Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aircraft and Vehicles => Topic started by: caldera on July 25, 2026, 10:44:39 PM

Title: observations of the damage models
Post by: caldera on July 25, 2026, 10:44:39 PM
Different planes seem to routinely take damage in different locations.  This is anecdotal and a small sample size of planes, but with enough experience, pattern recognition isn't just unsubstantiated imagination. 

What's really interesting is these two sets of planes have the exact opposite results.  For the record, I can't remember ever losing the main gun in the Yak and know for a fact (as it's only recent memory) I've yet to get one single pilot wound in the A-5.  I got a LOT of broken guns in the 39 (posted at least 40 screen shots of the gun being the only damage - what are the odds?) and P-38 pilots can corroborate that the pilot is a lead magnet.


Yak-9T : indestructible 37mm cannon
P-39Q: 37mm cannon made of very thin glass

P-38J: pilot wound is standard equipment
190A-5: bulletproof pilot


And I'm not even going to mention the titanium/balsa wood Yak-3.  Yes, nothing will be done about these things.  I just felt like venting.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: hazmatt on July 26, 2026, 12:17:21 AM
Don't forget the D9 with a radiator the size of a barn!
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Dadtallica on July 26, 2026, 07:14:28 AM
Two nights ago in a Ta152 I was tangling with people and flew close to a town for three consecutive passes. I heard one ack hit me each time… they took out all my guns one by one. I had yet to fire a shot.

I was made and chuckling all at once!  :joystick:
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Wiley on July 26, 2026, 11:12:11 AM
Two nights ago in a Ta152 I was tangling with people and flew close to a town for three consecutive passes. I heard one ack hit me each time… they took out all my guns one by one. I had yet to fire a shot.

I was made and chuckling all at once!  :joystick:

One ping nose cannon destruction happens a L O T to me in that plane, frustrating as hell on your first pass on bombers.

Now Caldera's got me thinking about the A5...  It feels like it has to have happened, I've flown it a bunch, but I can't think of an instance. :headscratch: Thinking I might have to put in a couple days flying it to see.

Wiley.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: caldera on July 26, 2026, 03:12:40 PM
One ping nose cannon destruction happens a L O T to me in that plane, frustrating as hell on your first pass on bombers.

Now Caldera's got me thinking about the A5...  It feels like it has to have happened, I've flown it a bunch, but I can't think of an instance. :headscratch: Thinking I might have to put in a couple days flying it to see.

Wiley.

If you do get a PW, remember to get a screenshot of the damage list.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: oTRALFZo on July 27, 2026, 12:07:42 PM
One ping nose cannon destruction happens a L O T to me in that plane, frustrating as hell on your first pass on bombers.

Now Caldera's got me thinking about the A5...  It feels like it has to have happened, I've flown it a bunch, but I can't think of an instance. :headscratch: Thinking I might have to put in a couple days flying it to see.

Wiley.
Same here. I have to deal with it regularly especially when tasked to deack town guns. Usually 1 hit and my 30s are jammed.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Wiley on July 29, 2026, 07:42:09 PM
If you do get a PW, remember to get a screenshot of the damage list.

Sorry, happened too fast before tower.  I did receive a PW tonight in a 190A-5 though.

Wiley.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Animl-AW on July 29, 2026, 09:14:59 PM
Facing the nose of a fighter plane the cockpit and engine are the biggest targets, your nose is first in. All the guns are shooting right there. It's when you're passing through you take on other types of strikes,... now you're broadside. The damage model is not a randomizer, it's surface strikes. Hitting a certain part triggers a damage animation and effect for that area.

D9 the radiator is in the nose, in front of the engine like a car, and usually the first thing to go, that or an oil leak, sometimes both. Biggest objects in front view.
In a 38 the engines and cockpit are the largest parts, more likely to be hit first.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Devil 505 on July 29, 2026, 09:19:45 PM
Facing the nose of a fighter plane the cockpit and engine are the biggest targets, your nose is first in. All the guns are shooting right there. It's when you're passing through you take on other types of strikes,... now you're broadside. The damage model is not a randomizer, it's surface strikes. Hitting a certain part triggers a damage animation and effect for that area.

D9 the radiator is in the nose, in front of the engine like a car, and usually the first thing to go, that or an oil leak, sometimes both. Biggest objects in front view.
In a 38 the engines and cockpit are the largest parts, more likely to be hit first.

Makayla did some testing on the P-38 years ago. The pilot hit box is larger than the cockpit.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Animl-AW on July 29, 2026, 10:06:28 PM
Makayla did some testing on the P-38 years ago. The pilot hit box is larger than the cockpit.

How much bigger matters. I wonder why.

How did he determine that? Because online films can be inaccurate.

I know in the D9 I get a lot of PWs.
I wonder how it’s applied to all planes.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Devil 505 on July 29, 2026, 10:42:58 PM
How much bigger matters. I wonder why.

How did he determine that? Because online films can be inaccurate.

I know in the D9 I get a lot of PWs.
I wonder how it’s applied to all planes.

He tested it by sitting in a parked P-38 while another player in a jeep fired single rounds into it.. From what he said, the pilot hit box was most of the area between the engine nacelles.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: caldera on July 30, 2026, 06:13:46 PM
Sorry, happened too fast before tower.  I did receive a PW tonight in a 190A-5 though.

Wiley.

Interesting.  Thanks for the info.

