Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Mol on November 11, 2026, 12:36:58 PM

Title: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Mol on November 11, 2026, 12:36:58 PM
Here is an idea inspired by something I saw in another thread.

ENY aims to address the problem of numerical imbalance by creating an equal and opposite aircraft quality imbalance intended to even things out.

However, this seems problematic because it is natural to want victory to reflect the quality of the players and their tactical decisions, rather than simply their numbers or the performance of the aircraft available to them.

Currently, numerical superiority is compensated for by restricting aircraft choice, but the relative skill of the players has no weight in that balancing calculation. But what if we could put human skill and tactical decision-making back at the centre of things? Bear with me.

I saw someone suggest an alternative involving balancing all three sides by adding AI pilots so the number of pilots (human + AI) that are “In Flight” on all three sides was always equal.
Then what if that idea was combined with something similar to the way fleets already operate, allowing human players to direct the AI forces? So, rather than having AI pilots simply flying around independently, what if a human commander could decide how they were employed?

The command could be voluntary, with higher-ranked players able to assume control in much the same way as the existing fleet command system. You could even separate the command by allowing the player with the highest rank in each category to take control of fighters, bombers, and GVs separately, thus spreading control across skill sets. 
The commander could:
The commander would control the missions and objectives, not the individual combat activity of the AI pilots.

Human players could join these AI attacks, support them, use them as diversions, or simply conduct separate sorties of their own.

I think this is similar in principle to what already happens in the WWI: Western Front arena, although there humans join AI operations, whereas this idea involves AI supplementing human forces to correct a numerical imbalance.

The essential difference from ENY is that instead of attempting to compensate for numerical superiority by restricting aircraft performance, we would balance the available forces using AI pilots.

Initially, the system could simply aim to equalise the total number of active pilots (human + AI) on each side, the numbers of active pilots could be determined as it is in the ENY calculation.

Of course, equal numbers don't necessarily mean equal fighting strength. An AI pilot might be more or less effective than a human pilot, and that effectiveness might vary depending on the type of mission. However, that could be calibrated over time using combat results and other arena statistics, adjusting the AI capabilities and contribution to bring the effective fighting strength of the sides closer together.

Perfect balance would be unrealistic, but then ENY doesn't achieve perfect balance either.

Importantly, equalising the available forces would not prevent a country from achieving local numerical superiority by concentrating aircraft in one area. That would remain a tactical decision made by the human players, just as it is now.

Likewise, whether to attack, defend, or concentrate on capturing bases would remain a human decision. The AI would simply provide additional forces with which to carry out those decisions.

Some potential advantages of balancing the arena this way would be:
Of course, imbalances will still happen. They are the goal. local superiority is essential for success in many situations, but that should happen as the result of the quality of the human players, their planning, knowledge, and skills and not on which side currently has overwhelming numbers. 

The main objection I would anticipate is that most players prefer to fight other real people rather than AI.

That's a perfectly reasonable objection. After all, competing against other people is the major attraction of Aces High.

However, ask yourself which is worse: encountering some AI opponents, or being repeatedly ganged by an overwhelming numerically superior enemy, having your aircraft choices restricted, or finding yourself on a side with too few players to mount an effective operation?

The proportion of AI pilots would naturally depend on the population imbalance. When the sides are reasonably balanced, few or no AI pilots would be needed. When the imbalance is substantial, the weaker sides would receive proportionally more AI support.

The important point is that the AI would be supplementing human players, not replacing them. Human players would still decide where to fight, what to attack, what to defend, and how best to employ the forces available to them.

I also think this would be worth experimenting with rather than necessarily replacing ENY immediately. Start with simple AI fighter and bomber missions to balance the sides, evaluate the results, and calibrate the system from there.

Every idea involves a trade off or two. It’s a question of choosing your poison. The real question is what is the lesser evil?
In summary, we all want victory to reflect the quality of the players and their tactical decisions, rather than simply their numbers or the performance of the aircraft available to them. This idea puts more emphasis on the skills of the players and the quality of their actions and decisions.

However, it also introduces yet another contentious element with a new set of unknown factors, risks, potential annoyances and questions.

So perhaps, if it were to be tried, it could be done tentatively in a separate arena at limited times so players could try it out, find the wrinkles, see what they liked or disliked about it.

Does the idea have any potential? I don’t know, I don’t understand the game dynamics well enough to say, it just seemed like an idea that deserved some air time.

MoL
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: hitech on November 11, 2026, 12:40:34 PM
Quote
Every idea involves a trade off or two. It’s a question of choosing your poison. The real question is what is the lesser evil?

I believe I think you got it.

I don't have any objections to the idea.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Shane on November 11, 2026, 01:00:24 PM
Sounds a lot like advocating for... contestability.   :aok

 
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Banshee7 on November 11, 2026, 01:16:35 PM
 :aok
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: LilMak on November 11, 2026, 02:29:12 PM
I truly have a problem with AI even if it’s just a supplement to human players.

However, my opinions set aside, I do not object to trying new things. My major concerns for your proposal would mostly be unintended consequences. Like, what would be stopping players from simply switching to the numerical side and lambasting AI for hours? Also, if command is based on score (like fleets) the spying and griefing accusations will go through the roof. Also score. Should killing a AI be counted as much as killing a player? Should it even be counted at all? How can this be gamed by the players in some fashion we can’t predict?

More concerning than my personal AI issue is that this seems pretty complicated. Complicated leaves a lot of questions that will need to be addressed before and after implementation.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Dadtallica on November 11, 2026, 02:42:51 PM
Everyone will hate something.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: -gg- on November 11, 2026, 02:44:22 PM
I like the idea

Like LilMak, I was thinking some stuff might be exploitable - but I like this.

To me, I think Ai defenders for bases when numbers are low would be great. No more milkrunning undefended bases and rolling a map with zero opposition. And if you have offensive missions for Ai, then you could also have WAY more action on the map. With Ai defenders too - could create action all over the map.

Filling out the action on the map can only be a good thing.

There's a lot of potential in this.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Rubicon on November 11, 2026, 03:16:07 PM
I am conflicted with the idea of AI filling out the ranks.  For the most part, this is a PvP game and that is what attracts me to it.  Introducing AI in quantity means we are mixing PvP and PvE and I am not sure it would work.

If a 2 sided PvE environment was created that might be fun.  We could work together to destroy the AI hordes.  Ai planes could have different liveries - perhaps the bright red planes are the experten and will take a lot of skill to defeat where the blue ones are perhaps more fogiving.

Imagine 90 of us V 150 to 200 of them  :)
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: AKIron on November 11, 2026, 03:18:55 PM
Filling out the ranks with AI is better than having no one to fight in my expert opinion.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: -gg- on November 11, 2026, 03:19:26 PM
I was a little conflicted about Ai planes too, but I think with the numbers so low  this is a really positive thing. I think it will snowball into more real players staying logged in and engaged.

I could see numbers getting back into the 100s again.

And with the new film Ai editor. More eyes on the game

Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Animl-AW on November 11, 2026, 03:41:59 PM
Just another game now.

Sick of the AI pilot talk.

No more TRUE MMP

Might as well make it single player.

Instead of constant low number talk drivel, how about just getting more players, WHICH IS THE CORE OF THE PROBLEM. AI is a lazy band-aide crap

AI fad where everything is AI remnds me of crack cocaine, they never know when to stop
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Dadtallica on November 11, 2026, 03:49:27 PM
Just another game now.

Sick of the AI pilot talk.

No more TRUE MMP

Might as well make it single player.

Instead of constant low number talk drivel, how about just getting more players, WHICH IS THE CORE OF THE PROBLEM. AI is a lazy band-aide crap

AI fad where everything is AI remnds me of crack cocaine, they never know when to stop

I would like a singles player option. Maybe tour of duty is back on the table.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Animl-AW on November 11, 2026, 03:51:17 PM
I like the idea

Like LilMak, I was thinking some stuff might be exploitable - but I like this.

To me, I think Ai defenders for bases when numbers are low would be great. No more milkrunning undefended bases and rolling a map with zero opposition. And if you have offensive missions for Ai, then you could also have WAY more action on the map. With Ai defenders too - could create action all over the map.

Filling out the action on the map can only be a good thing.

There's a lot of potential in this.

Did it help dcs fight? No it just made more sterile fights. Boring people like boring stuff, makes things boring a norm.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Animl-AW on November 11, 2026, 03:52:06 PM
I would like a singles player option. Maybe tour of duty is back on the table.

I can go back to Half-Life and Doom. We going backwards and throwing in the white towel
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Dadtallica on November 11, 2026, 04:07:28 PM
I can go back to Half-Life and Doom. We going backwards and throwing in the white towel

I don’t understand how a single player campaign is detrimental? In fact that might even be a better way to get new people to learn quicker.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Eagler on November 11, 2026, 05:29:31 PM
If Animl-AW is against it we have to try it..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: hitech on November 11, 2026, 05:36:18 PM
Just another game now.

Sick of the AI pilot talk.

No more TRUE MMP

Might as well make it single player.

Instead of constant low number talk drivel, how about just getting more players, WHICH IS THE CORE OF THE PROBLEM. AI is a lazy band-aide crap

AI fad where everything is AI remnds me of crack cocaine, they never know when to stop

First, the flight AI isn’t new. It has always been in the game; we just never used it. The new AI connection adds one thing: the ability to plan flight paths and missions on the fly.

Second, who do you think Crew Chief is aimed at? Not existing players. Its main purpose is to bring in more subscribers. When we launched on Steam, about 30,000 people came to try the game, and only a handful stayed. Easing the way in for new players is the whole point of the AI integration.

More players is exactly what we are working on. Mol’s idea is not about replacing players; it is about giving the short side something to fly with until the numbers are there.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: LilMak on November 11, 2026, 09:39:57 PM
When we launched on Steam, about 30,000 people came to try the game, and only a handful stayed.

HiTech
More didn’t stay after the steam release because it was clearly a bait and switch. The game was advertised as free to play which is technically true if you wanted to fly by yourself. Two weeks is not nearly enough time to get someone into the game if they’re not familiar with sims. Heck, I came from AW and it took me quite a few minutes just to figure out how the runway spawns worked.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Wiley on November 12, 2026, 11:50:59 AM
More didn’t stay after the steam release because it was clearly a bait and switch. The game was advertised as free to play which is technically true if you wanted to fly by yourself. Two weeks is not nearly enough time to get someone into the game if they’re not familiar with sims. Heck, I came from AW and it took me quite a few minutes just to figure out how the runway spawns worked.

And it looks like the same mistake is going to be made with Epic.  Gamers have um... "an extremely well developed sense of fairness".  If you say F2P, then they find out the real game is a sub, they have a tendency to freak, versus telling them it's a subscription game off the hop.

Wiley.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: oTRALFZo on November 12, 2026, 12:53:33 PM
I have been advocating this for a while now but dont see why it is so touchy with some folks. We have AI implemented in the game with field ack/ship guns and even resupply so I don't see any issues as to why we could not us AI to balance out low numbers.

Not sure how we would use them for base defense, but I am thinking it would be nice to have several defensive cons to randomly fly around at least to be used as cannon fodder for when a hoard decides to come in.
We can have AI missions to strat factories and when one side is outnumbered, the more damage it does to their factories.

Just some ideas.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: -gg- on November 12, 2026, 01:01:32 PM
I have been advocating this for a while now but dont see why it is so touchy with some folks. We have AI implemented in the game with field ack/ship guns and even resupply so I don't see any issues as to why we could not us AI to balance out low numbers.

Not sure how we would use them for base defense, but I am thinking it would be nice to have several defensive cons to randomly fly around at least to be used as cannon fodder for when a hoard decides to come in.
We can have AI missions to strat factories and when one side is outnumbered, the more damage it does to their factories.

Just some ideas.


I think base defense would be a good place, along with the offensive bomber raids ( which give people targets).

Base defense with some Ai planes would be more realistic than just allowing two players to roll undefended bases all night or morning. Let some Ai planes and GVs get added to the mix to have some kind of fight for those bases.

Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: thndregg on November 12, 2026, 01:15:04 PM
Not sure what to think.

I only know (by the roster only) that on Tuesday night before Dickweeds squad night, I believe I observed a total of 53 Knits & Rooks combined, and 11 Bish.

I also observed that for most of my 2.5 to three hour B29 flight, there were only limited, short instances of Rooks and Knits developing any activity with each other according to map activity.

Most of the activity, if not very close to all activity was against the 11 Bish roster.

I did not factor in AFK/in flight, etc, etc, etc...

Not very analytical, but alas, there's my two taxed cents.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Banshee7 on November 12, 2026, 01:21:14 PM
I have been advocating this for a while now but dont see why it is so touchy with some folks. We have AI implemented in the game with field ack/ship guns and even resupply so I don't see any issues as to why we could not us AI to balance out low numbers.


Because it means no more rolling undefended bases   :devil :devil :devil
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Dadtallica on November 12, 2026, 01:25:01 PM
Every base should have auto puffy ack. At least one.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Wiley on November 12, 2026, 01:36:45 PM
I ran into an AI P51 yesterday a little while after the bombers did their thing.  I was defending a base against GVs mostly.  The biggest difference I saw was it engaged me to the death instead of one pass haul backside.

Still not quite sure how I feel about AI fighters.  A case could be made for either side.

Wiley.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Rubicon on November 12, 2026, 01:37:47 PM
I have been advocating this for a while now but dont see why it is so touchy with some folks. We have AI implemented in the game with field ack/ship guns and even resupply so I don't see any issues as to why we could not us AI to balance out low numbers.

I fly for the thrill of competing against other players.  I already hate getting killed by AI ack but I get the reason it is there.  AI planes - meh, may as well go play a single player game
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Animl-AW on November 12, 2026, 01:41:36 PM
First, the flight AI isn’t new. It has always been in the game; we just never used it. The new AI connection adds one thing: the ability to plan flight paths and missions on the fly.

Second, who do you think Crew Chief is aimed at? Not existing players. Its main purpose is to bring in more subscribers. When we launched on Steam, about 30,000 people came to try the game, and only a handful stayed. Easing the way in for new players is the whole point of the AI integration.

More players is exactly what we are working on. Mol’s idea is not about replacing players; it is about giving the short side something to fly with until the numbers are there.

HiTech

I assumed that. I know it’s not new. But if it were left up to some ya might as well make a single player. I hope the AI fanatics don’t ruin tradition with lobby overload.

I get the new player draw. However, a lot of old dogs who have flown almost no AI/Drone just will not accept AI fighters.. AI has been normalized and is now the answer to everything. A few here are obsessed like a junky with it, a toy they push on others. Aspirin, which aids a symptom but fixes nothing.

Certainly appreciate new player efforts, I just can’t get onboard with AI pilot/fighter. Oit’s like sacrilegious to me in MMP

<shrug>
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Spikes on November 12, 2026, 01:46:14 PM
More didn’t stay after the steam release because it was clearly a bait and switch. The game was advertised as free to play which is technically true if you wanted to fly by yourself.
I believe this was an unfortunate technicality by Steam when it was launched. HT addressed it at the time and said his hands were tied because technically the game is free to play.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: DmonSlyr on November 12, 2026, 04:00:06 PM
Im telling yall right now, people are going to complain like no tomorrow when they start getting ganged by AI. The Match play is a great example of that and how challening they can be in groups. Then you have all the different skill levels youd have to add, and what planes they'd be flying in. While bombers may be fine. It would completely change the scoring unless AI planes weren't calculated in scoring. I think there is a lot of variables youd have to consider. 
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: oTRALFZo on November 13, 2026, 06:23:11 AM
I fly for the thrill of competing against other players.  I already hate getting killed by AI ack but I get the reason it is there.  AI planes - meh, may as well go play a single player game
Nothing saying that there is any intention of replacing the real player. I think the prime purpose will go to help support the balance of numbers.

If you log on in the early AM, it is NOT unusual to see 27 vs 5 vs 2 on a typical day and it has not changed in years. ENY doesn't help these situations because half the time, the time the larger group usually rolls maps uncontested or molest a lone defender with 15 Jugs.  What I am hoping for is to get some sort of balance and enact some AI that can help counter those situations. I would hope that the more unbalanced the numbers are, the more AI can implemented until the numbers become somewhat even.

Im telling yall right now, people are going to complain like no tomorrow when they start getting ganged by AI. The Match play is a great example of that and how challening they can be in groups. Then you have all the different skill levels youd have to add, and what planes they'd be flying in. While bombers may be fine. It would completely change the scoring unless AI planes weren't calculated in scoring. I think there is a lot of variables youd have to consider. 

I highly doubt there will be ganging from AI LOL. like I mentioned above it should be used to help balance out numbers. Maybe even get rid of ENY but that would require heavy thinking.

I also highly doubt affecting scores would be an issue. I think it should be in the kill count and maybe get damage points (like you do when shooting a field ack)
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: DmonSlyr on November 13, 2026, 11:00:24 AM
Nothing saying that there is any intention of replacing the real player. I think the prime purpose will go to help support the balance of numbers.

If you log on in the early AM, it is NOT unusual to see 27 vs 5 vs 2 on a typical day and it has not changed in years. ENY doesn't help these situations because half the time, the time the larger group usually rolls maps uncontested or molest a lone defender with 15 Jugs.  What I am hoping for is to get some sort of balance and enact some AI that can help counter those situations. I would hope that the more unbalanced the numbers are, the more AI can implemented until the numbers become somewhat even.

I highly doubt there will be ganging from AI LOL. like I mentioned above it should be used to help balance out numbers. Maybe even get rid of ENY but that would require heavy thinking.

I also highly doubt affecting scores would be an issue. I think it should be in the kill count and maybe get damage points (like you do when shooting a field ack)

I get what you mean about the team embalance, but that is a gameplay issue. Feeding them AI will just help them get more kills. I dont understand why the bish have to ruin the gameplay for everyone and it is a problem, but war situations can be like that sometimes.

Oh there will be ganging. Have you played Match play? How do you code if an AI will engage you or not? How do you code for it to disingage? That can get pretty complicated. Does it vulch too? Idk, I just feel like there would be many unconsidered variables that you wouldn't realize until it was implemented and played in the game.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Wiley on November 13, 2026, 11:15:09 AM
If you log on in the early AM, it is NOT unusual to see 27 vs 5 vs 2 on a typical day and it has not changed in years. ENY doesn't help these situations because half the time, the time the larger group usually rolls maps uncontested or molest a lone defender with 15 Jugs.  What I am hoping for is to get some sort of balance and enact some AI that can help counter those situations. I would hope that the more unbalanced the numbers are, the more AI can implemented until the numbers become somewhat even.

That right there is why I think ENY is deeply ineffective.  There is practically no difference between getting molested by 15 jugs or 15 ponies.  You engage, you're going to die.

All it does is irk players.

Wiley.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: AKIron on November 13, 2026, 11:22:27 AM

Feeding them AI will just help them get more kills.


You're assuming AI will be an easy kill. Very possibly it will not.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: Wiley on November 13, 2026, 11:33:58 AM
You're assuming AI will be an easy kill. Very possibly it will not.

The one I was messing with the other day was decent, not stellar.  I'd expect once we get to know how it thinks it might get easier to kill, or if he ups its difficulty will manhandle people.  I think the main problem will be kind of like how AI bomber gunnery/ack works.  It's either trivial, or a death ray.  Very tricky I think to make it just decent.

Wiley.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: AKIron on November 13, 2026, 11:45:43 AM
I would expect its expertise could be adjustable and you may encounter different levels in a single fight.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: AKIron on November 13, 2026, 11:47:04 AM
AI pilots have come a long way since 1982.

Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: oTRALFZo on November 13, 2026, 12:54:41 PM
That right there is why I think ENY is deeply ineffective.  There is practically no difference between getting molested by 15 jugs or 15 ponies.  You engage, you're going to die.

All it does is irk players.

Wiley.
I have no issues with ENY when the numbers are imbalanced. Those times usually means I am flying lone wolf and I will always fly fighter mode and dont care what country I join.

I do have issues with ENY at prime time when the mass log offs creates a crappy ENY so drastically that its not worth flying crap planes with your squaddies. I would have much more fun and would not care if AI replaced the low side. I think with the recent numbers it may be a welcome sight.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: CAV on November 13, 2026, 04:06:09 PM

Big question I got is if AI is going to be a replacement To the ENY system.

Is the game going to launch AI missions independent of a human?

Or will a Human player be given control of them so he can make Tactical decisions based on the map situation? Build strike packages, Launch Fighters for cap, Etc etc etc.

And how will that person be determined, A roll of the dice?
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: AKIron on November 13, 2026, 04:30:33 PM

And how will that person be determined, A roll of the dice?


I wondered about that also. I might suggest a prompt to the person who has been online the longest in the current session. Offering them control. If they decline or don't respond within a couple of mins it goes to the next in line. Predefined AI sorties from which to choose. A Fighter sweep launched to the sector with the most enemy. A bomber mission to a contested enemy field. A fighter cap over a friendly field being attacked, etc.... Choose A, B, C, ....
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: CAV on November 13, 2026, 04:34:28 PM

That is similar to how it is done in WW2 online.

A window pops up and says you're the ranking Person for this attack. Do you accept command.
Title: Re: ENY an alternative maybe?
Post by: turt21 on November 13, 2026, 04:47:01 PM
I run mostly GV's since returning 3 mo ago. I was surprised one night that Wirbs were unavilable due to ENY. Really, seems a little too far.
                  SKTurt