I’m here pointing out unintended consequences of a decision that seemed to make sense on the surface. I’m not alone because many thought it was a good idea at first but are witnessing the cost does not outweigh the benefits. Most of the push back against reverting to darbar and radar towers for coverage seems to be players that are, at least, part time wall flowers. I’m conceding that the tower is a good place to find the fights you’re looking for without ruining the intangibles that struck the balance between sim and game that have made AH nearly perfect. Without anyone brave or stupid enough to cross the dance floor, the entire dance collapses and people go home. Pilots like myself, laser, violator, and others are getting more and more frustrated with this to the extent that it’s really starting to affect the amount of fun we can extract from the game in a given hour. We are the “prey” and, like it or not, if we disappear, there will be nothing left for the “predators” to eat. I’m under no illusion that my gripe will stop hordes or relentless pickers nor do I expect people to play “my way”.
This thread started as a which team has the numbers kinda thing. That’s not real the problem at least not all of it. The problem is fights need a little while to mature in order to make them viable. It doesn’t take a massive horde to ruin that maturation. Three on one will usually be enough. AWACS gives the side with three a 200% advantage in situational awareness. Three players see exactly what I’m doing but I only see one until the other two come into icon range. This lets them set up perfect intercepts, avoid contact altogether, or plan perfect picks which not only reduces my chance of survival but the amount of actual time I do survive.
If there is an insistent need to find the enemy, lets just turn the radar on 100%. Paint every, tank, plane, ship, manned gun in glowing red on the map. At least the playing field would be even for everyone all the time. Not this thing where whoever just happens to have more planes in a local grid square or two gets exponential advantages with no way to counter it.
-
Well, I think it was for new players. Doesn’t seem many are thinking of new players, as if we don’t need them.
Events
-
Was the point of this thread to achieve some changes?
-
This one issue is accelerating the decline of the MA as a viable place to have fun for pilots like myself and others who are here to carve out good fights regardless of score or survival. If I can have a good fight before I get absolutely trounced (win or lose), I’ll be back with a fresh new ride to be a target again. ... Most of the push back against reverting to darbar and radar towers for coverage seems to be players that are, at least, part time wall flowers.
Hmmm. I've been called many things, but "wallflower" is a new one! Like you, I'm here to have good fights, and my score and survival rates are legendary (just look!). I find at least one good fight every night I'm on. I don't understand why you can't. Engaging multiple bandits is part of having a good fight.
- oldman
-
Well, I think it was for new players. Doesn’t seem many are thinking of new players, as if we don’t need them.
Events
It was for the new players, but if old players step up new players can learn faster. During squad night last night we had a newbi on asking questions and we got him flying and dying with us all night. He had no trouble finding a fight or to understand what to do to help, he asked, we helped him to find the fights/action.
-
Hmmm. I've been called many things, but "wallflower" is a new one! Like you, I'm here to have good fights, and my score and survival rates are legendary (just look!). I find at least one good fight every night I'm on. I don't understand why you can't. Engaging multiple bandits is part of having a good fight.
- oldman
Let me straighten this out…
First: I don’t believe called anyone out specifically in this thread. Certainly not you. Sorry you felt attacked.
Second: I never said I can’t still find a good fight. I absolutely would not pay for this game if I couldn’t.
Third: I’ve spent most of my time (over two uninterrupted decades) in AH running headlong into multiple bandits. Often alone, low, and mostly in a plane that won’t let me write checks that my ACM can’t cash. So, you’re right, engaging in multiple bandits has been pretty fun.
But “multiple” can have infinite variables. For example 10 v 1 is a blast if the enemy only comes at you one or two at a time. Not nearly as fun when all 10 are on you simultaneously. Can you see the difference Oldman? (Yes this is me specifically talking to you for the first time in this thread)
-
It was for the new players, but if old players step up new players can learn faster. During squad night last night we had a newbi on asking questions and we got him flying and dying with us all night. He had no trouble finding a fight or to understand what to do to help, he asked, we helped him to find the fights/action.
There is nowhere near the organizational infrastructure or the desire to create that could absorb a new player base and attract them in any capacity.
Enjoy what we have while we have it.
-
Let me straighten this out…
First: I don’t believe called anyone out specifically in this thread. Certainly not you. Sorry you felt attacked.
Second: I never said I can’t still find a good fight. I absolutely would not pay for this game if I couldn’t.
Third: I’ve spent most of my time (over two uninterrupted decades) in AH running headlong into multiple bandits. Often alone, low, and mostly in a plane that won’t let me write checks that my ACM can’t cash. So, you’re right, engaging in multiple bandits has been pretty fun.
But “multiple” can have infinite variables. For example 10 v 1 is a blast if the enemy only comes at you one or two at a time. Not nearly as fun when all 10 are on you simultaneously. Can you see the difference Oldman? (Yes this is me specifically talking to you for the first time in this thread)
No offense taken! In my case, "wallflower" probably is an accurate description! I just thought it was an unfortunate way to diminish the views of people who like the current settings.