I've been killed in the A-5 about 70 times recently and had many other sorties end by escaping with various damage.
Ailerons, V-stab, wing tips and cowl guns are the most prevalent.  Aft fuel and inboard cannon a few times and one time fwd fuel.  Sometimes blown up outright.  Had the engine insta-killed by a Spit XVI but still no blood. 

It's really weird coming from the P-38 to the 190.  Lots of pilot wounds to none.
Maybe it's just luck that's about to run out.  If I do get a PW, I will update here.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Wiley on July 30, 2026, 08:25:45 PM
Interesting.  Thanks for the info.

I've been killed in the A-5 about 70 times recently and had many other sorties end by escaping with various damage.
Ailerons, V-stab, wing tips and cowl guns are the most prevalent.  Aft fuel and inboard cannon a few times and one time fwd fuel.  Sometimes blown up outright.  Had the engine insta-killed by a Spit XVI but still no blood. 

It's really weird coming from the P-38 to the 190.  Lots of pilot wounds to none.
Maybe it's just luck that's about to run out.  If I do get a PW, I will update here.

My suspicion is it's in the vicinity of what Animal was talking about.  Different planes and their components and geometry having different stuff get hit first/often.  Dora's glass jaw radiator is well known, the front(?) fuel tank almost always gets hit as well.  What Devil mentioned about the 38 doesn't surprise me either.

Interesting that you're finding it difficult to get a PW in the A5.  I only flew a couple sorties before I got mine.  It's probably the 190 I fly the least, other than the F8, and PWs are not at all uncommon in the A8, D9 and Ta.  It just had me curious because I couldn't remember a specific instance.

Wiley.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: hazmatt on July 31, 2026, 05:09:49 PM
Makayla did some testing on the P-38 years ago. The pilot hit box is larger than the cockpit.

Ya I suspect that it's the same with the D9's radiator. I don't recall other planes like the P-51 getting hit in the radiator near as often in the same situations (like de-acking a town for example) I suspect it's the same for the TA-152s cannons.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: hazmatt on July 31, 2026, 05:13:07 PM
  Dora's glass jaw radiator is well known, the front(?) fuel tank almost always gets hit as well. 

What I always found interesting is how often I took a hit in the radiator on the D9 when somebody was firing at me from behind. One would think that would be one of the last things to be hit if the rounds are coming from your 6.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Animl-AW on August 01, 2026, 12:49:21 PM
I can’t confirm about the “hit square” thing. But note, it’s a pilot wound, a head wound should be death. That said the difference between the 38 and some other fighters is the engine isn’t in front of the pilot taking the hit. You have guns but no engine there, the rounds can be easier to  pass through front of the cockpit. This may explain why the “hit square” is bigger.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: LCADolby on August 01, 2026, 01:06:46 PM
From memory I never really suffered the PWs in the P38 (usually insta-towered), but did so in the A5.

The D9s fragile Rad is all but legendary as well as all the 190 series Forward Fuel Tanks.

Nose gun(s) in the 152, 262 and P39 all tragically lost so easily in fights.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Animl-AW on August 01, 2026, 02:10:34 PM
I constantly get PW in D9, but I use it for deacking 70% of the time. A5 pretty much the same when I get ENY.

I don’t fly the 38 nearly as much as I used to, certainly would not use it to deack, it’s too big of a target against too many guns.

Every plane has its high points and flaws.

I’m just guessing, if hit squares are actually used, one for PW another for head strikes. They wouldn’t be the same size but also maybe layered. Maybe hit cubes or spheres or all 3.

I was never part of plane modeling. I just did damage model settings with what I had to work with in AW.



Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: caldera on August 01, 2026, 10:01:15 PM
Was trying to dodge a bunch of gangtards by flying through base ack, right as the base changed hands.
The turncoat ack gave me a pilot wound. 
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Vulcan on August 10, 2026, 06:52:42 PM
Yak-9T : indestructible 37mm cannon
P-39Q: 37mm cannon made of very thin glass

Isn't the 9T cannon surrounded by the engine, whereas the engine in the P-39 engine is behind the cockpit and thus the cannon is 'unprotected'?
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: Devil 505 on August 10, 2026, 07:22:11 PM
Isn't the 9T cannon surrounded by the engine, whereas the engine in the P-39 engine is behind the cockpit and thus the cannon is 'unprotected'?

Not quite surrounded. The breech was behind the engine with the barrel running between the cylinder heads.

(https://icm.com.ua/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/yak_9t_132_r9.jpg)

(https://i.postimg.cc/pd2TN0Kg/Yakovlev-Yak-9T-article-by-Russian-magazine-M-Hobby-Aug-2015-No-170-Pages-32-33.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/DSMFLPjg)
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: caldera on August 22, 2026, 02:40:21 PM
Got my 2nd pilot wound in the A-5 today.  So it is repeatable.  Sort of.

Would have had a hundred in the P-38 by now.
Title: Re: observations of the damage models
Post by: save on September 23, 2026, 07:56:16 AM
Wingtips on the A-series FW-190 seem to fall off easily, however you can even do some fighting with one wingtip blown off at higher speed. Incredibly I've landed the A5 and A8 with both wingtips blown off, using rudder to turn, never managed to do that in any other plane, but Im a FW-oholic, as my stats I ran showed.

Engine smoke is very common attacking bombers, even at 1k range with competent crew.

Caldera - Don't get me going about Yak3 damage model  :old: