General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: hitech on September 30, 2026, 11:45:23 AM
Title: Old conveyor argument
Post by: hitech on September 30, 2026, 11:45:23 AM
I was organizing old photos and came across this. (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=413174.0;attach=38521)
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on September 30, 2026, 11:48:05 AM
lol :aok
With a bunch of people making different arguments it's practically impossible to get everyone to agree on the nature of the question. Does the belt match the speed at which the wheel spins or the plane?
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: hitech on September 30, 2026, 01:54:36 PM
With a bunch of people making different arguments it's practically impossible to get everyone to agree on the nature of the question. Does the belt match the speed at which the wheel spins or the plane?
For the plane to not take off the belt has to constantly accelerate at the rate of the diagram I made. Basicly your using the wheel gaining momentum as it spins to hold it back.
HiTech
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on September 30, 2026, 02:42:35 PM
For the plane to not take off the belt has to constantly accelerate at the rate of the diagram I made. Basicly your using the wheel gaining momentum as it spins to hold it back.
HiTech
I understood. I participated in the argument long ago. Many could not understand the difference between the belt matching the plane's forward speed and the spinning speed of the wheel. Some of those who conceded the wheel speed argument could not understand angular momentum. There were really 3 or 4 different arguments interwoven.
If the belt matches the forward speed of the plane then it takes off easily. If the belt matches the spin speed of the wheel and can accelerate sufficiently (per your diagram) and infinitely then the plane can never move forward fast enough to take off.
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on September 30, 2026, 02:55:58 PM
Eskimo made a video showing how rearward force is applied to a wheel sitting on a belt sander. Using an elastic band as an axis for the wheel it moved backwards as the belt sander accelerated to speed. Once the sander was up to speed the wheel moved forward until the tension in the elastic axis was reduced. Speed 2 on the sander and the wheel moved rearward again until the belt had accelerated to speed 2. I think many understood but just enjoyed being contentious. ;)
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: CptTrips on September 30, 2026, 03:20:45 PM
I assume you have consulted the Oracle? https://chatgpt.com/share/6abd6e4a-8980-83e9-93b1-7370dec78970 (https://chatgpt.com/share/6abd6e4a-8980-83e9-93b1-7370dec78970)
Well, the Myth Busters dudes would just build one and try it. :rofl
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on September 30, 2026, 03:25:58 PM
I assume you have consulted the Oracle? https://chatgpt.com/share/6abd6e4a-8980-83e9-93b1-7370dec78970 (https://chatgpt.com/share/6abd6e4a-8980-83e9-93b1-7370dec78970)
Well, the Myth Busters dudes would just build one and try it. :rofl
Yeah, their belt matched the plane's speed, not the wheel's. Of course it was going to take off. There was at least a 60 mph difference between the belt speed and the speed of the wheel.
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: Randy1 on September 30, 2026, 04:04:57 PM
Thrust to start a plane rolling has little to do with your diagram outside of rolling restrictive forces induced by the tire under that weight.
Pushing a plane is one thing. Achieving lift conditions is a another.
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: horble on September 30, 2026, 04:41:29 PM
having flashbacks to this argument spilling over into every single thread on the WWII Online Off-topic subforum
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on September 30, 2026, 04:50:56 PM
In the first case, a plane on a belt that matches only the planes forward speed though the air, seems obvious to most that yes, the plane can takeoff. Some think the plane can't move forward with a belt going backwards at the same speed and, well, they're just wrong.
The belt matching the rotational speed of the wheels introduces a whole 'nother question and must be analyzed and particulars determined before an answer can be decided.
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKKuya on September 30, 2026, 05:11:14 PM
:headscratch:
How does Gilligan's bamboo bicycle apply? I really wat the castaways to leave the island by air.
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: Dadtallica on September 30, 2026, 05:12:29 PM
How about a sea plane going up a waterfall? :joystick:
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on September 30, 2026, 05:13:52 PM
Would that be similar to a sailboat tacking against the wind?
That always amazed me.
it makes sense when viewed as...
upwind, draws power from the wind and transfers it to the wheels. downwind, power from the wheels transfers to the rotor:
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on October 01, 2026, 03:10:06 PM
Title: Re: Old conveyor argument
Post by: AKIron on October 08, 2026, 08:49:11 AM
Could have used AI to illustrate in a "discussion" about atmosphere and a flat earth a while back. No dome needed. Gravity is a real thing and keeps the atmospheric pressure the same in this cylinder as that on the outside at various altitudes whether either end or both are closed or open.
Seal both ends and remove the cylinder far from the Earth and entropy equalizes the air pressure throughout the cylinder. Stand it upright back on the Earth and the pressure then changes to match that of the corresponding altitude outside the cylinder.