Searching my memory, I can recall cases when as many as six were trying to nab me. Those were exciting - if short - fights. Ten would be a lot. But I suspect where we really differ is in our goals. You are trying to defend a base, so getting shot down by a horde makes a difference in what you're trying to do. By contrast, defending the base isn't important to me. If the base falls, there will be another fight at another base. I'm just there for those fights. Either way, I don't see that the DAR settings encourage ganging any more than planned missions do.
As I wrote earlier, I think it takes both types.
- oldman
-
There is nowhere near the organizational infrastructure or the desire to create that could absorb a new player base and attract them in any capacity.
Enjoy what we have while we have it.
I dont agree with this at all. There are still quite a few of us who go out of our way to help.
There are the guys who do all the planning and organizing, and scoring for the scenarios, FSO and such.
There are the guys who spend hundreds of hours on map making/rebuilding
The guys who spend as much time skinning planes and vehicles and run the approval process for Dale to add them to the game.
Then there are the guys that post videos, like me, to Youtube to use that platform to get the "word" out there along with social media.
Then there are those guys who maintain sites/servers with info/tips/help about the game. Squad pages as well.
Then those players in game that are always ready to help. Be it with technical issues or if someone needs supplies. We have a lot of players willing to help.
All of this promotes the game. I know I have seen a dozen or more new players come in from seeing posts on social media and youtube, and many more returning players due to the social media side. I know Im always harping on "click like, subscribe and comment!" on my posts about my videos, but each time any of you do those things YOU are helping bring people to the game.
Are we "organized"? Some what, are we "creative"?, every single day!!! Could we do more? Yup, and we are all looking for more ways to help promote the game and welcome new players.
-
There will always be those that see issues as "the glass is half empty", then there are those that see issues as "the glass is half full". All things being equal, I would rather be on the Up side. It makes life more enjoyable. :cheers:
-
I dont agree with this at all. There are still quite a few of us who go out of our way to help.
There are the guys who do all the planning and organizing, and scoring for the scenarios, FSO and such.
There are the guys who spend hundreds of hours on map making/rebuilding
The guys who spend as much time skinning planes and vehicles and run the approval process for Dale to add them to the game.
Then there are the guys that post videos, like me, to Youtube to use that platform to get the "word" out there along with social media.
Then there are those guys who maintain sites/servers with info/tips/help about the game. Squad pages as well.
Then those players in game that are always ready to help. Be it with technical issues or if someone needs supplies. We have a lot of players willing to help.
All of this promotes the game. I know I have seen a dozen or more new players come in from seeing posts on social media and youtube, and many more returning players due to the social media side. I know Im always harping on "click like, subscribe and comment!" on my posts about my videos, but each time any of you do those things YOU are helping bring people to the game.
Are we "organized"? Some what, are we "creative"?, every single day!!! Could we do more? Yup, and we are all looking for more ways to help promote the game and welcome new players.
This was not a knock on anyone in the community in any way. Without all the sweat equity around here it would be less fun. They are gladly applauded and there’s lots of posts from me doing just that.
The same core still exists. There is clearly no desire from the “company” to do anything to either cultivate or manage a grand new influx of people or improvements.
Unless I missed a memo all these points are moot.
-
There will always be those that see issues as "the glass is half empty", then there are those that see issues as "the glass is half full". All things being equal, I would rather be on the Up side. It makes life more enjoyable. :cheers:
Realistic is not the same as pessimistic.
I’m one of the only people around here that does not have a problem with the way things are. I kinda like it here! :cheers:
-
Realistic is not the same as pessimistic.
I’m one of the only people around here that does not have a problem with the way things are. I kinda like it here! :cheers:
I like my house. Still bought new shelves for the garage. Also painted some cabinets a few weeks ago.
-
Great for your house lol
The house you’re staying in here only has a caretaker.
-
Sorry to jump in randomly, but count me in the Lil Mak/Vio/Etc camp. Dar settings are hard to deal with when you're trying to fight a swarm taking a base. And I can easily setup an ambush as a defender is transiting to the designated seal-clubbing base when they pass over that random Cheeto-eating GVer watching porn on his other monitor . :joystick:
If there are 10 players in the MA, there are enough. I will never give up on this argument. Even if it’s 2v1, it gives a large advantage to the side with the greater (local) numbers and is leading to a nearly constant seal clubbing of one side. It’s intuitive without even having to fully understand it. If players can’t comprehend that this is more of a detriment than a feature, it’s my job to point that out continuously until it changes or the game fails completely.
Players can still jump into fights if they have access to AWACS in the tower. They shouldn’t have it in the cockpit unless they’re in a friendly radar ring. The GV issue especially rubs me the wrong way because that player asleep on the couch or eating Cheetos in the kitchen isn’t just flashing the base. They’re painting me on radar showing my type, direction of travel, and that I’m not particularly high to players inbound who are not even in my sector yet.
:salute
HlyWd
-
that random Cheeto-eating GVer watching porn on his other monitor
It's harder then it looks! You have to make sure you don't grab the wrong things wit the Cheeto hand!
-
It's harder then it looks! You have to make sure you don't grab the wrong things wit the Cheeto hand!
:rofl
-
It's harder then it looks! You have to make sure you don't grab the wrong things wit the Cheeto hand!
What if your wife likes cheetos?
You always got to think a head.
So to speak.